Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Moira WalshMay 08, 2013

By the time I saw The Great Gatsby, it had already opened, and at least some critical notices were suggesting that it was a "bomb." Perhaps it was my lack of expectations that caused me to be pleasantly surprised. Now I admit that Robert Redford, through no particular fault of his own, is all wrong in the title role. I don't know whether at best Jay Gatsby (born Gatz), the mysterious and probably crooked tycoon who was destroyed by his obsession with a flighty millionairess, could be made convincing for today's audiences. In any case the main point about F. Scott Fitzgerald's Gatsby was that he was an obsessed outsider, trying to buy his way into the circles of the rich and social. Redford has the misfortune to look as though he was born with a silver spoon in his mouth and educated at Harvard.

Otherwise, I had no serious quarrel with the film's conception. Forty years ago, Fitzgerald wrote a stark little contemporary fable. But today it is a period piece and the elaborate period trappings are necessary. (And besides, the film's decor, in the broadest sense, is breathtaking and in itself worth the price of admission.) The performances by such people as Mia Farrow, as the despicable heroine, Daisy, Bruce Dern as her loutish husband, and especially Sam Waterston as Nick, the narrator-onlooker, are surprisingly good. And despite the heavy trappings the story is still a grimly arresting cautionary tale. But I wonder if the film can possibly live up to the aura created in the public's mind by what may very well be the most elaborate and omnipresent promotional campaign in screen history.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.

The latest from america

President Donald Trump, center, surrounded by Speaker of the House Mike Johnson, R-La., and Rep. Lisa McClain, R-Mich., speaks to reporters before a House Republican conference meeting, Tuesday, May 20, 2025, at the U.S. Capitol in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson)
“These proposed changes threaten access to care for millions of Americans, particularly those in underserved areas, where our member systems work every day to provide quality, compassionate care.”
Kevin ClarkeMay 20, 2025
The Archdiocese of Chicago has scheduled a Mass and a special program to celebrate the election and inauguration of Pope Leo XIV, a native son of the Windy City.
The genre of the crime-solving priest or religious might be a niche one, but it's been around on the page and the screen for more than a century.
James T. KeaneMay 20, 2025
“I would suspect that people are very proud that Chicago produced a pope, and it testifies to the fact that there’s a lot of good here in the city that recommends itself to the church.”
Delaney CoyneMay 20, 2025