Church in Italy faces wakening political monster

Simmering tensions between the Church and the Italian Right over immigration spilled out over the weekend after the Italian bishops joined UN criticism of the way international ships recently left 73 Africans on a raft to die of dehydration, ignoring their pleas for help. Only five survived.

The bishops connected that tragedy to abhorrent new Italian legislation passed by the right-wing Berlusconi government and its Northern League partner which makes unofficial immigration a criminal, rather than an administrative, offence. Why rescue criminals from the sea?


Rocco Buttiglione, president of the opposition Christian Democrat Union (UDC), and probably Europe's leading Catholic politician, has strongly criticized the new law, which, he says, "threatens people who would like to integrate into society and who are not criminals, pushing them into the clutches of the very criminals we are trying to combat." Archbishop Agostino Marchetto describes it as an "original sin in the legislation on migration".

Avvenire, the mass-circulation Italian daily owned by the Italian bishops, editorialised on Friday: "No policy of controlling immigration can justify the international community abandoning a boatload of shipwrecked immigrants to their deaths".  That was echoed by Archbishop Antonio Maria Veglio, president of the Pontifical Council for Migrants and Itinerant People. "Our so-called civilized societies have in reality developed an attitude of rejection of foreigners, resulting not only from ignorance but selfishness and refusal to share what one has with others," he told Vatican Radio. "Every migrant is a human person, who as such possesses fundamental and inalienable rights which must be respected by everyone and in every circumstance," he added, quoting Caritas in Veritate.

"Why doesn't the Vatican open its doors to them?" sneered Umberto Bossi, leader of the xenophobic (and powerful) Northern League over the weekend. The architect of the new immigration law passed on 8 August, Roberto Maroni, also belongs to the Northern League; Bossi was saying what the Government would have liked to.

This clash is almost an exact repeat of the row over draconian immigration laws this time last year between another mass-circulation Italian Catholic publication, Famiglia Cristiana, and the Berlusconi government, which I blogged on here.

Famiglia Cristiana last August compared the fingerprinting of Roma children in Italian Gypsy camps to the persecution of the Jews by the Nazis before and during the Second World War. Avvenire on Friday said the shunning of the migrants at sea was akin to ignoring the deportation of Jews during the second world war. "Then it was terror and totalitarianism which shut their eyes," it wrote. "Today it is quiet indifference, if not irritated distaste."

For anyone familiar with the scapegoat theories of Rene Girard, the analogy between Jews in pre-1940s Europe and undocumented migrants in today's Europe is compelling. And for those who know how Italy's politics have often been the trend-setters for the rest of Europe, the re-emergence of scapegoating as a tool of unification is a sinister development. Scapegoating -- the singling out of a minority, and blaming them for the ills of the moment -- is a powerful tool for uniting societies. A common tactic is to characterize an entire group of individuals according to the unethical or immoral conduct of a small number of individuals belonging to that group.

The Berlusconi government, under pressure from its Northern League partner, does this all the time, accusing undocumented migrants of being murderers and drug-traffickers, and trying to make illegal immigration synonymous with crime -- exploiting links in the popular imagination.

There are now even "citizen patrols" -- vigilantes -- to crack down on migrants, which the Government is using to calm people's fears on crime.

The Church sees where this is going, and is speaking out. They've seen this before, and they know where it can go. This is a wakening monster, and the Church will be judged in future generations by how energetically it sought to slay it.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
9 years 6 months ago
Austen Ivereigh - it is really sad to see such things happen such as people left on rafts to perish. I it unconscionable! Meanwhile, here in America hundreds of people   die in the desert migrating into the
State of Arizona from heat and thirst - not only that, but the US Government will bring charges against anyone trying to give medical aid or transport them or leave them water. 
This government policy makes it quite hard to help out, obviously.
Check this website:
9 years 6 months ago
To allow humans, made in the image of God, to perish because no one would help them is an unspeakable crime against them and humanity.  To take the theory of Rene Girard, a bit further, these Africans were sacrificial victims.  Not as in ancient religions to placate a transcendent, all-powerful god, but to a society of idolatrous humans who have taken charge of what is properly God's work.  This idolatry is manifest in widespread abortion, eugenics and euthanasia in the West.  What John Paul II called the culture of death. 
The irony is in the demographics.  Europe and America needs immigration as their "native" (read here, white) people are not producing enough children to maintain their way of life.  Italy has one of the lowest replacement rates in Europe.  America needs its immigrants as well.  John Stangle points out the scapegoat mechanism at work in this country.  When people are arrested for providing medical care and water to fellow human beings , we have reached a low point in America. 


The latest from america

“We need a permanent legislative solution for those who have spent their lives contributing and living in the United States, the country they know as home,” Bishop Joe S. Vásquez of Austin, Tex., and chairman of the U.S. Bishops Committee on Migration, said while endorsing the latest iteration of
J.D. Long-GarcíaMarch 19, 2019
Before long I had tears in my eyes—and not from the uneven grooves worn into the wood by pilgrims’ knees. Something about the physical discomfort helped me to focus on the much greater pain Jesus had felt on those same stairs.
Over against our human unreliability stand the rock-solid assurances of God.
The latest survey, conducted in January, found that 44 percent of white Catholics approve of President Trump’s job performance.