Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Christopher ParkerNovember 03, 2022
White sheep on green grass during day timePhoto from Unsplash.

A Reflection for Thursday of the Thirty-First Week in Ordinary TIme

By Christopher Parker

Find today’s readings here.

So Jesus addressed this parable to them.

“What man among you having a hundred sheep and losing one of them

would not leave the ninety-nine in the desert

and go after the lost one until he finds it?

And when he does find it,

he sets it on his shoulders with great joy

and, upon his arrival home,

he calls together his friends and neighbors and says to them,

‘Rejoice with me because I have found my lost sheep.’” (Luke 15:3-6)

What kind of sheep do you hope to be?

Depictions and descriptions of Jesus as the good shepherd must be one of the most common analogies in the Catholic Church. It is an image so inextricably knotted to the Catholic understanding of Jesus that we can easily stop engaging with it or thinking critically about it. The omnipresence of today’s Gospel story can hinder us from seeing anything new in it.

Believe me. I’m the one writing a reflection about it.

But as I sat at my desk, trying to think of something fresh to say about one of the most popular New Testament passages in history, I thought about the 99 sheep, the ones who remain in the desert. And I realized that I’ve been thinking about this passage the wrong way.

See, in my head, I’ve always envisioned 99 sheep crowded in a group where the shepherd left them, waiting patiently for the return of their protector. They were the righteous sheep. They had no need for saving. That’s what the story says. But knowing what I know about humans and our propensity for wrongdoing, I think my image was naïve and my understanding incomplete.

We can be sheep who stay a little longer in the spot where the shepherd left us. We can be sheep who stray a little less far from where we belong. And we can certainly be sheep who bleat loudly to be found.

Maybe they really did remain righteous sheep for a little while—before they grew envious of the attention paid to their flock-mate, or fearful of nocturnal predators in the darkening desert, or just bored with standing around. Then they, too, must have wandered off, and when the shepherd returned to his spot covered in sweat, with the itchiest shoulders ever, I bet he found maybe two or three sheep. Maximum.

That’s where the story really ends: The good shepherd sighs and wipes off his brow, heading back out for the Sisyphian task of trying to save creatures that cannot seem to stay saved. I’m sure some sheep wander back of their own accord, and others are seconds from death when the shepherd rescues them. All of them will wander again before too long.

What kind of sheep are you? If your answer is “a righteous sheep,” I’ve got bad news. None of us are righteous sheep. We are, all of us, constantly failing in innumerable ways. We are all the wandering sheep.

But that’s O.K., because nobody’s asking what kind of sheep you are. All you need to focus on is what kind of sheep you hope to be. We can be sheep who stay a little longer in the spot where the shepherd left us. We can be sheep who stray a little less far from where we belong. And we can certainly be sheep who bleat loudly to be found.

More: Scripture

The latest from america

statue of our lady of sheshan atop a minor basilica, the sun is behind the statue
In an unusual move, the Vatican issued a public statement of regret, essentially accusing the Chinese government of violating its agreement with the Vatican.
Pope Francis called for overcoming polarization in the life of the Catholic Church in an exclusive interview with America magazine.
Gerard O’ConnellNovember 28, 2022
A Reflection for Monday of the First Week of Advent, by Kaya Oakes
Kaya OakesNovember 28, 2022
Pope Francis, seated, speaking with editors and staff of America.
Pope Francis sits down with America for an exclusive interview on polarization, racism, Ukraine, Vatican-China relations and church teaching on the ordination of women.
The EditorsNovember 28, 2022