Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Jim McDermottApril 08, 2009

IIn a recent meeting with Mexican government officials, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton attributed the growing violence in the country to aggressive druglords, and announced that the United States would stand "shoulder to shoulder" with Mexico against them. "The criminals and kingpins spreading violence,” she said, “are trying to corrode the foundations of law, order, friendship and trust between us that support our continent,"

Within Mexico, however, another picture of the violence is emerging, one that pits not the druglords but the federal government as the main cause.  In a recent interview with America, Fr. Luis Arriage Valenzuela, S.J., director of a human rights center in Mexico, reports an explosion in human rights abuses and violence stemming from the growing militarization of the country.  “When [Mexico’s President] Felipe Calderón Hinojosa started his administration in Dec 2006 he said his priority would be to combat drug dealers. And in that context, today the military goes out into the streets to fight. The problem is, they’re not trained  for civil encounters. Their mentality is war, to combat an enemy; they can’t differentiate between interactions with civilians and military encounters. As a result, ordinary civilians are having their human rights violated.”

In the last year, Valenzuela’s center has received hundreds of human rights abuse cases, including civilians who are harassed, arrested, assaulted or tortured by federal soldiers for protesting government policies, or just for being in the wrong place at the wrong time; and others who have been killed without explanation. 

Click here for the full interview. 

 

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
15 years 1 month ago
Don't forget the guns which are often purchased in the US and smuggled back over. If the drugs were legal in both countries, much of the violence would of course go away.
15 years 1 month ago
Please take fr. Arriaga's comments cum grano salis and with common sense: the Mexican state has no other tool but the army to fight the vicious, incredibly violent drug gangs. It is all very well to speak out against human rights abuses, and there is no doubt that some may be committed, but, pray, who would do the fighting if not the soldiers? Does anybody want Mexico to become a failed state? And, yes, those gangs are armed by our friendly gun-toting American neighbours and their inordinate passion for over-the-counter weapons. By the way, I live in Mexico.

The latest from america

Although the Catholics invented the practice of excommunication to deal with severe sins, other religious groups have also adopted it for their own purposes.
John Cogley was once called “the most prominent American Roman Catholic journalist of his generation.” The onetime executive editor of Commonweal also played a key role in the election of J.F.K.
James T. KeaneMay 07, 2024
Catholic life in the United States is deeply rooted in the reforms of the Second Vatican Council. But that might not mean what you think it means.
Stephen P. WhiteMay 07, 2024
A young female doctor in blue scrubs holds hands with an older female patient, both sitting on a couch. (iStock/BongkarnThanyakij)
Many professionals who care for strangers are not religious workers, but they play a pivotal role in reinforcing the imago Dei, the notion that all people are made in the image of God.
Don GrantMay 07, 2024