The GOP's Big Problem

The GOP has a GOM (Grand Old Mess) on its hands. (Apologies to Gladstone.) The election for a new party chairman is exposing the fact that the party has no idea how to proceed after two straight election losses.

George W. Bush had become the boogeyman for the GOP. It was all his fault. This line of reasoning has the advantage that everyone agrees, albeit for different reasons. Conservatives say Bush betrayed his principles, encouraging the growth of big government and especially in his decision to ram through the Wall Street bailout last autumn. "Most of us strongly supported the Bush administration through the entire two terms," GOP delegate Curly Haugland told the Washington Post, "but in the last few months, this bailout and the abandonment of capitalism really kind of sealed it."


Abandonment of capitalism? Ah, there is nothing quite so bracing early in the morning as a true believer, someone who has convinced himself that maybe if there had been less regulation of Wall Street, and lower taxes of course, the economy would be doing gangbusters. After all, the invisible hand of the market works everything out for the best. Mr. Haugland should try telling that to the millions of Americans who have lost their jobs in the past few months.

The economic collapse of the past six months is the final repudiation of the idolatry of the market that is such a part of conservative lore, starting with Reagan and Thatcher. "Government isn’t the solution; government is the problem," Reagan famously proclaimed in his first inaugural address. But, to whom did Wall Street and Detroit turn when their capitalists ran their companies into the ground? The collapse of communism came about because the internal lies of the system made it hollow to the core; the collapse of the idolatry of the market also came about because the internal contradictions of the system became too great. The tide of unrestricted markets that Reagan initiated, that tide is now flowing back out to sea. Good riddance.

To paraphrase a famous first century rabbi, the economy is made for man, not man for the economy. This is a first principle of Catholic social teaching. And, its immediate corollary is that when the private sector fails to provide for the good of all in a society, the government must step in. In terms of the relationship of government to the economy, this first month of President Barack Obama’s term is becoming a profoundly Catholic moment.

So, let the true conservatives bewail their oh, so recent champion George W. Bush. Let them elect a true believer to the chairmanship of their party. The faithful remnant in the Congress all hail from the most conservative districts in the country, so they are unlikely to recognize that the Republicans must move to the center, not to the extremes, if they are going to return to power some day. They should be focused on their abysmal showing among young people and Latinos, but instead they are debating the purity of their economic litanies. Shame. Someone should tell them, to paraphrase Ronald Reagan, that the market is not the solution; the market is the problem.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
8 years 8 months ago
My first thought is to let them die. Their economic theories and their opportunism on abortion have doomed them. My second thought is to organize a more moderate versions of Republicanism, just in case the former Freshman Senator from Illinois does not do well. My third thought is the same as the first, let them die and create a third party to either run against the former Freshman Senator from Illinois (if he doesn't do well) and the inevitable Huckabee or Palin candidacy on the right. Of course, if Mr. Obama does well, no further action is required until 2016, as the GOP will likely further slide into irrelevance.
8 years 8 months ago
Is that some kind of record for hyperbolic phrases per sentence? Your emotion and bitterness at your political opposition shines through each over the top statement and provides a demonstration of why angry left publications like America are nearly unreadable by Catholics who don't believe in central planning. "In terms of the relationship of government to the economy, this first month of President Barack Obama’s term is becoming a profoundly Catholic moment." After all the pro-abortion stuff of Obama's first couple weeks, it's just breath-taking that any allegedly Catholic publication can make that statement in good faith.
8 years 8 months ago
Mr. Winters: This is not your typical closely reasoned commentary. To say that on the economy ''this first month of President Barack Obama's term is becoming a profoundly Catholic moment'' is hard to take. Are we Catholics supposed to accept his economic measures and overlook his unstinting support of abortion? He ordered the State Department and Agency for International Development to fund organizations that provide advice on abortion as a method of family planning. This makes the last week a ''profound'' loss for the value of life and truth.
8 years 8 months ago
It's sad that the pro-life leadership chose to align itself with the Republican party. The strategy was so flawed that it could only lead to the cycle that has developed: One Step Forward--Two Steps Back. We saw it a decade ago during the Clinton years and again now. What little was gained (even after six years of single party rule) will now be lost. Other than dividing the Catholic faithful, generating political diatribes from the pulpit and insults within the pews and blogosphere, we are no closer to outlawing abortion than we were 30 years ago.
8 years 8 months ago
It's all about abortion all the time.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

iStock photo
The majority of Americans now believe that “God is not a prerequisite for good values and morality.”
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 19, 2017
Workers march in Johannesburg, South Africa, on Sept. South Africa's biggest union group held marches nationwide to protest what it alleges is chronic corruption fueled by President Jacob Zuma and a prominent family of businessmen, reflecting public anger over a scandal that has ensnared several international companies. (AP Photo/Themba Hadebe)
The bishops “urge constitutional experts and the law reform commission to guide the nation on the feasibility of establishing an anti-corruption court, with specialized prosecutors, that would ensure speedy and efficient disposal of corruption cases and financial crimes.”
Russell Pollitt, S.J.October 19, 2017
“Goodbye, Christopher Robin” is a dramatic look at the life of the British writer A. A. Milne and his strained relationship with his son.
Haley StewartOctober 19, 2017
There are no epidurals for manuscripts.
Natalia Imperatori-LeeOctober 19, 2017