Click here if you don’t see subscription options
James Martin, S.J.July 13, 2009

Fr. Joseph Komonchak at Dotcommonweal has picked up the Vatican journalist Sandro Magister's interview on Chiesaexpressonline with Fr. Thomas Berg, a former Legionary of Christ, who is described in Magister's article as follows: Father Berg is "a member of the Legionaries of Christ since 1986, a priest since 2000, professor and confessor at the Legion seminary in Thornwood, New York, and very involved in formation activities. In April, he left the congregation, and asked to be incardinated into the archdiocese of New York. Archbishop Timothy Dolan made him a vicar of the parish of St. Columba in Hopewell Junction. Berg is also the director of the Westchester Institute for Ethics and the Human Person."

"In this interview," [Magister continues] "Fr. Berg explains in measured terms what is truly at stake, what are the strong and weak points of the congregation under investigation, what must be demolished and what rebuilt. He denounces the cult of personality that still surrounds the figure of Maciel. He criticizes the reasons why obedience to superiors often degenerates into blind submission. And he highlights the fundamental question: how it is possible that so many good things have come out of an institution that has been shown to be so full of flaws.  It is the first time that an authoritative member of the Legionaries of Christ, a member for many years, has spoken publicly and candidly about the crucial problems that have exploded in this congregation."   

Two of Fr. Berg's answers are especially blunt:

"Q: How would you suggest dealing with the centrality given to the writings, the person and the figure of the founder, Marcial Maciel?

A: I hope that the Legion will very quickly accelerate its disavowal of, and disassociation with, Fr. Maciel. On that point, I see no other way forward. All - and I mean all - the pictures of Maciel yet hanging in Legionary houses have to go. They have to stop referring to his writings in public (I understand that at one recent Legionary community mass the homilist still saw fit to quote from one of Maciel's letters). A simple step in that direction, by the way, requires the immediate abrogation of their custom of referring to Fr. Maciel as "nuestro padre" or "mon père" - terms of endearment whose use he allowed and fostered. Amazingly, many if not most Legionaries still insist on using the term."

"Q: What elements do you find more disturbing and in need of special attention from the visitors?

A: Just to name a couple. Why, for example, were approximately 25 Legionary priests convoked yet again - as groups are every year - to a two-month long "spiritual renewal" at the Legion's center for spirituality in Cotija, Michoacan Mexico, housed in the very house (now retreat center and museum) that Fr. Maciel grew up in? Why there? Why in Cotija? Why now?

Why, furthermore, has the Legion continued to engage in vocation work? Now? In these circumstances? It would be a very honest gesture for the Legion of Christ to simply call a halt to all vocational work at least for the duration of the canonical visitation, and even better until it finally gets its house in order.

And one of my deepest concerns is that current Legionary seminarians are not presently in a position to adequately discern what Christ is calling them to do. And this is because they are systematically deprived of the kind of information they not only have a right to know but a fundamental need to know: a complete presentation of the basic facts of Fr. Maciel's double life; the understanding that the religious life, with its norms and internal discipline, they have come to live is deeply problematic and in need of thorough scrutiny and review; a thorough presentation of the reasonable criticisms that have been leveled against the Legion and Regnum Christi; and an honest admission on the part of the major superiors of the Legion's errors. We should all find it deeply disturbing that most Legionary seminarians - and the same can be said of consecrated members of Regnum Christi - to this day live their daily lives largely unaware of most of these things, shielded as they are from virtually all negative information about the Legion and Regnum Christi. Consequently, they lack the requisite interior freedom to genuinely discern God's calling in their lives at present. This is something to which the visitors need to pay careful attention.

A much deeper issue, of course, is the question of the charism. I personally feel the need for the Church eventually - in some formal way - to reaffirm the validity of an institutional charism in the Legion of Christ and Regnum Christi. Regnum Christi members especially need to know from the highest Church authority whether there ever really was a genuine charism inspired by the Holy Spirit at work in the Legion and Regnum Christi, or whether what the Church has witnessed in the sixty-eight year phenomenon of the Legion was rather God simply drawing much good out of a primarily human and deeply flawed enterprise.

This question - whether there is a genuine institutional charism present here or not - is very serious and, as it presents itself in the case of the Legion, unprecedented in the history of the Church. I hope that the visitors will turn up useful information that will assist the Holy See in discerning the answer to that question.

