The Editors on the HHS Decision

Here is a sneak peek at next week's editorial:

For a century and a half the Catholic Church in the United States has served the American people with health care, education and social services. Even a few months ago it would have seemed preposterous to suggest that the U.S. government would place the future of those good works at risk. That seems to be what has happened, however, with a decision by the Department of Health and Human Services to allow only a narrow conscientious exemption to the employer health care insurance mandate of the Affordable Care Act, the administration’s signature health care reform law.

For U.S. Catholics as citizens, the administration’s failure to offer a broader exemption presents a grave test of the “free exercise” of religion protected by the Bill of Rights. For the narrow definition of religion in the new H.H.S. guideline is at odds with the millennia-old Catholic understanding of the church as a community of believers in service to the world. The H.H.S. definition would force the church to function as a sect, restricted to celebrating its own devotions on the margins of society. The ruling is a threat to our living as a church in the Catholic manner.

Read the rest here. And for more on the question of material cooperation, read Cathleen Kaveny's article from 2010.

Tim Reidy

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Thomas Piatak
5 years 7 months ago
Thanks for this.
Gabriel Marcella
5 years 7 months ago
This is an eloquent, powerful, and rigorous defense of Catholic principles in the public square. The question that remains is how this truly awful HHS mandate escaped the careful vetting process of the White House, especially for such a sensitive issue in an election year. It should be required reading for discussion in all Catholic universities, colleges, seminaries, high schools, hospitals and service agencies. Thank you, America editors.
Crystal Watson
5 years 7 months ago
"For the narrow definition of religion in the new H.H.S. guideline is at odds with the millennia-old Catholic understanding of the church as a community of believers in service to the world. The H.H.S. definition would force the church to function as a sect, restricted to celebrating its own devotions on the margins of society."

*

But Catholic colleges employ many people who are not Catholic and Catholic hospitals employ many people who are not Catholic  ... you cannot in all honesty call these colleges and hospitals "communities of believers".  And the fact is that almost everyone in those "communities" already uses contraceptives.  This HHS definition wouldn't make of the church a sect, it would recognize that the Catholic church is one church among many in a pluralistic society.
Jim McCrea
5 years 7 months ago
Just because a group is big doesn’t mean that it can’t be a sect. 
“A sect is a group with distinctive religious, political or philosophical beliefs. Although in past it was mostly used to refer to religious groups, it has since expanded and in modern culture can refer to any organization that breaks away from a larger one to follow a different set of rules and principles.” (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sect)



1054 brought the formal separation of the Latin and Eastern churches from what was once the one Christian Church.  I am sure that the Orthodox will aver that the schism was precipitated by the filioque controversy which, in their eyes, was a “distinctive religious .. belief.”

For a good eye-opening education (that you most likely did not receive in any Catholic primary and secondary school) read Philip Jenkins’ “The Lost History of Christianity: The Thousand-Year Golden Age of the Church in the Middle East, Africa and Asia – and How it Died.”

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

These photos were taken August 16, 1920, at St. Elizabeth's Hospital for the Insane. Salmon had been on a hunger strike for 34 days. (National Archives and Records Administration via the website BenSalmon.org)
The courageous witness of 'unarmed prophet' Ben Salmon—precisely one century ago—anticipated a major development in Catholic doctrine on war and peace,.
Barry HudockSeptember 22, 2017
On this week's jesuitical, we talk with Catholic rockstar, Audrey Assad.
Olga SeguraSeptember 22, 2017
Soldiers hold up closed fists motioning for silence during rescue efforts at the Enrique Rebsamen school in Mexico City, Mexico, on Sept. 21. (AP Photo/Rebecca Blackwell)
Reports of a girl trapped in the rubble of a collapsed school in Mexico City captured the world's attention, but the story was created by bad journalistic and government practices.
Jan-Albert HootsenSeptember 22, 2017
A woman holds up a sign during a rally against assisted suicide in 2016 on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Ontario. (CNS photo/Art Babych)
The American College of Physicians called for better promotion of palliative and hospice care, which opponents of physician-assisted suicide say are underutilized areas of medicine that could address concerns of patients facing difficult illnesses.
Michael J. O’LoughlinSeptember 21, 2017