The People (Some of Them) Speak in Pennsylvania, Kentucky & Arkansas

Sometimes in politics, the only pattern is that there is no pattern. Last night’s primaries yielded an amazingly diverse set of conclusions from the insta-pundits, way too much of it focused on inside-the-Beltway considerations. I love Andrea Mitchell, but her report from Philly focused almost entirely on the recriminations between the White House and the campaign of Sen. Arlen Specter over whether or not the President had done enough. To be clear, Obama first appeared on a Pennsylvania ballot in the spring of 2008 and they have been forming their opinion of Specter for 30 years. Ditto about the interpretation of the results in Kentucky’s GOP Senate primary, which were seen as a referendum on Sen. Mitch McConnell, who was not on the ballot, as opposed to an endorsement of Rand Paul, who was on the ballot and won.

If the Kentucky and Pennsylvania Senate primaries showed a bias in favor of those with fewer establishment and Washington ties, Sen. Blanche Lincoln managed to hold on to a win in Arkansas. She did not cross the fifty percent threshold and so there will be a run-off, but what is astounding is that Lincoln ran an old-fashioned incumbent campaign, emphasizing her seniority and record in Washington. I was surprised that didn’t get her chased across the border into Oklahoma.


A couple of points that seemed to go under-reported. Candidates always use their victory speeches on primary night to re-position themselves for the general election. They know they will have a large audience watching, and they pivot from the intra-party fight to the inter-party fight, and move to the center. Not Rand Paul. In his victory speech, he not only thanked the Tea Party movement for their support, he essentially presented himself as the candidate of that movement who, incidentally, is the candidate of the Republican Party. It will be curious to see if that works. Americans are notoriously non-ideological about their politics, and Paul’s Democratic opponent, Attorney General Jack Conway is will advised to run as a problem-solver with no D.C. experience.

Paul also criticized the President because "he went to Copenhagen and appeared with Robert Mugabe and Hugo Chavez and others, Evo Morales…these petty dictators say that to stop climate change, it is about ending capitalism…the President by attending Copenhagen gives credibility and credence to these folks and he should not go." Now, I confess, I had to go to google to recall whether Evo Morales was the president of Bolivia or Peru. And, my first recollection of President Obama in Copenhagen was not at the uneventful climate change conference but at the International Olympic Committee that denied the Summer Games in 2016 to Chicago. Maybe, just maybe, the good people of the Blue Grass State are more plugged in than I would have imagined, but I think Paul’s speech reflected the Kool-Aid he has been drinking at those Tea Party events. And, I wonder what moderate, suburban voters will make of it. And, I would have thought there were more proximate issues upon which to criticize the President and, in fairness, much of Paul’s speech hit some popular themes.

Another thing that jumped out at me about the Kentucky primaries was the turnout. Only 330,000 people voted in the GOP primary, compared to 440,000 in the Democratic primary. I would not read too much into that: In 2008, 700,000 Kentuckyians voted in the Democratic primary and only 198,000 in the Republican one, yet McCain carried the state handily, beating Barack Obama by 57%-41%.

The other big news of the night came from western Pennsylvania’s Twelfth Congressional District which was the only contest to pit a Democrat against a Republican, to fill the term of Cong. Jack Murtha who died earlier in the year. This was one of the few districts in the country, and the only one in Pennsylvania, that voted for John Kerry in 2004 and went red in 2008, back McCain over Obama. In short, insofar as the GOP is hoping to make significant gains based on disapproval of Obama, this was the district in which to do it, but the Democrat, Mark Critz, won easily.

So, what was the verdict yesterday? Arkansas is looking more like it will be tilting to the GOP and Pennsylvania is looking more like it is tilting to the Dems. Kentucky should be a safe GOP seat, but Mr. Paul is a wildcard. Of all yesterday’s political news, the one with the greatest potential to alter the balance of power was the New York Times report on Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal had mis-characterized his services in the Marine Reserves, saying in several speeches that he had served "in" Vietnam when, in fact, he only served "during" Vietnam. Kentuckyians may or may not know the president of Bolivia, but Nutmeggers know about Vietnam. The gaffe takes what should have been a safe Democratic seat and puts it in play. Even if Blumenthal’s sky-high approval ratings in the state allow him to minimize the damage, damage has been done and the Democrats will need to spend resources on a state that should have been in the bag.

