Click here if you don’t see subscription options
John Roselle, S.J.February 26, 2013
CNS photo/L'Osservatore Romano via Reuters


“I only wish I had more to give,” an elderly Jesuit said at a community meeting a few days before he left for the infirmary. One can imagine Pope Benedict having the same sentiments during his last days in office. Joseph Ratzinger’s time as the Holy Father has come to an end; he is utterly spent. Yet he will always be heroic to me. I do not say this is in a saccharine manner, nor do I expect that everyone have the same impression. Few would have guessed that the little old man (I mean that with all respect and affection) elected eight years ago would live up to such a claim. He surely did not either, seeming to choose deliberately the name of a pope who had already faded into history but who had done what he could for peace in the last century. Upon assuming Peter’s chair, Pope Benedict XVI told us that we as God’s people would have to accept what Joseph Ratzinger knew he was all along: “a simple, humble laborer in the vineyard of the Lord.” At the announcement of his stepping down, he requested “pardon” for his “defects.”

Our popular culture reverberates with an expressed desire for the heroic, as evidenced by the endless string of messianic politicians, glorified athletes and blockbusters featuring superheroes. A superhero Pope Benedict was not, for such do not exist. However, he relentlessly pointed to the real Messiah. In his fidelity, Pope Benedict possessed the essence of Christian heroism: humble, loving sacrifice in the service of Jesus Christ and His people. Whether as a priest, professor, peritus, protector of Christian doctrine or pope, Ratzinger’s learned ministry was marked with magnanimity and desire for what St. Ignatius called the magis, “the more” that is conducive to God’s will. A man known for dialogue and goodwill throughout his life, he showed that these are not soft or flabby qualities but rather strong virtues. They empowered him to contend against what he named “the dictatorship of relativism,” while he spoke with such credibility that a figure like Prime Minister David Cameron of the United Kingdom said that Benedict had caused his country to “sit up and think.” 

As we review his life, these virtues were not simply the grace given for the office. They were hard-won and lived for decades before he became pope. As a scholar, Joseph Ratzinger was known for patience, understanding, and openness. In a gesture of a longtime friendship, he promptly invited his theological challenger Hans Küng to the Vatican. He called the Society of Jesus to the “frontiers” and affirmed to the Jesuits assembled at the 35th General Congregation on February 21, 2008: “the Church needs you, relies on you and continues to turn to you with trust, particularly to reach those physical and spiritual places which others do not reach or have difficulty reaching.”  As I have replied to some who have denigrated the Jesuits as unfaithful, “Well, the Pope at least believes in us!” 

Ratzinger’s life was spent in pursuing and articulating the truth in all of its nuances. He dared to do what no other pope has ever done, letting himself be interviewed for the length of a book in Light of the World. After news of his candor broke, I recall a friend of mine who remarked on the “idiocy” of him commenting on condoms. The complicated ethical assessment as pope was congruent with who he was as a young professor, a man unafraid to speak the truth with love. Pope Benedict simply smiled when someone informed him that people would run roughshod with his remarks. A hero has a certain self-possession that does not allow the whims or ignorance of others to get the best of him. As one of my mentors has reminded me, in all of Ratzinger’s life there is practically no one who can say that he personally “lashed out” at them. With aplomb akin to “good Pope John,” he has guided the church with wisdom and sweetness. 

Ratzinger could have had reason to be prideful since (as St. Paul notes in 1 Corinthians 8:1) “knowledge puffs up,” but instead his life testifies to the reality that “love builds up.” Knowledge is power, both of which he possessed abundantly. He showed the heroic possibilities of power directed toward the good of the church. His meetings with abuse victims in various countries were particularly moving. One victim present at such a gathering in Malta reported the Pope “wept” there with them. 

Ratzinger’s relinquishment of the Petrine office is the consummation of his vocation as “servant of the servants of God.” It seems Pope Benedict’s baptismal name was aptly chosen. Joseph, the universal Protector of the Church, was a heroic figure entrusted with the Blessed Mother and God’s own Son. Yet Joseph’s heroism was hidden in history; his was a life of diminishment to the extent that Scripture does not even tell us what became of him. 

In the Spiritual Exercises, St. Ignatius sought to help people answer the “Call of the King,” to live under “the Standard of Christ” even to the point of rejection and to follow God’s Spirit that sends us to do everything for God’s greater glory. We would do well to contemplate the life of Joseph Ratzinger as we pray for him in his remaining life of prayer and penance. His was not the cool release of power, the act of a noble politician like the Roman dictator Cincinnatus. It is what Archbishop Gomez of Los Angeles calls “the act of a saint.” Joseph Ratzinger is proceeding in obedience to the One who was nailed to a tree, accepting with and in Him a strange humiliation. Surely he recalls that the first Bishop of Rome was publicly hung upside-down. Many have suggested that Pope Benedict’s was a failed mission. The circumstances of his time in the papacy were not ideal; many goals eluded him. Yet let us remember another Man who at the end of his life was judged a failure. And no servant is greater than his Master. 

