Click here if you don’t see subscription options
Kevin ClarkeMarch 24, 2016

Commenting on the woeful state of national political culture, House Speaker Paul Ryan tried to revive the perhaps flagging idealism of American young people in an address to a bipartisan group of House interns—one that may have also been intended for the ears of exasperated members of his own party. As many in the youthful crowd no doubt struggled to remember or even comprehend the era of bipartisan civility Ryan described, the Speaker assured them it could one day return, and acknowledged that his own deportment in the recent past may not have been exemplary.

“In a confident America,” Ryan said, “we aren’t afraid to disagree with each other.

“We don’t lock ourselves in an echo chamber, where we take comfort in the dogmas and opinions we already hold. We don’t shut down on people—and we don’t shut people down,” the speaker told the interns on March 23. “If someone has a bad idea, we tell them why our idea is better. We don’t insult them into agreeing with us. We try to persuade them. We test their assumptions. And while we’re at it, we test our own assumptions too. 

"I’m certainly not going to stand here and tell you I have always met this standard,” he added. “There was a time when I would talk about a difference between ‘makers’ and ‘takers’ in our country, referring to people who accepted government benefits. But as I spent more time listening, and really learning the root causes of poverty, I realized I was wrong.

“‘Takers’ wasn’t how to refer to a single mom stuck in a poverty trap, just trying to take care of her family,” Ryan said. “Most people don't want to be dependent. And to label a whole group of Americans that way was wrong. I shouldn’t castigate a large group of Americans to make a point.

"So I stopped thinking about it that way—and talking about it that way. But I didn’t come out and say all this to be politically correct. I was just wrong,” he added, in a remarkable moment of contrition. “And of course, there are still going to be times when I say things I wish I hadn’t. There are still going to be times when I follow the wrong impulse.”

Some will no doubt dismiss the speaker’s belated apology as too-little, too-late or mere cynical public relations, but who can say what his young audience will make of it? The House interns had been gathered in the Ways and Means Committee hearing room, where, Ryan pointed out, some of the nation’s most enduring public policies have been hashed out by Republicans and Democrats and where he first participated in the Washington political process as a young member of Congress.

Ryan called it the perfect setting for his speech. “It is here, in this committee, that we debate some of the biggest, most consequential issues. Our tax code, health care, trade, entitlement programs, welfare reform. It’s a big deal to be on this committee. And understanding the privilege and the responsibility that came along with it, [committee members] took our job seriously.

"And we always held ourselves to a higher standard of decorum. We treated each other with respect. We disagreed—often fiercely so—but we disagreed without being disagreeable.” He added, “It sounds like a scene unfamiliar to your generation.

"Looking around at what’s taking place in politics today, it is easy to get disheartened,” he told the interns. “How many of you find yourself just shaking your head at what you see from both sides?…Here is what I know now that I want you to know, that you cannot see yourself today. And that is not just a lesson for young minds, but a message for all Americans. Our political discourse—both the kind we see on TV and the kind we experience among each other—did not use to be this bad and it does not have to be this way.”

Ryan added, in what sounded like a warning to his own party’s presidential candidates, embroiled as they were yesterday in mining deeper levels of Twitter-driven degradation, “We don’t have to accept [such discord]. And we cannot enable it either.”  

Ryan said the late Congress member Jack Kemp had been an inspiration to him as a young man, describing him as “a conservative willing—no, eager—to go to America’s bleakest communities and talk about how free enterprise could lift people out of poverty. These were areas that hadn’t seen a Republican leader come through in years, if ever.

"I had the chance to accompany Jack on some of these visits. I saw how people took to him. I saw how he listened, and took new lessons from each experience. He found common cause with poverty fighters on the ground. Instead of a sense of drift, I began to feel a sense of purpose. Jack inspired me to devote my professional life to public policy. It became a vocation.”

Clearly a vocation Ryan hopes his young audience might likewise accept, along with his challenge to rebuild a culture where politicians “don’t resort to scaring you, we dare to inspire you.

“We don’t just oppose someone or something. We propose a clear and compelling alternative. And when we do that, we don’t just win the argument. We don’t just win your support. We win your enthusiasm. We win hearts and minds. We win a mandate to do what needs to be done to protect the American Idea.”

Politics, he told the interns, “can be a battle of ideas, not insults. It can be about solutions. It can be about making a difference. It can be about always striving to do better.”

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Lisa Weber
7 years 11 months ago
His comments are a nice start, at least.
Anne Danielson
7 years 11 months ago
Without freedom, there cannot be innovation, but this does not change the fact that unbridled capitalism, will eventually lead to atheistic materialism, and we ultimately end with rendering onto Caesar, what belongs to God. If we desire to be a culture that desires to inspire, we must begin by recognizing that a Civil Society is one that serves to proclaim God's Truth, not debate God's Truth. In recognizing that God Is The Author of Love, of Life, and of Marriage, our Founding Fathers recognized that God, not Caesar, Has endowed us with our unalienable Right to Life, to Liberty, and to The Pursuit of Happiness. There was a Time in Salvation History when we, as Catholic Americans, were not afraid to proclaim God's Truth about the Sanctity of every human life from the moment of conception, and the Sanctity of marriage and the family as God intended, but that was before we allowed our hearts to become hardened. Apart from The True God, no nation can remain civilized, and therein we have the crux of the matter.

The latest from america

Pope Francis meets relatives of hostages taken from Israel by Hamas militants in his residence at the Vatican on Nov. 22, 2023. (CNS photo/Vatican Media)
One might criticize Pope Francis' statements about the war in Gaza, but they should not be confused with the question of the Catholic Church’s relationship with the Jewish people.
David Neuhaus, S.J.February 21, 2024
Despite the irreverent “homecoming” funeral for actor and author Cecilia Gentili not going as planned, New York Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan said he believes the “cathedral acted extraordinarily well.”
Julie Asher - OSV NewsFebruary 21, 2024
Graham Greene crafted some of English-language literature's finest works, part of a fascinating life marked by bouts of uncertainty and the certainty of doubt.
James T. KeaneFebruary 20, 2024
It is an extraordinary testament to a person’s pastoral care when they are remembered as someone who was a steady presence in the most difficult times.