Finally, I fear there may be more victims of Fr. Maciel out there. Their welfare has to become more clearly a palpable and obvious priority for the Legionary superiors. I am hopeful that the major superiors of the Legion who may be now have acquired much more information in this regard will be entirely forthcoming with the visitors."

The rest is here.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
13 years 6 months ago
I am truly glad that Fr. Berg has spoken up regarding this trying time for the Legion of Christ.  That said, I also want to convey my heartfelt sympathy and support to the priests of LC and the members of RC that I know.  I know them to be genuinely good people who exhibit God's love for us.
13 years 6 months ago
Father Thomas has voiced what we, Regnum Christi members, think too.  I know many LC priests agree with him also. Father Maciel's failures and betrayal is astounding.
I spoke with my parish priest, a friend, about it. He reminded me that there was a time I was in mortal sin and said I should not be judgmental. He added that there are Popes who fathered children too. He said with all that he has seen and experienced working for the Church, he would have left a long time ago if he did not believe it was of God. I guess the inner workings are not always pretty.
He said if the LC and RC are of God, there is no need to worry. It will reform and survive. If not, accept that some good came of it and move on. God can use anything and any situation to bring Him glory.
I have not read many of Father Maciel's writings. I never met him nor have I ever felt close to him or glorified him in any way. The RC spirituality is very basic and not really original. You pray everyday, frequent the sacraments often, do an examination of conscience at night, study the Bible and try to apply it to your life, get rid of vices, work on virtue. It's very basic stuff!
However, it helps to have a support group and a little bit of accountability. That is why my team meetings are so good for me. The words and examples of the women I know are so inspiring. I know the good I have seen and I know the good I have experienced.
I find it unique that in RC the people are really trying to live out every aspect of their faith and really try to help others come to know Jesus Christ. This is rare in today's society. I am especially amazed at the joyful openess to life I have witnessed. 
The LC priests have given up everything to serve the Church. Many of them entered the seminary at young ages. Some of them are living saints.
I am not a schoalr but do have a few technical questions:
How could the Vatican approve an order and lay Movement - and then, 68 years later say - oops - we made a mistake? Thousands of lives are involved in these organizations because of their approval and hearty endorsement over the years. It hurts and is humiliating to be caught up in this scandal.
Why did the Vatican clear Father Maciel of the molestation accusations TWICE before (once at the order's very foundation) and let Father Maciel continue his work with the LC if they had ANY RESERVATIONS about his innocence?
Isn't it very rare, psychologically, to be a gay and straight? Most people are attracted to one gender or the other, not both. Is it possible that Father Maciel had a one time slip up with a woman and erroneously covered it up in an effort to try and protect the others? Is it also possible that at the end of his life he confessed or told this to someone and, in doing so, raised questions about his integrity throughout his entire life and that is why the other charges are still out there?
Is it possible for the Pope to reform the order, give it his stamp of approval, and act as its "founder" instead of Father Maciel? Or, can we use Pope John Paul II? 
I've gone on long enough. Please keep praying that God's will be done with the LC and RC. I certainly will.

The latest from america

Pope Benedict XVI is accompanied by Cardinal George Pell of Sydney as he greets World Youth Day pilgrims at a welcoming ceremony at Barangaroo in Sydney, Australia, in this July 17, 2008, file photo. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Pope Benedict’s German biographer, Peter Seewald, confirmed that nine weeks before he died, Benedict revealed that insomnia was the “central motive” for his resignation.
Gerard O’ConnellJanuary 27, 2023
Russian recruits called up for military service walk along a platform before boarding a train in Omsk, Russia, on Nov. 27, 2022. (CNS photo/Alexey Malgavko, Reuters)
While representing Ukraine as an ice dancer in the Olympics, I made friends with many Russians. And I hope that one day my daughter can greet them in their own language.
Siobhan Heekin-CanedyJanuary 27, 2023
Should James Cameron have involved more Indigenous creatives in making a movie rooted in Native American history?
Kristin WestonJanuary 27, 2023
People supporting a citizenship law beat a Muslim man during clashes with those opposing the law in New Delhi Feb. 24, 2020. Christian leaders from different denominations in New Delhi condemned the communal violence. (CNS photo/Danish Siddiqui, Reuters) 
Seventy-five years after Gandhi’s death, when Hindu nationalism has risen to the highest echelons of the Indian government, his legacy in the nation he helped liberate is complex and, in some cases, denigrated.
Ryan Di CorpoJanuary 27, 2023