Remembering Dachau Differently

Ditch and fence, Dachau concentration camp

Today we celebrate the seventieth anniversary of the liberation of the concentration camp at Dachau, Germany. It is a great day to be sure, but sometimes I think we are commemorating the wrong event. Wouldn’t it make more sense to focus on the time, almost seven years earlier, when the camp became known for intimidating Jews? The liberation, by all accounts, came far too late for most inmates. But in 1938, when Jews—particularly Jewish men—were being carted off to Dachau in great numbers in the wake of the so-called “Kristallnacht,” or “Night of Broken Glass,” something might still have been done.

I visited Dachau for the first time with my students almost thirty years ago. At that time I was teaching German at a boys prep school in Jersey City, NJ. It may be an unfair generalization, but in my experience boys are simply much more likely to exhibit a sometimes baffling degree of “war buff “enthusiasm. At least mine did. I constantly got questions from them about the (to me) arcane differences between the Nazi elite police squads—such as the SD, SA, SS, Gestapo, etc. To be honest, I could never keep it all straight, which disappointed my students, who could tell me, with impressive levels of accuracy, exactly how many tank divisions Rommel led in North Africa, and how many sorties the Germans flew over Britain in a given war year.


Undeniably, they were interested in “history”; and I suppose we should be grateful for that. But they seemed much more excited about military strategy and personalities than about those larger moral questions of the war and the Holocaust. They found it all too exciting. My work seemed cut out for me.

So on our tour of Germany later that year, I decided to take them to Dachau. Let them see first-hand what happened, I thought. Well, the concentration camps don’t really tell their own story. The high point, if you can call it that, were the crematoria and gas chamber, which my students inevitably confused with Auschwitz. It was all they could talk about. It seems we were determined to see in Dachau the quintessential extermination camp, instead of the horrible concentration camp it mainly was—a large and dangerous political prison and forced labor camp that had opened already in 1933 when the Nazis came to power, but really only hit its stride in the wake of the Kristallnacht incarcerations.

It didn’t really surprise me that my boys went right for the high drama. It seemed that it was my job, though, to get them to see that there was plenty of “drama” in Dachau as it was. To see that a camp that had been used to enslave workers, conduct “medical experiments,” and to abuse and intimidate Jews into fleeing Germany (after leaving their wealth in country) was bad enough, and worthy of our attention. Yes, thousands died there, and some were indeed killed with cruel calculation: there was a special courtyard designated for summary executions. But the camp’s principal purpose was not to abet the genocide that would really only begin in earnest in 1941. Before the war had even begun, Dachau’s most notorious mission was to bully German Jews into “voluntary” emigration.

That evening, we ate a dinner of greasy roasted chicken at the “Wienerwald” located in the little town of Dachau itself. Oddly, that is what I remember most clearly: just the fact that there is a quaint little German town bearing the same name as the notorious camp. And that people live apparently ordinary lives here, much as they must have when those approximately 10,000 Jews rounded up in the November pogrom of 1938 were brought through this peaceful little village. What did those residents see? What did they think?

It is all fine and good to celebrate the liberation of Dachau. But why don’t we recall with at least as much interest the time when Dachau became Dachau? When it first swelled its prisoner ranks with German Jews who had suddenly been “disappeared” from neighborhoods all across Germany? You can debate endlessly about who know what (and how much) about the Holocaust per se—the genocide perpetrated largely in Poland and Eastern Europe. But virtually every German would have noticed the disappearance of his or her neighbors. Remembering that point in history—a juncture when resistance, protest and plain old civic courage were still conceivable—may be the far more important history lesson.

William Collins Donahue is the Bishop MacDermott Professor of German Studies, and Professor of Jewish Studies at Duke University.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
3 years 10 months ago
I studied in Munich in 1978-79 just after finishing college. I visited Dachau with my German Lutheran pastor (a woman!) and her friends at the end of that year. None of my German companions were old enough to have any memory of their country under the Nazis. Yet they felt a terrible burden in simply being German. Since I had--and still do-- a deep love for Germany, I both felt, and identified with, the tremendous guilt they expressed to me as we toured Dachau together. It was a beautiful Sunday afternoon in June but I'll never forget how chilling that experience was. One point that isn't made in William Donohue's thoughtful piece is that a number of the long term prisoners at Dachau were clergy and laymen--both Lutheran and Catholic-- who had, in some way, offered resistance to the Nazis. They were specifically sent to Dachau and housed together. I'm sure the intent was to limit the influence of prisoners with strong Christian beliefs, This strategy ultimately backfired, however. because it helped to produce a great fruit of our modern Catholic Church, namely the creation of the permanent diaconate. A group of Catholic laymen banded together at Dachau for mutual encouragement. Part of their inspiration was recalling the role of deacons in providing spiritual and material support for others within the early Church. Deeply concerned about the spiritual vacuum that had been created in German society through Nazi propaganda, this group began to discuss the idea of a new, modern diaconate within the Catholic Church. It was these men, along with two priests who was also incarcerated at Dachau, who first advocated for the reinstatement of the permanent diaconate. It took a number of years and the advent of Vatican II, but eventually their dream was realized. Let me end this post on a personal note...I became a Catholic twelve years ago and now lead RCIA at my parish. It was while doing research for a presentation on Church vocations that I learned this surprising history behind the return of deacons after Vatican II. I would never want to forget or minimize the horror that Dachau represents. At the same time, I'm comforted to know that something of long- lasting value came out of such terrible circumstances. God does indeed "write" in crooked lines!
Tim O'Leary
3 years 10 months ago
Thanks for your very personal comment, Catherin. Perhaps, you saw the movie "The Ninth Day" about a Catholic priest who was a prisoner in Dachau ( I read there were some 2500 priests imprisoned there for resistance against the Nazis.


The latest from america

Before long I had tears in my eyes—and not from the uneven grooves worn into the wood by pilgrims’ knees. Something about the physical discomfort helped me to focus on the much greater pain Jesus had felt on those same stairs.
Over against our human unreliability stand the rock-solid assurances of God.
The latest survey, conducted in January, found that 44 percent of white Catholics approve of President Trump’s job performance.
Today and everyday we are invited to pray with the psalmist.