Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Kevin ClarkeFebruary 04, 2010

Gaza might not be the only thing under siege in the Middle East. Israeli democracy has taken a fair number of hits recently. A Zionist student organization, Im Tirtzu, partly bankrolled by the Christian Dispensationalist-Zionist (and non-pal to Catholics) John Hagee, has issued an inflammatory report condemning independent Israeli human rights organizations (and the Israeli agency responsible for some of their funding) for their “unpatriotic” assistance to the United Nations. A U.N. special reporting team last year investigated the behavior of the Israel Defense Forces during the Gaza incursion that began in late December 2008. Three brutal weeks later, Gaza’s infrastructure was in ruins and 1,400 were dead. Last September the controversial Goldstone report, the outcome of that investigation, suggested both Hamas and the IDF had probably committed human rights violations and war crimes in that spasm of violence. Israeli human rights groups had provided testimony and other assistance to Goldstone and his investigators. Now Israeli politicians are calling for, not an independent investigation of Goldstone’s allegations, but a witch-hunt of the human rights organizations which assisted the UN in a clear attempt to silence their critical, and critically necessary, voice within Israel.

In recent weeks two well known Israeli human rights advocates have been arrested or detained and interrogated by Israeli police because of their activities, and 13 Israeli human rights organizations have sent an urgent letter to the president, the Knesset speaker and the prime minister, protesting an “increasing and systematic campaign against human rights organizations” in Israel.

This dangerous environment has been years in the making and is complemented by a rising hard-right sentiment within the Israeli government and its political parties, the too-powerful illegal settlers movement and a growing tolerance for religious extremism within the IDF rank and file. Taken as a whole the confluence of such potent culture shifts surely endangers what’s left of the peace process, continues a process of dehumanizing Palestinians and now finally, predictably, threatens the viability of Israel democracy itself. These trends require careful attention now before they unleash volatile forces that could prove impossible to contain in the future.

Kevin Clarke

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.

The latest from america

Father Robert Prevost’s early years in Peru shaped his ministry and vision for the church—but few know the brutal reality he encountered there in the 1980s and 1990s.
Inside the VaticanJuly 09, 2025
A Homily for the Fifteenth Sunday in Ordinary Time, by Father Terrance Klein
Terrance KleinJuly 09, 2025
A Palestinian man stands next to a burned car after an attack by Israeli settlers in Kafr Malik, in the Israeli-occupied West Bank, June 26, 2025. (OSV News photo/Ammar Awad, Reuters)
On July 7, settlers carried out a daytime arson attack on the Church of St. George and a Byzantine Christian cemetery. The fifth-century church is “one of the oldest and most venerated places of worship for Christians in Palestine.”
Kevin ClarkeJuly 09, 2025
Pope Leo XIV met with Ukrainian President Zelenskyy today and reaffirmed the Vatican's willingness to host peace talks between Russia and Ukraine.