Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Matt Malone, S.J.February 26, 2008
Does anyone really think that it would have been better to have Richard Nixon rather than John Kennedy managing the Cuban Missile Crisis; or Stephen Douglas rather than Lincoln confronting the crisis of secession? Yet if the American people had made their choices for president in 1960 and 1860 based on which candidate had the most experience for the job, than an unstable Nixon might have had his finger on the button in those perilous thirteen days and a President Douglas would have invaded Mexico to keep the slave-holding south in the union. Senator Clinton keeps trumpeting her experience, that she is "ready on day one" to make decisions. But the real question is: who has demonstrated the kind of sound judgment required to make those decisions well? The Obama campaign claims that Clinton has shown poor judgment in everything from whether to go to war in Iraq to how much to spend on pizza for her under funded campaign. That charge may or may not be true or fair, but at least it addresses the right question. Most former presidents will tell you that there is no experience that adequately prepares you for the presidency, an utterly unique position in its power and scope. Obama may not be another Lincoln in terms of his statesmanship or even his judgment, but he has roughly the same experience: a few years in the Illinois Legislature and a short tenure in Congress. Lincoln’s leadership demonstrates that while experience does matter, judgment matters more. One could argue that Clinton has demonstrated better judgment than Obama admits or even better judgment than Obama himself and that therefore Clinton is the better choice. But Senator Clinton has not been fighting the battle on that field. It should, however, be familiar topography: the candidate with the best experience in the 1992 election was obviously George H.W. Bush. Surely Mrs. Clinton doesn’t think anyone should have voted for him. Matt Malone
Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.

The latest from america

In this interview, Cardinal Gracias speaks about the election of Leo XIV, his membership in Pope Francis’ council of cardinal advisors and why he considers Francis a saint.
Gerard O’ConnellMay 28, 2025
A Homily for the Solemnity of the Ascension, by Father Terrance Klein
Terrance KleinMay 28, 2025
Pope Leo XIV's offer to host peace talks between Russia and Ukraine was motivated by a conviction that the two sides must start negotiating and stop the killing, the Vatican secretary of state said.
Rev. Paul Nicholson, S.J., begins his homily for the Ascension with a striking image from Medieval art: Jesus’ feet dangling in the air, his body swallowed by clouds.
PreachMay 27, 2025