National Labor Relations Board seeks to reconcile religious freedom and labor rights

In a much-anticipated decision last week the National Labor Relations Board ruled on adjuncts’ right to organize at religious colleges and universities. Over the past few years adjunct instructors at several Catholic colleges and universities have filed for union representation elections. Georgetown, St. Michael’s, St. Mary’s and the University of St. Thomas have seen the elections proceed without incident. Others – such as Duquesne, Manhattan, St. Xavier, and Seattle – objected to the whole process, arguing that as religious institutions the First Amendment exempted them from the National Labor Relations Act. Regional NLRB offices retorted that the schools, which served students of all faiths and didn’t require religious instruction, were not sufficiently religious for the purpose of the law – creating an unfortunate echo of the Affordable Care Act contretemps over contraception at Catholic hospitals.

Religious schools (Catholic and otherwise) appealed the decision to the head NLRB office in Washington DC. In Pacific Lutheran the Board gave its answer, an attempt to reconcile the religious freedom of denominational universities without unjustly abridging the rights of their employees. The Board deliberately renounced authority to determine if a college or university had a “substantial religious character” and generally expressed considerable deference to any institution that “holds itself out” as a religious institution. But workers, including faculty, do not automatically forfeit all their rights when they accept employment at a religious institution: only if the University “holds out” publicly that the faculty perform a religious function in furtherance of the religious mission will they be ineligible for these protections. The Board stated:


We rely on the institution’s own statements about whether its teachers are obligated to perform a religious function, without questioning the institution’s good faith or otherwise second-guessing those statements. If the evidence shows that faculty members are required to serve a religious function, such as integrating the institution’s religious teachings into coursework, serving as religious advisors to students, propagating religious tenets, or engaging in religious indoctrination or religious training, we will decline jurisdiction. [Pacific Lutheran University and Service Employees International Union, Local 925, Petitioner. Case 19–RC–102521]

The long march of this litigation may not be over; either party may appeal the decision to the courts. However, the Board has made a considerable effort here to vindicate the just demands of both the universities and their adjunct faculty. Let us pray that the two sides use the opportunity to build employment relations premised on collaboration and mutual respect.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Ernest Martinson
2 years 10 months ago
I would go further than arguing the First Amendment exempts religious institutions from the National Labor Relations Act. I would offer that the constitutionality of the NLRA should be revisited. In attempting to equalize the bargaining power between employer and employee, the freedom of both employer and individual employees has been compromised. There are means to balance the bargaining power that empowers the worker rather than collectives such as unions and government. The role of government in the economy, environment, and equity needs to be radically debated.
David Smith
2 years 10 months ago
Indeed. That government should always have the final word in every dispute is not healthy in a culture that values - that proclaims - the freedom of the individual to stand apart from the crowd. This is especially true in a majoritarian democracy like ours, in which one crowd is effectively given the power to rule every four years.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Activists with Planned Parenthood demonstrate in support of a pregnant 17-year-old being held in a Texas facility for unaccompanied immigrant children to obtain an abortion, outside of the Department of Health and Human Services in Washington, Friday, Oct. 20, 2017.
Texas bishops: "No one -- the government, private individuals or organizations -- should be forced to be complicit in abortion."
Catholic News ServiceOctober 23, 2017
It is time for the laity to speak out and act like true disciples of Christ in spreading the joy of the Gospel. 
Thomas J. ReeseOctober 23, 2017
Pope Francis speaks from the Vatican as he addresses Canadian youths in a video message that was included in a Salt and Light Television program on Oct. 22 (CNS photo/courtesy Holy See Press Office).
“The world, the church, are in need of courageous young people, who are not cowed in the face of difficulties," the pope said.
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 23, 2017
Men walk near destroyed buildings as thousands of Somalis gathered to pray at the site of the country's deadliest attack and to mourn hundreds of victims at the site of the attack in Mogadishu, Somalia, on Oct. 20. (AP Photo/Farah Abdi Warsameh)
Mogadishu was rocked to its core on Oct. 14 by a truck bombing that left 358 dead and hundreds wounded. The missing are still being sifted for among the scorched rubble.
Kevin ClarkeOctober 23, 2017