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
David Pasinski
10 years 7 months ago
I imagine that a tribute like this is a counterpoint to the many less generous assessments in both religious and secular press. As with anyone, is there an "...and" that is at least as equally relevant. the Bard on Caesar's death is yet true, but personal piety is not an adequate rebuttal to so much harm that may not have been vincible, but nevertheless was done in this Pontificate.
Thomas Piatak
10 years 7 months ago
A very nice piece.
Bruce Snowden
10 years 7 months ago
I agree entirely with Jesuit Priest John Roselle that Pope Benedict XVI was humble and heroic, an example beneficial to the whole Church. May his retirement be prayerfully peaceful, spent in quiet solitude, offering his personal dark night of the soul, the (his) Papacy, to Christ for the Church. I hope the new Pope will be a younger man, acknowledged by the Men in Red to be “the one” through the gentle coo of the Spirit Dove, black feathered! May he be successful in cleaning-up scandals in the Church, which in initial form began long ago with denial and betrayal on “ the night before he died” extending all the way back to the plenteously graced First Parents of the First Family of God , Adam and Eve who prefigured the Church, we the People of God, all sharers in the denial and betrayal of Eden’s folly, in some way or the other! God bless the new Pope! God bless the Church!
Adam Mescher
10 years 7 months ago
I appreciated the attention you gave to Pope Benedict's obedience, humility and gentleness. These qualities are rare to find in someone as knowledgeable as him. Thank you! And blessings to our church during this critical time of discernment.
Joseph Bogdanowicz
10 years 7 months ago
Bravo! Excellent article!! Mr. John Roselle, SJ brought to the fore the deep GOODNESS of Pope Benedict XVI! His interplay between Ratzinger's accomplishments before the Papacy as well as his courageous contributions in the Vatican were well woven into the wisdom of St. Ignatius' "Spiritual Exercises". Thank you, Mr. Roselle, SJ for such an insightful essay on this holy man whose leadership many of us are already missing! For certain, we will follow in his stead!
Josie Lomasney
10 years 7 months ago
Beautiful article! I agree with everything you wrote. Pope Benedict, and all of us, need to emulate Christ's humility and love, especially when the world tells us that those Christ-like qualities are not desirable! Love you Papa!
Maria Bete
10 years 7 months ago
What a beautiful article! I love the symbolism of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI as a true Christian hero. There is a lot of media right now doing its best to discredit him and the Church, and it is a beautiful change to have an article that poignantly depicts the holy man he is.
Josie Lomasney
10 years 7 months ago
Agreed, Maria!
Meg Mansfield
10 years 7 months ago
". . .he has guided the church with wisdom and sweetness." How perfectly this statement epitomizes the papacy of our beloved Benedict XVI, who imparted his great learning to the world with such humility and gentleness! What a wonderful article!!
Jennifer Earle
10 years 7 months ago
Great article! I really liked how Benedict XVI was shown as having great knowledge. His knowledge was always rooted in great love. He loved everyone so much no matter where they came from. "His meetings with abuse victims in various countries were particularly moving. One victim present at such a gathering in Malta reported the Pope “wept” there with them." Beautiful! Love you Benedict :)
Katherine Correa
10 years 7 months ago
Indeed, Pope Benedict XVI will be forever known as the unafraid Pope-scholar. This article highlights the Holy Father's unique devotion to truth, however unpopular: as written above, "He was as a young professor, a man unafraid to speak the truth with love." During his papacy, Benedict XVI specifically targeted two serious issues in the Church - relativist youth and experimental Church musicians. To the youth, gathered in 2008 at Dunwoodie Seminary of St. Joseph in New York, he said that relativism is a growing malady that must be stopped by this generation; it is no longer satisfactory to relax our morals and say that "whatever is good for me is good for you." To the Church musicians, who misguidedly brought rock n' roll music to youth Masses, Benedict XVI stood firm and defended the sacred solemnity of Mass. The youth loved him as a pillar of truth on these matters, in a world where lies and permissiveness abound and destroy our identity as young Catholics. Pope Benedict XVI always stood for what was right, even when an increasingly materialistic society criticized him for it.
Sofia Vietas
10 years 6 months ago
I love this article! It's so beautiful how God works to guide the Church to serve the needs of the faithful. Pope Benedict's resignation shows no failures, only strength in following the will of God. And we are given such an awesome example in holiness to follow!
Fernando Diaz del Castillo Z.
10 years 6 months ago
Thank you John S.J. for this fair and beautiful article. Resignation of the Pope was a demonstration of his intelligence, humility and that he did´t love power. It was good this article by a Jesuit. The Pope believed in you, yet not all Jesuits believed in Him.

The latest from america

To reach Catholics in the pews—and to influence public policy on immigration—church leaders should make it clear that they are not advocating for “open borders.”
J. Kevin ApplebySeptember 26, 2023
A Reflection for the Tuesday of the Twenty-fifth Week in Ordinary Time, by Ashley McKinless
Ashley McKinlessSeptember 26, 2023
In a self-described follow-up to his encyclical “Laudato Si,” Pope Francis plans to release a new environmental document to assess what has happened since 2015 and what more needs to be done.
OSV NewsSeptember 26, 2023
Migrants wait to be transferred from Lampedusa Island, Italy, on Sept. 15. Thousands of migrants and refugees have landed on the Italian island of Lampedusa this week after crossing the Mediterranean Sea on small unseaworthy boats from Tunisia, overwhelming local authorities and aid organizations. (AP Photo/Valeria Ferraro)
On his visit to Marseille last week, Pope Francis decried the “fanaticism of indifference” on the plight of migrants who risk their lives—and all too often lose them—in the attempt to reach Europe across the Mediterranean Sea.
Bridget RyderSeptember 25, 2023