Vatican: Holocaust Denial "Unacceptable"

Nicole Winfield of AP has the story here.  And Catholic News is reporting that Cardinal Walter Kasper called denial of the Holocaust "stupid."

From her story:

The Vatican said Monday that comments by a recently rehabilitated bishop that no Jews were gassed during the Holocaust were "unacceptable" and violate Church teaching.


In a front-page article, the Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano reaffirmed that Pope Benedict XVI deplored all forms of anti-Semitism and that all Roman Catholics must do the same. The article was issued amid an outcry from Jewish groups that Benedict last week lifted the excommunication of a traditionalist bishop, Richard Williamson, who has denied that 6 million Jews were murdered during World War II.

The Vatican has stressed that that removing the excommunication by no means implied the Vatican shared Williamson’s views. Williamson and three other bishops were excommunicated 20 years ago after they were consecrated by the late ultraconservative Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre without papal consent — a move the Vatican said at the time was an act of schism.

Benedict has made clear from the start of his pontificate that he wanted to reconcile with Lefebvre’s traditionalist Society of St. Pius X and bring it back into the Vatican’s fold. Lefebvre had rebelled against the Vatican and founded the society in 1969. He was bitterly opposed to the teachings of the Second Vatican Council, the 1962-65 meetings that brought liberal reforms to the church.

One of the key documents issued by Vatican II was "Nostra Aetate," which said the church deplored all forms of anti-Semitism. The document revolutionized the church’s relations with Jews.  In the article, L’Osservatore said Benedict and his predecessors had all made clear the church’s teaching on "Nostra Aetate" in documents, actions and speeches and that its contents "are not debatable for Catholics."

Williamson’s statements, broadcast last week in a Swedish state TV interview, "contradict this teaching and are thus very serious and regrettable," L’Osservatore said. While broadcast before the Jan. 21 document lifting the excommunication, they remain "unacceptable," it said.   --AP

But...if denial of the teachings of "Nostra Aetate" is "unacceptable," then how is it that one can be a bishop in good standing and reject the rest of the teachings of Vatican II?  (Lumen Gentium, Gaudium et Spes, etc.)  Violating church teaching is a charge that is frequently leveled against the far left, the left, the liberal, the progressive Catholic.  Is violation of church teaching acceptable when it happens on the right? 

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
9 years 1 month ago
"Is violation of Church teaching acceptable when it happens on the right?" Heterodoxy is heterodoxy in every location.
9 years 1 month ago
I have nothing but respect for the Holy Father and I am obedient to the Church's magisterium, but I don't get this move by Pope Benedict XVI. I trust that his intentions were good: bring back in the fold all the SSPX adherents despite the idiocy of one of their bishops. Perhaps he was concerned, as some commentators have reported, that the only growing segment of church goers in Europe are those who are part of the traditionalist movement and that a splinter church in Europe would be disaster. But courting an unrepentant "Bishop" whose repugnant anti-semitic views are only matched in foolishness by railing against the "modernist" church should not be the price to pay for this. That being said, from the initial statements so far, it doesn't seem that the gesture by Pope Benedict XVI will ultimately not be met in full faith (as in accepting Vatican II as authoritative) by Williamson and the other bishops (that is if canonically they are still bishops). One can only pray that the laity and clergy of SSPX will chuck their pride at the door and enter back into the fold
9 years 1 month ago
But Fr Martin, this criminal is NOT in good standing. He is, for example, suspended a divinis. Quite contrary to Fr Hans Küng, by the way...
9 years 1 month ago
Quoting from the address I linked in a previous comment thread, 'There is a glaring contradiction in the fact that it is just the people who have let no occasion slip to allow the world to know of their disobedience to the Pope, and to the magisterial declarations of the last 20 years, who think they have the right to judge that this attitude [towards the Lefebvrists] is too mild and who wish that an absolute obedience to Vatican II had been insisted upon.' (Cdl. Ratzinger, 1988)
9 years 1 month ago
Are liberals only concerned about the denial of Church teachings when the right denies Church teachings? They certainly are not concerned when Catholic politicians deny Church teachings about the sanctity of life!
9 years 1 month ago
For what it's worth: 1- Bp. Fellay, the Superior General of the SSPX, 'has silenced Bp. Williamson' and declared his (Williamson's) statements regrettable and unacceptable. (cf. 2- Juridically, NOTHING HAS CHANGED with regard to SSPX. In a juridical sense, no, they are not legitimized. The SSPX still doesn't have the approval of the Holy Father or of a bishop in any diocese. The bishops of the SSPX be validly consecrated bishops, they were illicitly consecrated and that hat hasn’t changed. They are still not reconciled with the Holy See and they are still suspended a divinis. They are still without permission to exercise ministry in the Church and therefore may not licitly ordain. They have no authority to establish parishes, etc. Ditto for SSPX priests. They say Mass without permission from the Holy See or the local ordinary. They don't have the required faculties to hear confessions or give sacramental absolution except in danger of death. Mind you, the excommunications back in 1988 were, IMCO, valid. But that's another discussion altogether. AMDG, -J.
9 years 1 month ago
Vatican II is infallible when restating a matter of faith or morals. The teachings found in The Delaration on Religious Liberty (for example) do not directly fall under the category of faith and morals per se. That doesn't mean that we can just chuck them out but if we care about truth we must read the Vatican II documents along with former documents dealing with the same issues.I'm no scholar but I've read Quas Primas from Pope Pius XI as well as Dignitatis Humane and they certainly seem to contradict each other. This shouldn't upset our belief in the infallibility of the Church because Dignitatis Humanae did NOT change any doctrinal or moral teaching of the Church but there are some very NOVEL IMPLICATIONS about Church and state, religious liberty, etc. that I believe led to much of the widespread heresies in the Church. Read both documents for yourself and if someone can prove me wrong I'll stand corrected.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

The U.N. report documents cases of extrajudicial murders committed by police, illegal house raids and threats and harassment against journalists and social and political activists in Honduras.
Jackie McVicarMarch 20, 2018
An employee wrapped in a blanket talks to a police officer after she was evacuated at a FedEx distribution center where a package exploded on March 20, 2018, in Schertz, Texas. (AP Photo/Eric Gay)
In their joint statement, the Texas bishops echoed Chief Manley’s appeal to the community. “We ask all people in our dioceses to remain vigilant, and to pray and work for peace,” the bishops said.
Paul StinsonMarch 20, 2018
The challenge of finding families for homeless youth and for those in group shelters is creating the latest flashpoint over competing civil rights claims. (iStock/bodnarchuk)
Catholic Social Services refuses to place foster children in homes headed by same-sex couples; the city of Philadelphia says this policy violates a nondiscrimination law.
My approach to the mystery of A.L.S. is a bit different than that of the famed physicist.
Elise ItalianoMarch 20, 2018