"This Is Our Church"

Over the past few decades, dioceses throughout the United States have been faced with tough decisions surrounding church closures. The factors behind such closures are often quite complex. In some instances, changing demographics have seen Catholics move from the inner-city to the suburbs. Even where the demographics have remained relatively stable, church attendance has sometimes sagged to levels at which parishes are no longer economically viable. The decline of vocations to the priesthood and religious life has thinned the pool of available ministers to attend the sacramental and pastoral needs of a parish. And, increasingly, the economic downturn and costs associated with clergy sexual abuse have wrought realignment of Catholic parishes.

These closures, no matter how well they are done, are painful processes. Ties to one's parish can be very strong, since they often include generations of baptisms, weddings, funerals, and the experience of ordinary parish life. The picture gets more complicated still when parochial schools are involved. As a result, attempts to close parishes and liquidate church assets are often met with anger and resistance.


Such is the case in the Archdiocese of Boston, where seven years ago Cardinal Sean O'Malley announced the closure of six churches in and around Boston. Parishioners, angered by the move, have staged ongoing vigils in several of the churches since 2004. This week, the Boston Globe ran the story of several of these parishes. Though some of the vigils have ceased, others have continued ever since the initial closing. That is almost 2,500 days of prayer sit-ins, manned by rotating members of the parish. Though Mass is no longer held in the churches, they come together to hold prayer services. Somewhat paradoxically, the closure has had the impact of forging communal ties:

“I think some of us used to sit in the same side of the church,’’ [one vigil attendee] said. “But we didn’t all know each other until all this began.’’

The parishioner leading the protest, in words surely common wherever a parish is closed, said: "This is our church", and "We're still here, and we're not going anywhere." 

At least in the short term, this appears to be the case. This week, Cardinal O'Malley is expected to issue a decree de-classifying the buildings as religious structures, a move which opens the door for the assets of these former parishes to be sold. The vigil-holding parishioners are expected to appeal the decision to the Vatican, and the churches cannot be liquidated until the appeal is resolved -- an outcome that may take another few years. In other dioceses, parishioners have won such appeals, though the outcome is far from certain. (And, in related news, the Vatican last week announced a "visitation" of the Diocese of Cleveland, aimed in part at probing the proposed closure of some fifty churches in the diocese.)

The reaction from the Archdiocese of Boston to the vigils has also been noteworthy. Their official spokesman, Terrence Donilon, remarked that although archdiocese did not want to "drag people out,"

"There are no ifs, ands, or buts about it. It’s time to move on.’’  Donilon continued that, “Some of these churches are saying they don’t even need a priest to be connected to the archdiocese,’’ [but] “that’s not how the Catholic Church works, and these people are not living the full Catholic experience.’’

Bracketing the merits of Donilon's assertions about the "full Catholic experience" and a parish's tie to a diocese running through a priest, his comments raise an important question -- and not just for Boston.  Given that parish closures seem set to continue in many different places, and given the dearth of people to staff them, what will future Catholic parish life in the United States look like?   

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
ed gleason
6 years 10 months ago
'What will Catholic parish life look like?"...one word =  suburban

How will staffing be done? =Episcopal convert priests will fit right in 
Greg Bullough
6 years 10 months ago
''The decline of vocations to the priesthood...has thinned the pool of available ministers...''

There has been no decline in vocations, but rather a diversification that the Magisterium has refused to accept. There are plenty of married men with vocations, many of whom are both already ordained priests in good standing with the Church. There are plenty of women with vocations. The Magisterium would, however, rather import priests from foreign lands and cultures and close churches than forgo their society of bachelors or to lower the price of admission to something less than the one which they themselves paid.

Then, too, confronted with the freedom to marry, not a few of these men who ran away from the possibility of such committments and into the priesthood would be forced to confront their own fears, and yes, ambivalence about their feelings towards women. At the very least, the prospect of having to take their own medicine as regards marriage and family life must be a daunting prospect, indeed.

What is worst of all, though, is that the pool of available married men and women might be those pesky "Vatican II" throwbacks. On top of everything else they'd bring a realistic and pragmatic view of marriage and sexuality based upon experience and from women's viewpoints. That would shake the fantasy world inhabited by the current crop of JP2/B16 bishops and recently-ordained clerics.

Jim McCrea
6 years 10 months ago
Even with a formal connection to a diocesan-approved parish staffed by diocesan-approved ministers, many people are far from getting the "full Catholic experience" today!

Let's face the truth, folks:  mandatory celibacy is more important to the Grand Poobahs of this church than is the availability of the Eucharist. 

What lurks in their psyches to the point that they are so very fearful of married clergy?  How do they handle Eastern Rite married priests?  Married convert ministers?

Are they afraid to admit that they bought into a bill of goods and, by golly, if they had to sacrifice formal conjugal relations (I say formal because we all know that there is more than a bit of concubinage going on in this church on a world-wide basis), then these new guys have to, too!


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Chilean clerical sex abuse survivors Juan Carlos Cruz, James Hamilton and Jose Andres Murillo in Rome, May 2. The three met Pope Francis individually at the Vatican April 27-29. The Vatican announced on May 22 that a second group of abuse victims will visit the pope in June (CNS photo/Paul Haring).
The encounters will take place from June 1-3 at Santa Marta, the Vatican guesthouse where Francis lives.
Gerard O’ConnellMay 22, 2018
Pope Francis talks with Cardinal Sean P. O'Malley of Boston, president of the Pontifical Commission for the Protection of Minors, as they arrive for a meeting in the synod hall at the Vatican in this Feb. 13, 2015, file photo. (CNS photo/Paul Haring) 
Righteous call-outs should be patterned after Cardinal O’Malley’s rebuke of Pope Francis on sex abuse.
Simcha FisherMay 22, 2018
In May, my cousin Christina and her husband Tyler were murdered in their home.
John J. ConleyMay 22, 2018
Follow Father Arturo Sosa's first visit to the Jesuits in Canada!
America StaffMay 22, 2018