Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Gerard O’ConnellJune 05, 2014
Pope Francis walks with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas during arrival ceremony at presidential palace in Bethlehem. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)

For the past half century political leaders on both sides of the Atlantic and in the Middle East, with varying levels of political will, have used an array of instruments in an effort to broker a lasting peace accord between Israelis and Palestinians. They have failed up to now, and that 66-year-old conflict continues.

On May 25, in Bethlehem, the birthplace of the Prince of Peace, Pope Francis introduced a whole new dimension into that search for peace: prayer.  Intervening as a moral and spiritual leader, not a political one, he sought to break the impasse and open new horizons for peace. For this reason, he invited the presidents of Israel and Palestine to join him in the Vatican to pray for peace in their lands. “I believe prayer is important, prayer can help,” he said on the plane back from Tel Aviv to Rome, while clarifying that his aim is not mediation.

He asked the Custodian of the Holy Land, Father Pierbattista Pizzaballa, O.F.M., to act as coordinator for the event that is scheduled to take place in the Vatican Gardens on Sunday evening, June 8.  

As he watched the American attempt to broker a peace accord fail, the Argentine pope felt in his heart that he had to do something to help these two peoples emerge from the deadly cycle of violence, retaliation, war and hatred. William Shomali, auxiliary bishop of the Latin Patriarchate in Jerusalem, told me “the idea” for the prayer initiative came to him during the celebration for the canonization of the two popes, and he then asked Rabbi Abraham Skorka to contact Peres, and the Palestinian Ambassador to the Holy See, Issa Kassisieh, to explore the possibility with Abbas.

Francis’ original idea was to hold this prayer-for-peace in the Holy Land during his visit there. The Notre Dame Center in Jerusalem was considered as a possible venue but had to be discarded for political reasons, as was Jericho. To overcome the political obstacles, the pope offered the Vatican as the venue, and this proved acceptable.   

Peres and Abbas will fly into Rome on Sunday, and join Pope Francis for the prayer session in the Vatican Gardens. The three leaders will be accompanied by their respective delegations, each with around 15 members. Full details are likely to be unveiled at the Vatican press conference, June 6.

Sources say Peres’s delegation is likely to include close advisors and probably three rabbis from Israel: Ratzon Arousi, Daniel Sperber and David Rosen. Abbas’s high level delegation includes Saeb Erekat (chief Palestinian negotiator), Nabil Aburdeneh, the former Minister for Religious Affairs, Mahmoud Habbash, the emeritus Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Michael Sabbah, Father Jamal Khader and Palestine’s Ambassador to the Holy See. Pope Francis will be joined by the Patriarch of Constantinople, Bartholomew I, and several of those who formed his entourage in the Holy Land trip, including Secretary of State Pietro Parolin, some Vatican cardinals, and his Jewish and Muslim friends from Buenos Aires: Skorka and Abboud.

This prayer-for-peace initiative has provoked various reactions and raised many questions, including how is it being perceived in Israel and Palestine, and what if any follow up can be envisaged. To answer some of these questions I contacted three people living in Jerusalem: Rabbi David Rosen, Father David Neuhaus, S.J., and Bishop Shomali. 

Rabbi Rosen, International Director of Interreligious Affairs of American Jewish Committee and advisor on Interfaith Relations to the Chief Rabbinate of Israel, warmly welcomed the prayer-for-peace invitation. “It’s great. And if it is not just an event in itself but the beginning of something, even better,” he said.

Although he said one cannot generalize about anything in Israel, Rosen claimed that “the majority response to the pope’s initiative might be described as ‘skeptically positive’!” But if there is no follow-up, he said, it will be seen only as “a reiteration of the pope’s goodwill,” and will have “no significant impact.” On the other hand, if it results in something concrete, such as the creation of “a permanent council of the local religious authorities (supported by international religious authorities/institutions) that could prepare a charter for interreligious coexistence in the Holy Land; a joint statement on Jerusalem; and serve as support for political peace-making," then it could have maximum impact, he stated.

Father Neuhaus, S.J., the Latin Patriarchate’s Vicar for Hebrew speaking Catholics in Israel, said Pope Francis “surprised us all” by “his determination to communicate his message and the freedom with which he managed to do that despite the attempts of everyone here to tie him down.” He explained that “an integral part” of that message was: “let God in! Make space for God. Not the word “God” which is instrumentalized, used and abused by each side to the multidimensional conflict. Rather, the real living God.”

He summarized Francis’ message in this way: “Can you see the horizon beyond the walls that have been erected due to the conflict?” He said the invitation “to come and pray. Yes, pray, not talk politics, not negotiate” was part of that message. 

That invitation “has been greeted by confusion, amazement and a little bit of mockery,” Neuhaus added, because Peres is at the end of his mandate, and many in Israel believe that the initiative will be used “in a cheaply political way.”  He explained that “cheap politics, the politics that uses religion, is common here,” and “few believe that the political dimension is not again using the religious dimension. Few seem capable of understanding that perhaps the religious dimension can free up the political dimension and open up vision.”

He thinks the initiative “can only impact those in Israel who are willing to try to see and hear.” At the same time, he admitted that “it is difficult to predict what impact the image might have but it is important that this is going to take place at a time when tension is increasing and the walls blocking any horizon of possibility are higher than ever.”

Father Neuhaus is convinced that “the least that can come out of this encounter is that we as religious people and leaders might see the role of religion in the conflict,” in other words, the role religion can have “not in being mobilized by the conflict to sacralize the position of the side of the wall I live on,” but rather, “the power of religion to break open new resources of creativity and generosity.”

He said Francis “is clearly standing on the margins and crying out in a prophetic voice: Prepare the way of the Lord, but unfortunately, most religious leaders prefer to stand at the center, in the court of the king, and shout out: Prepare the way for my king, the one who pays my salary and the one whose war I bless.”

