Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Kerry WeberMay 04, 2010

The New York Times offered some great coverage of the events and emotions surrounding the final days of St. Vincent's Hospital, which closed for good this past Friday. Staff gathered for a Mass and barbeque and offered each other support. And while many mourned the loss, they also remembered the good the hospital has done.

St. Vincent’s was inexorably defeated, [said Sister Miriam Kevin Phillips, known as Sister Kevin, a nurse and a nun with the Sisters of Charity,] by its devotion to the poor and by the transformation of the Village from a home for immigrants and the working class to a neighborhood filled with wealthy people who were drawn to more prestigious academic medical centers.

She had seen it with her own eyes, as a lifelong Village resident, and as a nurse and later senior vice president for mission at St. Vincent’s. “As the population changed, the type of patient who came into St. Vincent’s changed too,” Sister Kevin said.

The exodus of Village residents to other hospitals is backed up by State Health Department data, which show that before the closing, the 11 nearest zip codes accounted for only 37 percent of St. Vincent’s patients. When the Titanic sank, Sister Kevin said, the Sisters of Charity wired the rescue ship, the Carpathia, that St. Vincent’s ambulances would be waiting at the dock, but would take only passengers from steerage. They knew, she said, that the rich passengers would be taken care of.

Like almost everyone saying goodbye, Sister Kevin said that St. Vincent’s had shaped her life. Living on West 13th Street as a teenager, she admired the nurses in their crisp uniforms and determined to become one of them.

The Times also offered an audio slideshow containing some moving accounts from long-time staff members, who recalled their years of service at the hospital, as well as a second slideshow containing images of an artist's interpretation of St. Vincent's final days.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.

The latest from america

Pope Leo XIV is seen in a video interview with RAI Uno on June 19 at Vatican Radio’s transmission center at Santa Maria di Galeria outside of Rome, where he had made an impromptu visit. (CNS photo/screengrab from RAI Uno video)
Pope Leo XIV renewed his “appeal for peace” in an interview after a surprise visit to the Vatican Radio Center.
Gerard O’ConnellJune 20, 2025
There are so many things you can enjoy when you are poor—and some, it seems, that are easier to enjoy when you’re poor because you cannot lean on the crutches and the shortcuts that litter the path of the rich.
Simcha FisherJune 20, 2025
A picture taken from a fan magazine of Gene Roddenberry with actors from “Star Trek: Next Generation” (Pixura/Alamy)
Gene Roddenberry’s son said his father was an atheist. But documented evidence tells a different, more nuanced story about the creator of “Star Trek.”
Eric T. StylesJune 20, 2025
At the Vatican on Saturday, Pope Leo urged “reason and responsibility” amid rising tensions between Israel and Iran—just hours before lighting up the jumbotron at Chicago’s Rate Field, calling 30,000 faithful to be “beacons of hope.”
Inside the VaticanJune 19, 2025