Get out your scorecards

Over at the National Catholic Reporter, John Allen offers an inside baseball look at exactly what the heck is going on at the Vatican regarding the L.C.W.R. clampdown, or is it? Allen offers a somewhat calming dissection of the behind the scenes jockeying that took place, is probably still taking place, between the CDF and the Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, better known as the "Congregation for Religious." Readers will be shocked, shocked to learn that there may be some intrigue and hard feelings this week in Rome after the CDF move against (or as Allen would have it, "with") the L.C.W.R. among the leaders of the Consecrated Life who had spent a good part of last year attempting to soothe anxieties among U.S. women religious.

Says Allen:


It's an open secret that the tones emanating from these two departments about women religious in America are rather distinct.

Under Brazilian Cardinal João Bráz de Aviz and American Archbishop Joseph Tobin, the Congregation for Religious in the last couple of years has attempted to calm anxieties generated by a wide-ranging apostolic visitation of women's religious communities in the United States, which recently reached conclusion. (That's a separate process from the doctrinal review of LCWR; more on that in a moment.) Bráz and Tobin have signaled that they want dialogue, not confrontation, and have made clear there won't be any immediate earthquake as a result of the visitation.

When the LCWR initially said it was "stunned" by the assessment from the Congregation for the Faith, there was swift blowback. Critics said the tensions outlined in the document have been brewing for decades, so what's the surprise? Vatican insiders also insisted that Levada had written to LCWR in late February to inform them that results of the assessment would be discussed in an April meeting.

Yet the shock was nonetheless understandable, given the more conciliatory signals LCWR and other leaders in women's religious life had been receiving from the Congregation for Religious.

In broad strokes, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith believes that fundamental deviations from Catholic faith and practice have been allowed to fester inside some circles of women's religious life for too long, which they see as especially serious in the case of LCWR, given that it's a juridical person under canon law, approved by the Vatican, with a special responsibility to faithfully represent the church. The climate in the Congregation for Religious, meanwhile, tends to the view that now is a time for confidence-building exercises rather than what will inevitably be perceived as punitive measures. In addition, some senior Vatican officials, and not just in the Congregation for Religious, worry that the LCWR overhaul feeds images of a clerical boys' club hostile to women.

To be clear, the contrast, at least inside Vatican walls, isn't so much over whether the doctrinal assessment points to some real concerns. It's instead over whether the overhaul announced April 18 is the right way to address those concerns and whether this is the right time to do it.

Allen also suggests, that with U.S. Cardinal Levada retiring from the CDF next year, the proposed five-year overhaul of the L.C.W.R. may not prove as traumatic as many fear today:

"... in fairly short order, the Congregation for the Faith could be led by a non-American who might not feel the same personal investment in the process.

"To be sure, other personnel involved in the assessment won't necessarily be moving on and the Congregation for the Faith has a deep institutional memory, so Levada's departure probably won't signal a sea change in approach. It could, however, betoken a difference in intensity, and by itself, that might be significant."

You can read the rest of his frustratingly even-tempered analysis here.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Rick Fueyo
5 years 6 months ago
This line gave me a laugh

"You can read the rest of his frustratingly even-tempered analysis"

I have great respect for John Allen's reporting, and even more respect for the seeming state of his soul based on his writing.  But he reminds me of a beloved pastor we used to have that one of my colleagues said would shake the hand of Satan himself and bless him instead of judging.  That pastor was a good and holy man, and I strove to be like him in my dealings with all people. But he had a very difficult time actually judging any situation.
Helen Smith
5 years 6 months ago
Interesting to note that Cardinal Levada was working in the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (1976 to 1982) when Sister Theresa Kane R.S.M., a past president of the LCWR, made her famous plea to Pope John Paul II for the inclusion of women in all ministries of the church, including the ordination of women, during his visit to the United States in 1979.  
Maybe Levada has a long memory.
Jim McCrea
5 years 6 months ago
Levada has a SELECTIVE memory.


Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Cardinal Blase J. Cupich of Chicago speaks Nov. 13 during the fall general assembly of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in Baltimore. (CNS photo/Bob Roller)
Cardinal Bernardin’s consistent ethic of life could be helpful as the church grapples with issues like migration, health care and even taxes, some bishops say.
Michael J. O’LoughlinNovember 17, 2017
Giant machines dig for brown coal at the open-cast mining Garzweiler in front of a power plant near the city of Grevenbroich in western Germany in April 2014. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner, File)
“What we need to do is just continue to live out the challenge of ‘Laudato Si’,’ which is to examine our relationship with the earth, with God and with each other to see how we can become better stewards of this gift of the earth.”
Kevin ClarkeNovember 17, 2017
Hipsters love the authentic, the craft and the obscure—which is exactly why Catholicism, in its practices and its aesthetic, is perfectly suited for them.
Zac DavisNovember 17, 2017
In response to a query from America, Steve Bannon said, “The daily examen has become a tool for me to lead a better, more fulfilled life.”
James T. KeaneNovember 17, 2017