Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
James Martin, S.J.November 20, 2010

Some video to supplement Austen Ivereigh's reporting below, on the 24 new cardinals, including two Americans, Cardinal Donald Wuerl, archbishop of Washington, D.C., and Cardinal Raymond Burke, prefect of the Apostolic Signatura.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
14 years 8 months ago
The obvious preponderance of European votes in the next papal conclave triggers the thought of another related, interesting and rather current question:  the age of the voting cardinals as well as the pope's own age.
Cardinals reaching the age of 80 can no longer cast their vote in the election of a pope. The newly elected  pope, however, can continue to reign as pope even after reaching that now canonically critical age.

This appears strange and unfair:  which is easier, electing a pope, or being pope and govern the universal church?

If there is wisdom in the exclusion of the cardinals over 80 from a papal conclave, the same wisdom would suggest also the canonical retirement of the pope on his 80th birthday. 
Should such wisdom be questionable, let all cardinals continue to be valid papal electors as long as they live. If not, let even the pope canonically resign on reaching the age of 80.

When a pope is elected, all cardinals would know the exact date of the next conclave, namely the 80th birthday of the newly elected pope, barring of course the possible sudden death of even a young reigning pontiff.

Knowing in advance the exact date of the next papal election would greatly simplify for all cardinals their planning and scheduling of important meetings, retreats, anniversaries and necessary travel.

Cardinals would no longer be surprised by the sudden illness of an aging Holy Father or, worse perhaps, by his possible lingering incapacitated for weeks and even months as pope.
Five years ago, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, 78, and Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, 78, were the two closest papabili.  Today, Cardinal Ratzinger, 83, is pope, and Cardinal Martini, 83, is legally unable even to vote for a pope.  Videant consules... 
 

The latest from america

After an early morning attack on the Holy Family Church in Gaza, Pope Leo XIV called for an immediate ceasefire, dialogue and peace in the region.
Something essential is lost when generations remain siloed at church.
Juan MercedJuly 17, 2025
You’ve got a 401K. But do you have a spiritual retirement plan?
Myles N. SheehanJuly 17, 2025
Syrian security forces secure the area near St. Joseph Church in the Bab-Sharqi neighborhood of Damascus, Syria June 23, 2025, following the June 22 suicide bombing at Mar Elias Church. (OSV News photo/Firas Makdesi, Reuters)
A brief opening to shore up progress toward stability in Syria unfortunately coincides with Trump administration decisions to sharply curtail humanitarian and development assistance and to terminate the U.S. Agency for International Development.
Kevin ClarkeJuly 17, 2025