Michael Sean Winters


Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Beth Cioffoletti
8 years 8 months ago
I do think that climate, whether you call it global warming or not, and the economy are linked.
Ending capitalism may not affect climate change, but climate change is sure going to do a number on capitalism.
Tom Maher
8 years 8 months ago
MSW finds no pattern in yesterday's primaries and special election and avoids comparing yesterday's result to the results of other primaries and special elections since last fall.

Look again Mr. Winters. Yesterday results confrim again a distinct pattern of repudiation of the Obama admistisration economic policies and politics even by solid Democratic election districts such as the 12th Congressional district.

Less than four months ago Republican Scott Brown captured Ted Kennedy's senate seat in solidly Democratic state of Massachusettssignalling radical changes in voting patterns. Yesterday the Democrate that won the 12 th Congressional District seat in Pennsylvania reputiated all the Obama economic policies. Economic policies figured strongly in all of yesterrday's voting. Seantor Spector the Obama favoite was rejected by Democrates. Rand Raud in Kentucky with his anti-Obama economics won. So the results from voters contiue to show an distinct and strong anti-Obama pattern over the last six months where every race repudiates Obama economic policy.

Mr. Winters of course would predictiably miss any pattern not favorable to Obama due to Mr. Winters intense pro-Obama biases.
8 years 8 months ago
Can we just Blumenthal L-I-E-D instead of the more passive "mis-characterized"?  What does that even mean?  I suppose John Edwards "mis-characterized" his relationship with a female staffer while his wife was dying of cancer?  And why can't politicians of BOTH parties stand up and demand that people tell the truth, especially about combat military service, of all things?
St. Thomas More, pray for us!  ("Why, Richard, it profits a man nothing to give his soul for the whole world...but for Wales?")
James Lindsay
8 years 8 months ago
After listening to a Marine Vets event on CSPAN last night, I don't think Bluementhal has anything to worry about. So far the GOP is 0 for 5 in special elections in the House. They may pick up one in Hawai'i, but only until November, after which the Dems will get it back after having a primary.

The big debate will hopefully happen this year anyway. It will be on taxes and reconciliation could have it wired for the Democrats, since they can let the Bush cuts expire, except for the ones they like - which they can preserve temporarily through reconciliation if the GOP does not behave.

Look for a quietly passed tax bill that ends that debate for now. As long as that happens, I don't care about much else, with the possible exception of immigration reform (which is not dead yet).
8 years 8 months ago
So in your view, Mr. Bindner, cheers to Blumenthal and forward ho, correct?  What he did was wrong, pure and simple, and one's views of taxes, reconciliation or anything else doesn't change that, nor does the (bad) judgment of anyone, vet or not.  I assume you would laud the folks who pocketed their consciences to try to elect John Edwards president.  Integrity matters.
William Kurtz
8 years 8 months ago
I tend to agree with Jeff Landry on the importance of integrity, so I'll ask him: Sen. David Vitter of Louisiana enjoys the support of the religious right despite his patronage of prostitutes. Should Vitter be re-elected, since he is 100% pro-life?


The latest from america

Michael Osborne, a film director, documents the damage from a mud slide next to his home in Los Angeles on Jan. 18, after three days of heavy rain. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes)
The conceit of California-as-disaster-movie is ridiculous. But maybe watching our fires and mudslides helps other states consider both their own fragility and their underlying strength.
Jim McDermottJanuary 23, 2019
A commitment to religious liberty demands that effort be devoted to resolving, rather than exacerbating, any real or apparent tension between religious obligation and civil duty.
The EditorsJanuary 23, 2019
Pope Francis said Wednesday that fear of migration is "making us crazy" as he began a trip to Central America amid a standoff over President Donald Trump's promised wall at the U.S.-Mexico border and a new caravan of migrants heading north.