Loading...
Loading...
Click here if you don’t see subscription options
In All Things

The Return of the Al Smith Dinner

Michael Sean WintersOctober 17, 2008
In 2004, the Al Smith Dinner did not invite the presidential candidates because one of them was a pro-choice Catholic. But, this year, the tradition returned: white tie and tails, the Cardinal-Archbishop of New York presiding, and both presidential candidates yucking it up. Best lines of the night were John McCain’s joking that "I can’t shake the feeling that some people here are pulling for me. I am delighted to see you here tonight, Hillary" and Barack Obama’s attempt to correct the record: "Contrary to rumors you have heard, I was not born in a manger. I was born on Krypton and sent here by my father Jor-El to save the Planet Earth."

Michael Sean Winters

Show Comments (
2
)
Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
16 years 6 months ago
They were both hilarious. It was such a nice reprieve from this awful campaign. Just in case anyone is wondering why pro-choice Kerry would not be invited and pro-choice Obama would not, Kerry is Catholic, and so his public departure from Catholic teaching does not just make him wrong, it becomes scandalous. Obama is not Catholic, and so he is just wrong but not scandalous.
16 years 6 months ago
Well, would Nero be an invited guest to the Al Smith dinner? After all, he yucked it up while Rome burned. Last year it was Tony Blair as main guest. I generally support the bishops but why invite a guy that supported the war in Iraq and maybe cooked the books to promote the cause? That would be Tony Blair. That McCain is responsible for his part in promoting the same war is undenied. Isn't it estimated that over 200,000 civilians have been killed and 4 million made refugees. Guess I don't understand the Al Smith dinner philosophy. I can imagine that more children were killed in Iraq and still will be than the Al Smith dinner will ever help. Just who does the Al Smith dinner really benefit and for whose benefit is it performed?

Most popular

1
Backer of Cardinal Parolin attacks Pope Francis’ push for lay involvement in church governance
Gerard O’Connell
2
The new pope: How journalists (and cardinals) come up with their list of candidates
Colleen Dulle
3
With five days before the conclave, all but four cardinal electors are in Rome
Cindy Wooden - Catholic News Service
4
Hong Kong’s Jesuit Cardinal Chow on the conclave, the next pope and Francis’ legacy
Gerard O’Connell
5
Pope tailors aren’t expecting a typical order for cassocks to outfit the new pontiff
Colleen Barry - Associated Press (AP)

Your source for jobs, books, retreats, and much more.

All My Eyes See: The Artistic Vocation of Fr. William Hart McNichols
Books
Come Join Us
Volunteer / Vocation
Online Evening Prayer with Young Adults
Activities, Events
President of the Association of Jesuit Colleges and Universities
Jobs
Catholic insights: catechist and blogger!
Apps
See all Classifieds

The latest from america

How will the next pope strengthen safeguards against sex abuse?
Working for the protection of people by safeguarding against the crime abuse is an integral expression of Christian faith. The successor of Pope Francis has the task of picking up where he left off and continuing resolutely. How can that be done?
Peter BeerMay 02, 2025
Brother Alois of Taizé remembers Pope Francis: A life defined by the courage of faith
Francis always encouraged me in our attempt to move forward as an ecumenical community and in welcoming young people from different churches who come to Taizé from all over the world. He was the pope, but also a father and a brother to me.
Brother AloisMay 02, 2025
Some cardinals are attacking Pope Francis. He would have welcomed it.
Pope Francis welcomed criticism—as long as it was not made behind his back.
Sebastian GomesMay 02, 2025
At the conclave, politics and prayer come together. Is that a problem?
The cardinals have asked Catholics to pray for them and the conclave. What exactly should we be praying for? And should we be scandalized by the intermingling of politics and spirituality?
JesuiticalMay 02, 2025