Michael Sean Winters: Ave Atque Vale

Tomorrow we will bid farewell on this blog to Michael Sean Winters, one of our most indefatigable and most popular bloggers, and someone well known to the readers of America.  Michael, author of Left at the Altar: How the Democrats Lost the Catholics and How the Catholics Can Save the Democrats, is a well-known Catholic commentator and essayist.  Over the past year, he has written extensively on political matters, church issues and more broadly social issues.  He was one of our first (and most regular) bloggers, someone we relied upon for timely, hard-hitting looks at the issues of the day, and someone who usually drew a lot of "traffic" to our site, and who was often quoted in the MSM.  Michael, who has written for the print edition as well, will continue to write for the magazine--in print and online we hope--but will be blogging more or less regularly for the National Catholic Reporter.  Michael helped us immeasurably when "In All Things" was in its infancy.  Now that the blog is off and running, and we have more of our associate editors blogging daily, we will be relying more on "in-house" talent.  But we are exceedingly grateful to Michael for his terrific contributions, we wish him well at NCR, and we look forward to future contributons in America.  By the way, for those Vaticanologists who wish to read some hidden meaning into this farewell being penned by the culture editor, rather than our editor in chief or our online editor, some facts: both are away. But both join me, and the rest of the staff here at America, in thanking Michael Sean Winters.


James Martin, SJ

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
9 years 7 months ago
I wish Mr. Winters well and will have to look into what else he writes at other places.  He is a gifted writer even if I often disagree with his positions.  Just finished his book.  I suggest all read it as well as the book by David Carlin.
9 years 7 months ago
I will miss reading Mr. Winters; his entries came even before coffee.
 James Keegan
Beth Cioffoletti
9 years 7 months ago
I also didn't always agree with you, but you always cast a unique perspective on the news of the day, and added a much needed voice to the conversation.  Thank you!
Nicholas Collura
9 years 7 months ago
That's too bad! Michael, you will be very greatly missed...but I know you will bring as much intelligence, sincerity, thoughtfulness, and truthfulness to the NCR as you have to In All Things. My best to you over there!
James Lindsay
9 years 7 months ago
Good Luck Michael, I will see you at NCR.
ed gleason
9 years 7 months ago
Michael; I'm sorry you are leaving and hope you come back to post on the ongoing Church crisis, Challanging voices that stay 'inside' are needed more than ever. The issues are not going away ..Interesting times indeed.  
Jim McCrea
9 years 7 months ago
I will miss the few but prolific "attack dogs" that seemed to live to correct the ever-errant MSW's alleged misguided liberalism.
9 years 7 months ago
His more philosophical pieces of the relationship of Church-state were the best & quite thought provoking; his more political pieces were essentially proof-texts for DNC or White House talking points.  There were times when his pieces read like he woke up looking to tick one or another group off. He also has a maddening habit of not responding to critics; in all, I think he is best suited for print rather than the blogosphere.  I hope America replaces him with someone better suited to the greatest intellectual tradition of America in the blogosphere.
All the best,
An "attack dog".
Gabriel Marcella
9 years 7 months ago
We shall miss this Renaissance man gifted with a remarkable capacity to generate interest, controversy, and passionate response. Good luck, my friend!
we vnornm
9 years 7 months ago
I have enjoyed every post I've read by MSW, disagreeing more than a little, but always respecting this vital and creative man whose work has enriched the Church immeasurably. I look forward to reading your ideas in the future and hearing about your future successes, which I hope will be abundant. amdg, bvo
9 years 7 months ago
Well, I don't think i was an attack dog Father Jim but I did disagree with my Irish friend in particular on matters of economics and politics. I agreed with him more on our great Church tent being large and expansive,yet still in the end a tent.
MSM is a gifted and sincere Catholic writer who is as much a Catholic apologist as an apologist for the Democratic party ( and he is willing to say when he disagrees with both)  Thanks MSM- best wishes to you in your new gig and I hope sometime I get to buy you a pint at a watering hole  and talk/debate politics. blessings to you and your family. Joe
david power
9 years 7 months ago
Good luck  Mr Winters.Thanks for all of the  bloggings ,which were sometimes brilliant ,and I hope that you continue to write about the meaning of the spirituality of the Church as it touches  the temporal sphere. I hope that you work on bigger projects as your talent is held back in mediums like these. It was often an education in the Faith that you gave.
God bless  
James Lindsay
9 years 6 months ago
Fr. Jim,

Give us this day our daily blogger. No one posted on July 1.
Marcello Mastroianni
9 years ago
Just out of curiosity, I did a quick Google search for the word ''racist'' on America Magazine's website. While MSW was writing here, the word appears 3-4 times per month. Since he's left, it's down to once per month or not at all. MSW's departure is welcome.
Helena Loflin
9 years 7 months ago
Thank you, Michael, and best wishes!


The latest from america

President Donald Trump called it his “profound honor" on Friday to be the first president to attend the March for Life.
One of Audrey Hepburn’s most compelling films—1959’s “The Nun’s Story,” directed by Fred Zinnemann—is also one of her most overlooked.
Nadra Nittle January 24, 2020
The killing of General Suleimani is only the latest—and by no means unique—example of reliance on an A.U.M.F. long after its passage and far outside its reasonable scope.
The EditorsJanuary 24, 2020
Our readers answer the question: What was the most spiritually significant film you saw in 2019?
Our readersJanuary 24, 2020