Click here if you don’t see subscription options
The State of Israel celebrates its 60th birthday today. All Americans should take a moment today and think about this anniversary and why we too should join the celebration. Palestine was stuck in the Middle Ages in 1948. The Ottoman Empire had ruled the area for centuries until its collapse in World War I. A British Mandate governed the territory until 1948 by which time Israel had become a refuge for Jews fleeing persecution in Europe. But, throughout the centuries, pious Jews had prayed at every Passover seder "next year, in Jerusalem." Israel may have vanished from the political maps. It never vanished from Jewish consciousness or, for that matter, from God’s Covenant with the Jews. As Catholics, our relationship with the Jewish people could hardly be more complicated or more shameful. Antisemitism had flourished within and without the Church. Pogroms in Catholic Poland betrayed this hatred. The Dreyfus Affair in France was largely the work of reactionary Catholic monarchists. And, of course, the sad history of the Spanish Inquisition showed before the Holocaust the irrational extent to which hatred of Jews could lead a people and a nation in Catholic Spain. The Second Vatican Council and Pope John Paul II changed all of that. The Council denounced the charge of deicide against the Jews and brought about a new appreciation for the Covenant with Israel and the Hebrew Scriptures. John Paul II went to the synagogue in Rome and called the Jewish people "our elder brothers." (That ghetto had been created by his predecessors to "protect" Christians from the contamination of Jews although, in an odd twist, many Jews who fled the Inquisition in Spain came to Rome because Jewish life was less threatened there.) Of all the visual images of John Paul’s rock star-like trips, the most poignant surely was of a bent over, aging Pontiff placing his prayer note into a crevice in the Western Wall of the Temple in Jerusalem. He also finally ended the diplomatic scandal of the Vatican’s previous unwillingness to maintain formal diplomatic relations with the Jewish State. As Americans, we have a different reason to celebrate Israel. She is our best ally in the world. Part of this is strategic: ever since Harry S. Truman, over the vigorous objections of the State Department, recognized the State of Israel 11 minutes after David Ben-Gurion proclaimed the state’s existence in 1948, Israel and America have been in a strategic partnership. In an often chaotic part of the world, we had an ally that was stable and secure. But, there is a deeper reason than strategic necessity for the alliance. It has to do with shared values. Israel may have been born physically in what was once Palestine but it was born intellectually in the heart of the West. Its founders were European liberals and socialists, people familiar with the Enlightenment and its views on the proper role of government. In 1948, if you wanted to know what pre-war central Europe felt like and sounded like, the best place to go was not the war-ravaged remains of Berlin or Warsaw, but to Tel Aviv. Part of that cultural inheritance was a respect for the law of civilization. During the war that followed Israel’s declaration of Independence, the fledgling Jewish army was in desperate need of guns. The Irgun, a group of Jewish terrorists, filled up a boat, the Altalena, with weapons and ran the blockade outside the harbor in Haifa. Ben-Gurion, the first prime minister of Israel faced a dilemma. His army needed those weapons. But accepting them meant doing business with terrorists, albeit Jewish terrorists, who demanded their share of the weaponry. If he took them, he would be complicit in their crimes. If he refused them, Israel might not survive. Ben-Gurion ordered the Jewish Defense Forces to sink the Altalena. The order was carried out by a young captain, Yitzhak Rabin. The first premise of public morality in a civilized society is that might does not make right. In 1948, the fledgling Jewish state joined the ranks of civilized nations and she still stands there. It is a reason for all of us to celebrate. Michael Sean Winters
Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
15 years 4 months ago
Mazel Tov to the Israelis who founded the State of Israel with a sense of responsibility to the Palestinian people (including the Palestinian Christians) who already lived on the land. But where did Winters come up with pogroms in Poland? Does he know what the word means? And where did he come up with Jewish liberals founding Israel? Did he never hear of Zeev Zabotinski, who inspired Begin and Shamir, who was more fascist than liberal?
15 years 4 months ago
This opinion piece is either disingenuous or deliberate propaganda for the Israeli state. The simplistic confusions between a Jewish state and an Israeli state do not result in a clear account of the realities on the ground. It would be tedious to challenge all the misconceptions in the article; at least please envisage that an over friendly interest by a superpower is not necessarily to the advantage of any state. "Helpful" funding by an American supporter is bringing problems for the current Israeli PM Olmert. Read from today's Ha'aretz :- http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/982102.html
15 years 5 months ago
I am glad that Israel is celebrating its anniversary, but I am surprised that not a word is written in the article about the people who had lived on the land - often in harmony with the Jews who came. Many of these left, some were driven out forcibly. It is also useful to realize that some great Jewish philosophers, such as Martin Buber and Hannah Arendt - had serious reservations about the way that Israel developed and treated Palestinians and their concerns. In a time of intense conflict in the region, especially in Gaza, I am a little disappointed that a deeper analysis of Israel and Palestine was not offered in this blog.

The latest from america

A Homily for the Twenty-seventh Sunday in Ordinary Time, by Father Terrance Klein
Terrance KleinOctober 04, 2023
Rep. Kevin McCarthy, a Republican from California, leaves the floor of the U.S. House floor after being ousted as speaker on Oct. 3. (AP Photo/Stephanie Scarbrough)
There is a deeper problem than the chaos in the U.S. House: the question of what a government is for, and how it is to function beyond matters that a bare majority can vote through.
Sam Sawyer, S.J.October 04, 2023
Pope Francis did not attend Vatican II, but from the beginning of his pontificate, he set out with determination to continue its implementation.
Gerard O’ConnellOctober 04, 2023
I have spent the better part of the past two years trying to understand what synodality is. Today, it finally started to click.
Zac DavisOctober 04, 2023