Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Kyle T. KramerJuly 02, 2012

A few weeks ago my wife called me with news that nearly stopped my heart. “Eli almost drowned,” she reported about our 5-year-old son.

Eli had been wading around the edge of our pond with his 8-year-old twin sisters, intent on pulling out weeds and skipping stones. My wife, Cyndi, chatted on a cordless phone a short distance away. In the blink of an eye (which is all it ever takes, of course), she looked over to see the girls, both strong swimmers, stroking halfway across the pond. Eli, not yet a strong swimmer, nonetheless had a mind to follow them, and in those same few moments he had gotten himself too far out from shore.

Cyndi, also not much of a swimmer, kicked off her shoes and sprinted over. She waded in fully clothed and managed to grab Eli just as his floundering failed and he slipped beneath the dark surface.

Initially, I was furious that the children had disobeyed Cyndi’s orders to stay on the shoreline—an anger I knew was fueled by my terror at what could have happened. But our crying, contrite children dissipated my rage; and for several days afterward, I stumbled around in a kind of dazed luminosity. Whenever our son flashed his wide, impish smile, I could vividly imagine us and the world bereft of that smile, and I could not hug him tightly enough. Whenever he cut loose with his ever-ready laugh, I could hear the terrible quiet of that laughter forever silenced. My gratitude that he was still among us grew deep and wide and tall, like a tree planted in full sun. I saw (and still see) with fresh clarity how fragile Eli’s life is—and in that very fragility, how precious.

Since Eli’s near-drowning, I have begun to discern the same pattern of fragility and preciousness everywhere I look, as if I finally learned a foreign language, and suddenly what had been gibberish to my ears became clear speech. I saw Cyndi’s and my marriage, strong and resilient after 10 years, yet always vulnerable to the unkind word, or a pattern of neglect and “creeping separateness.” I saw our farm, whose hay and trees and crops are in the flush of their spring vigor now, but which can be—and have been—grievously damaged by careless use.

I also see the pattern well beyond the close-at-hand circle of our household. Our nation’s hard-won and vital democracy seems on the brink of complete hijack by moneyed corporate interests and intransigent politicians. Our church, the earthen vessel called to embody Christ’s love in the world, is deeply and painfully divided, endangered as much by tribalism and a lack of charity within as by the “culture of death” without. Our planet’s thin living surface, suspended between lifeless rock below and lifeless void above, groans under our insatiable demands on its resources.

Everything of real worth is also vulnerable, from the life of a child to the health of the global commons. Failing to understand this, because of distraction or take-it-for-granted apathy, virtually ensures we will lose much that we ought and need to keep.

I have thought, naïvely, that the main task in healing our culture lay in helping people come to see the value and vulnerability of all we want to cultivate and preserve. But Eli’s close call reminded me that such an awakening, though crucial, is merely the first step.

Anger and fear were reflexive for me when we almost lost Eli, and my mind raced with ways to protect the precious, fragile life of our children. Should we bulldoze the pond, as my grandmother pointedly insisted when she was alive, or surround it with an electric fence, as my parents suggested? Keep the kids on leashes?

Perhaps a similar reaction undergirds the fundamentalisms of our day: we realize the fragility of what we hold dear but think the only way to protect it is with a clenched fist and binary thinking.

Fundamentalism is futile, however. What we are ultimately trying to protect is life itself—of children born and unborn, of a civic community, a church, a biosphere—and whenever we hold on to living things too tightly, we snuff them out, despite our best intentions.

There is a still more excellent way between apathy and angry fundamentalism. But it is a messy, mysterious, cruciform, paradoxical way: loving, but holding loosely; being grateful for all that is valuable and vulnerable, but giving it up into a much vaster safekeeping than our own.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
10 years 1 month ago
While I totally "get" the human element and understanding of the preciousness of life, especially when applying it to one's own family, I am at a crossroad as to how to apply that same understanding to the present state of our Church.  I don't want the "life" the current Church leaders are toting- the blind obedience, the misogyny, the clericalism- to invade my family or my faith life.  In fact, I am fighting tooth and nail to prevent it from snuffing out what God is calling me and my family to believe in and follow.
10 years 1 month ago

Great great piece. Thank you, Kyle. Perhaps, the best course to take is to keep quiet and listen until we can hear the little voice inside of us to not be afraid, because I will be with you always. Judging is so counterproductive that it just makes everything complicated and worse. We should accept the fact that we are all broken people and in need of Almighty God's divine mercy and love to sustain us in this life. We can change the current culture only by starting with ourselves. St Francis of Assissi is a great model to emulate: Lord, make me an instrument of your peace. Where there is hatred, let me sow love. Where there is injury, pardon. Where there is doubt, faith. Where there is despair, hope. Where there is darkness, light. Where there is sadness, joy.

O Divine Master, grant that I may not so much seek to be consoled, as to console. To be understood, as to understand. To be loved, as to love. For it is in giving that we receive. It is in pardoning that we are pardoned. It is in dying that we are born to eternal life.
Cody Serra
10 years 1 month ago
Great insight into life and living. Sometimes we need to be shocked in a personal way to think about what we value, how we protect it, how do we allow the other to grow and mature in God's freedom and love.

The balance of holding to and letting it go, is part of our journey of life and faith.
We need to keep learning and practicing it.
10 years 1 month ago
Excellent.  Thank you, Kyle, for your witness, in this article and your life.

And thank you Norma for reminding us of the prayer of  Francis of Assisi.

May the Lord send his light to shine upon us as her has sent the Sun to warm and nourish the earth.

May he be with us on our journey of life as he is and was and will be the Shepherd of the universe. 
10 years 1 month ago
The typo in the third line was inadvertant though possibly Freudian.  Please change her to he.  Old eyes and impatience got the better of me.

The latest from america

From 1989: The controversy surrounding 'The Satanic Mysteries' is a paradigm of the difficulties that have existed over the centuries between Islam and the West.
Elias D. MallonAugust 16, 2022
A Reflection for Tuesday of the Twentieth Week in Ordinary Time, by Patrick Cullinan
Patrick CullinanAugust 15, 2022
A listening session in Johannesburg. Photo courtesy of the Archdiocese of Johannesburg.
Bruce Botha, S.J., said one notable achievement of the synodal process was that many people who experienced themselves on the margins of the church felt that they were heard.
Russell Pollitt, S.J.August 15, 2022
Two women in habit look over a ledge at a large crowd of people holding flags
For five years, the government and church of Nicaragua have been at odds over protests and state corruption.