Bishop Shomali meets with Israelis and Palestinians on a daily basis, and is convinced that “Israelis are tired of war. They want peace. Israeli people, for sure, want peace. They would accept the international stand about two states.”

He believes that “praying together for peace may help Israelis” because “prayer is the best way to change the mind of a population, because praying is accepting God’s will. And God’s will in this case is peace”. Moreover, “the Lord is able to change the mind of leaders. Not all of them will change. Indeed, some of them will think that prayer is the funeral of the peace-process.”

In Palestine, he said, the pope’s initiative “has been received very positively, because the leaders as well as the people have a strong trust in Pope Francis. He is the highest moral authority in the world today as King Abdullah II said in Amman. Palestinians believe that too. Even if he doesn’t succeed completely in bringing peace, at least they know he is a reliable person and his stand can make a difference.”

“After the failure of the peace process under American mediation,” Shomali said, “Palestinian people are looking for someone who is fair, impartial, who can mediate in some way. For this reason also the invitation of Pope Francis was well accepted. They are very religious and they believe in the value of prayer; they believe that while this initiative maybe will not bring peace immediately, nevertheless they think it can lead to another step and to another step which finally will bring peace. They believe that justice and peace will come one day, but they don’t know when.”

Shomali believes that “if people of the world” can join the pope and the presidents of Israel and Palestine in praying for peace “then this will change something; at least the situation will not deteriorate. If it keeps us out of a third Intifada, then that is already a good fruit.”

At the same time he counseled patience: “one probably shouldn’t expect immediate fruits because an olive tree produces olives after five years, so maybe the prayer of today will bring us peace within six or seven years. It is never late. But praying today is a must.”

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Beth Cioffoletti
9 years 9 months ago
This is a very well rounded and well written article, weaving together the different perspectives of how the different factions are viewing Francis' proposal of prayer. If anyone can pull this off, Francis can. Probably precisely because he is so steeped in prayer himself. On a Saturday in early September (2013) I watched Francis (live streamed on my computer) as he prayed before the icon of the Salus Populi Romani. He was praying for peace in Syria. For hours he sat before this holy icon, reciting the rosary and then silent for long periods of time. I had never seen anything like it before in my life. Live. I was mesmerized. (As it turns out I was in Rome for Holy Week and Easter this year and one of the first things I did there was to visit the Basilica of Maria Maggiore so that I could see the Salus Populi Romani for myself.) Francis says: “let God in! Make space for God. Not the word “God” which is instrumentalized, used and abused by each side to the multidimensional conflict. Rather, the real living God.” My gosh. Who can doubt that anything is possible. Even peace in the Middle East.
9 years 9 months ago
Watching this prayer initiative live I could not help but think that of the 3 sides present Israel has been the most criminal of the offenders of God's will in Palestine. There is no peace in the Middle East because Israel was in the first instance created illegally and for 66 years has violated international law and created its state by trampling on the rights of the Palestinians. For this prayer intitiative to be a success Israel and Israeli leaders need a full conversion by the Holy Spirit and the Spirit of the mericful Christ, backed by a strong military power to enforce compliance with international law. Israel is by a thousand times or more the greatest violator of God's will in the region. The sides Israel/Palestinian state are grossly unbalanced in terms of power and military might. Until the US withdraws its unconditional support of Israel and forces it to withdraw to pre-1967 War boundaries and probably beyond there can be no peace because this violation of the pre 1967 war boundaries is grossly criminal under any interpretation of international law. Israel has been the neighbor most filled with hate. It has created walls around a self created hell and bombed the living daylights out of the Palestinian ghettoes. Watching this peace intitiative it looked as if Peres' soul was the most in agony. The Israelis know what they have done and until they repent there will be no peace. But this repentenance, should it miraculously occur, after this prayer initiative MUST BE FOLLOWED with MILITARY FORCE to ensure its continuance. This is because the real intention of Israel is the annihilation of the Palestinian people and the annexation of all occupied territories into a greater Israel. This has already been done in part. The occupied territories have been exporting products as being "made in Israel" for years now. Israel is a parriah state, with massive nuclear weaponry. At the Pope's prayer initiative I had the distinct impression that the Pope really needed an exorcist to cleanse Israel of its demons. Israel's representatives looked like wolves in sheep's clothing to me. World military forces need to come together to have international law respected and the 1948 boundaries of Israel re-established. Why does anyone think that the world needs a Jewish state? The mere concept of such a thing is RACIST. A multi-ethnic Palestine where the original property holders's rights are respected is all that is needed for peace.

The latest from america

Pope Francis gives his blessing at the end of the recitation of the Angelus in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican Feb. 11, 2024. On March 3, he renewed his call for an immediate cease-fire in Gaza while while speaking to the crowd in St. Peter’s Square. (CNS photo/Lola Gomez)
At the noon prayer on Sunday, Pope Francis called for a cease-fire and for “the continuation of negotiations” to bring about the release of hostages taken by Hamas and the delivery of humanitarian aid to Gaza.
Gerard O’ConnellMarch 03, 2024
Thanks to Jack Serio’s direction and playwright Ruby Thomas’s script, “The Animal Kingdom” falls into the category of a difficult but necessary watch, and the questions we are left with inspire us to think more critically about our mental health and relationships.
Michael O’BrienMarch 01, 2024
A letter criticizing Pope Francis for promoting “ambiguities in matters of faith” and at the same time ruling the Catholic Church with an iron fist, is circulating in the Vatican.
In an exclusive interview with Gerard O’Connell, Archbishop Jorge Ignacio García Cuerva explains why his first three Masses in Buenos Aires were celebrated in a shanty town, prison and cemetery.
Gerard O’ConnellMarch 01, 2024