What is Truth? - Learning from Baseball

A recent book on baseball umpires, reviewed positively, is entitled “As They See ‘Em”.  That reminded me of  a comment in the New Yorker many years ago about  hree umpires explaining how they called ‘em.

-- The first umpire said “Some’s balls and some’s strikes, and I calls ‘em as they is.”  

-- The second said “Some’s balls and some’s strikes and I calls ‘em as I sees ‘em.”

-- The third explained: “Some’s balls and some’s strikes, but they ain’t nothin’ till I calls ‘em.”  

This takes me right back to philosophy (and sometimes theology) class. What is truth?     

-- The first is the dogmatist. He is sure of his grasp of  objective truth--as they is.    

-- The second, more honestly, admits his own perspective is a bit more relative, or subjective. Truth depends upon his own eyesight and judgment--as he sees ‘em.

-- The third is also dogmatic, and I believe  the most dangerous. He is in charge, he constructs or imposes what he sees, his truth upon reality--as he calls ‘em.

How this applies to various media writers and commentators, and how this applies to spiritual and temporal leaders, I leave up to the viewer to decide.

Peter Schineller, S.J.

Advertisement
Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
8 years 8 months ago
Well, you make a good point; on the other hand, for the sake of the game the pitch needs to be called; it is what I call it, as I see it and hopefully what it is. In the past there was no possibility of a replay, only a gathering of opinions; now, we can have a digital view within a framework of references. So, whatever the philosophy and attitude of the ump, still there is the truth and it can be determined. Still, was it a spit ball? I saw on national news a 5 second notice of the Pope at a Mass in Angola Africa attended by 1 million people. 30 seconds were given to the following news article about an actress. Hmmmm.
8 years 8 months ago
Jever hear of the Magisterium? the Holy Father? Of Jesus Christ, Who is the Way and the Life and the Truth?

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Father James Martin, S.J. and Ross Douthat at the Civility in America Part 1: Religion event held at The Sheen Center on Dec. 13th. (America/Antonio DeLoera-Brust).
Is there a duty for Christians to represent a certain kind of voice in the public discourse?
Angelo Jesus CantaDecember 14, 2017
A spokesman for the archdiocese described the meeting as “personal” in nature and aimed at “renewing a friendship that goes back 15 years or so.”
Michael J. O’LoughlinDecember 14, 2017
Black women cannot be expected to continue to save white people from the poor choices they make.
Anthea ButlerDecember 14, 2017
After a visit to Christ in the Desert, I knew it was not the monks whose lifestyle I should question.
Michael DauschDecember 14, 2017