Vatican's Response to EU Crucifix Ruling: "Furious" or "No Comment"?

That all depends on what account you read.  If you believe the Daily Mail's account of the Vatican response to the EU ruling banning crucifixes from Italian classrooms (because they violate the "religious rights" of children) then the Vatican is "furious."  They are, to quote the piece, "said to be furious."  (They ascribe this to a "Vatican source.")  On that slim reed leans the story's headline: "Vatican Fury as EU Court Bans Crucifixes," which makes it sound like the pope was red-facedly screaming on the phone to the EU or stomping through the apostolic palace.  But not so fast.  The Associated Press story says that the official Vatican spokesperson, Frederico Lombardi, S.J., said that he wanted to read the ruling before he commented on it.  He is quoted further down in the Daily Mail story as well: "We will look closely at the judgement before making any decision."  Of course both stories could be accurate: Fr. Lombardi's quote is certainly accurate: officials must still read the text of the just-published ruling.  And the "Vatican source" could in fact be accurately describing the reaction of some officials in Rome.  But the use of "Vatican Fury" as a headline is rather misleading, if you ask me.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
James Lindsay
9 years 4 months ago
We need more details on this. I assume that the EU ruling applies only to secular school classrooms and not those operated by the Church. Of course, there was no such thing as a secular classroom in the former Papal Estates. We are happily rid of that era where the Church seeks to usurp democratic government in Italy. Of course, it would be another matter if the EU attempted to ban iconography in religious schools. That would (and should) provoke outrage.

Advertisement
Advertisement

The latest from america

Lay Catholics are ready to lend their expertise, leadership and prayers to heal the wounds inflicted on children and the church by abusers and the leaders who failed to stop them.
The EditorsMarch 22, 2019
Kickstarter is one of a small but growing number of entities, known as “benefit corporations” or “public benefit corporations,” that are ushering in a new approach to business.
Thomas More GarrettMarch 22, 2019
Magazines like America are not really the first draft of history. But from time to time, when the publishing planets align, we break news as well as analyze it.
Matt Malone, S.J.March 22, 2019
The health of U.S. democracy demands attention to its electoral mechanics. Both candidates and voters should prioritize improving elections.
The EditorsMarch 22, 2019