Whither Hope?

Whither hope? Last week I complained that Obama’s inaugural address was all spinach and no hope and that it lacked an over-arching narrative. His roll-out of the economic stimulus plan suffers from a similar problem. The words may have been poll tested, as Carrie Budoff Brown shows over at Politico, but they pointed in too many directions. And, the President who just last week told us that the future was not in his hands but in ours failed to tell us what we can do, how these proposals can or should affect us, or even to explain the problems with the moral force he used during the campaign.

Obama’s campaign was good because it stuck to a simple theme: America needed a change, and not just from the Bush years, but from the slash-and-burn politics of the past twenty years or, as the Joker might have put it if he were running for office: America needs a better class of politician. We needed politicians who would make us less cynical and more hopeful, who would empower the people to change the culture of Washington and Wall Street, who understood that the desire of the American people to provide for their children is a profoundly moral desire and it was being frustrated for middle class Americans for too long. Listening or watching the radio address Saturday, I searched in vain for the moral language we heard in October about the dignity of work and how we should value that work.


If the inaugural address was all spinach, this weekend’s radio address was goulash: Everything got thrown into the mix. We will rebuild schools. We will build 3,000 miles of modernized electric transmission lines. We will double our renewable energy generating capacity. We will computerize health records. We will improve roadways. It is a laundry list. Where was the narrative?

The most important thing about the plan is that it be stimulative, although this word did not "test" well with focus groups so it did not find its ways into the President’s remarks. Which is a shame. If Paul Krugman can explain the need to stimulate the economy on a Sunday talk show roundtable, so can the President. Nor did Obama link the current stimulative impact of his proposals to long-term investments where possible. For example, new education funding will help keep kids in school which will help the economy in the long-term, but it also keeps students out of the labor market, which helps the unemployment rate in the short term.

No projects are more stimulative than rail lines because they create a terminus where customers are concentrated. Think of all the small businesses inside and in the immediate vicinity of Grand Central Station in New York or the Gare Saint-Lazare in Paris that cater to the crowds the trains create. And, for all the abuse hurled at pork barrel projects, I imagine certain kinds of pork barrel projects are very stimulative, such as museums and historical sites.

Most distressing is the failure to understand how a large and tangible goal can serve to inspire the American people. I am sure it is a good thing that we will double our renewable-energy generating capacity in three years. But, I also don’t know what that looks like. I do know what a wind farm looks like and wish the President had said something like "We will build 1,000 wind farms in the next three years and link them to our rebuilt electrical grid so they can supply cities from Philadelphia to San Diego with renewable electricity." I also am waiting for the President to travel to Detroit and promise the American people that our factories there will be re-tooled to make fuel-efficient cars just as they were re-tooled at the start of World War II to make tanks.

Mario Cuomo is credited with saying, "You campaign in poetry; you govern in prose." There is undoubtedly much truth to the observation. But, the change from Obama the hope-filled candidate to Obama the spinach-serving, policy wonk President, is so sudden as to invite whiplash. Nor is it the change for which people voted in November.



Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
9 years 12 months ago
As the gentle lady from New York State said: “Now I could stand up here and say, let’s get everybody together, let’s get unified, the sky will open, the light will come down, celestial choirs will be singing. And everyone will know we should do the right thing, and the world will be perfect.”
9 years 12 months ago
Is this the shortest presidential honeymoon in history or what? Eat some spinach and goulash, Michael, and fortify yourself for a bit of slogging through! All of what you say may have merit, but brace yourself -- read the headlines -- the companies of the world are laying off 65,00 workers -- and you want quick answers? inspiration? perspiration? Let's give this guy a chance before your heated rhetoric blows through a hole in whatever goodwill may yet exist!
9 years 12 months ago
Obama said that after his breakthrough keynote speech at the DNC 04 people wanted every speech to be about how the red states aren't red and the blue states aren't blue and were disappointed when he spoke on other issues. As far as say anything Hilary: she did in fact stand up and say "let everybody come together". She did so at the Convention 08. It was a powerful speech which helped bring supporters together. Yes, Hilary, words are powerful. Many supporters reconsidered expressing their fustrations by supporting McCain/Palin and remained in the DEM camp instead. She got up and said "change" and many of them did.
9 years 12 months ago
I think we need to be patient and supportive. Our country is severely broken. Our economy is a wreck and we are in a war that is not going well. Even worse we are pervaded by a deeply and widely held cynicism that says "Government is the problem." There are no easy solutions and the solutions that seem most likely to work are opposed on principle by a large percentage of the population and the media. And then there are many -- and many in this Church -- that want to see him out at all costs, no matter what it does to our country. Okay, so it has been six days since he entered Washington and we only gave Jesus five after He entered Jerusalem.


The latest from america

This year’s W.Y.D takes place less than three months after the conclusion of the Synod for Young People that was held in the Vatican last October.
Gerard O’ConnellJanuary 21, 2019
On Jan. 18, a teenager wearing a "Make America Great Again" hat, center left, stands in front of an elderly Native American singing and playing a drum in Washington. (Survival Media Agency via AP)

WASHINGTON (CNS) -- An exchange between Catholic high school students and a Native American tribal leader in Washington Jan.

Like most public writers, I was used to getting notes that were crude, crazy or even mildly threatening. Normally, I would say a quick prayer for these obviously troubled people and get on with my day. This time it felt different, precisely because the author wasn’t insulting or obviously deranged.
Rachel LuJanuary 21, 2019
In cities across the country, local activists marched in support of a progressive agenda centered on economic justice, racial justice and immigrant rights.
Brandon SanchezJanuary 20, 2019