Intellectual Idiocy #1

The lack of basic knowledge of the traditions of Western thought is a sore affliction in anyone, but in people who are paid to write about important events, this lack is criminal. The commentary on President Obama’s Nobel lecture in Oslo yesterday has hit new lows in this regard.

Consider the front page, above the fold, article in this morning’s Washington Post. There we read, in a news article, this sentence: "In an echo of predecessor George W. Bush, he [Obama] noted that ‘evil does exist in the world.’" Oh, so it was W who first noticed the existence of evil in the world? This meme was frequently employed yesterday, especially by conservatives, the idea that Obama’s sophisticated speech could have been delivered by his predecessor. Are they mad? Obama’s speech showed a man heart had been inspired by King and Gandhi but whose mind is captivated by Reinhold Niebuhr. Is there any evidence that George W. Bush knows the difference between Niebuhr and knockwurst, or even who Niebuhr was?

Advertisement

Former GOP House Speaker applauded Obama’s speech and said, "I think having a liberal president who goes to Oslo on behalf of a peace prize and reminds the committee that they would not be free, they wouldn't be able to have a peace prize, without having force... I thought in some ways it's a very historic speech." Mr. Gingrich, who is an historian by nature and training, seems to have forgotten that the two World Wars were prosecuted by three liberal Presidents - Wilson, FDR, and Truman – and that the architecture of anti-communism was supported by liberals and conservatives alike. Closer to our own time, he has evidently forgotten that it was Bill Clinton who last dispatched the U.S. military to the continent of Europe.

Sean Hannity could not even bring himself to join those conservatives who praised the President’s speech. He said it lacked "moral clarity." By this, he evidently means that the President’s speech lacked moral simplicity, but a morality that lends itself to simplicity is, by definition, one that is not very clear. Hannity, you will recall, dropped out of seminary first and college later, and maybe he never got to the courses that taught moral theory. But, most adults have experienced moral ambiguity at some point in their lives and understand that artificial efforts to reduce the complexities of life to simple moral either/or equations are doomed to fail.

Yesterday, I felt so good about a culture that could produce a President capable of delivering such a speech. This morning, reading the responses, my view of our culture is less rosy. But, even this morning there is hope. George Stephanopoulos was introduced to the viewers of "Good Morning America." George holds a master’s degree in theology from Balliol College, Oxford. At this flagship show, it is comforting to know that someone who can use the adjective "Augustinian" correctly in a sentence will be in the driver’s seat.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Helena Loflin
8 years 8 months ago
When I first heard the attribution to George W. Bush, I didn't know whether to laugh or cry.  Basic lack of knowledge is an affliction of FOX News.  Because it works so well for FOX, there seems to be a fauxFaux movement taking hold within the MSM.  It's astounding the goofiness that ABC, NBC, CBS and CNN will pass off to their viewers after FOX initiates it.  Often, the fauxFaux will dumb down themselves without the slightest nudge from FOX, like the Washington Post above.
Jon Stewart did a video montage of on-air Gretchen Carlson just a couple of nights ago and noted the extreme contrast between her "I'm so dumb" on-air behavior and her academic achievement and sophistication.  Gives added dimension to the meaning of fauxFaux.
I printed and read President Obama's speech.  Our country and the world are truly blessed!
 
Brian Thompson
8 years 8 months ago
He was not perfect, indeed terrible at times, but I would take the ineloquent man with a good heart over the slick-tounged seducer anyday.
Brad Roberts
8 years 8 months ago
I agree with Brian, Bush was terrible at times. And I agree with MSW the speech was impressive.

I would just point out, though, that people aren't always what they seem. Gretchen Carlson, who plays the wide-eyed, not-so-bright host of Fox & Friends apparently graduated Stanford with Honors and is a classically trained violinist (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gretchen_Carlson).

Sometimes people simply hide their intelligence and talents when in public and I'd like to think those who say they think the concept of evil began with Bush are just doing the same.
Chris Seeber
8 years 8 months ago
"Goodmorning America" is a "flagship show?"  My Goodness!
I know the author is a partisan hack but let me remind the readers we have been in Afganistan for NINE years.  Can anyone, using the four principle of the just war doctrine, jusitfy our continued presence in Afganistan?  I would be interested to see that reasoned aurgument.  Maybe another magazine perhaps!
Brian Thompson
8 years 8 months ago
It really is a pretty straitforward application of basic moral principles, Chris. When the son of perdition was waging war in the sandy reagions of the east, he indeed was warmongering and pillaging with reckless abandon. However, now the Messiah is mercifully, yet firmly, sending our brave warriors out to struggle for the sake of peace. The Chosen one can do no ill. Ideed, he is like Ghandi or King or Jesus, yet more since he can be the hero of non-voilence and peace while sending thousands of people to war. Oh blessed be he!

Advertisement

The latest from america

Often, we have a tendency to privilege emotional moments over the more intellectual ones in our spiritual life.
James Martin, S.J.August 20, 2018
Photo by Jonathan Simcoe on Unsplash
Most people just don’t know that their pondering about life, about what really matters, is called theology.
Pope Francis issued a letter to Catholics around the world Monday condemning the "crime" of priestly sexual abuse and its cover-up and demanding accountability.
Bishop Lawrence T. Persico of Erie, Pa., speaks during a meeting in late January at the headquarters of U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in Washington. (CNS photo/Tyler Orsburn)
“I think we need complete transparency if we’re going to get the trust of the people back,” said Erie Bishop Lawrence T. Persico.