Trying to put this month’s national digital breakdowns in perspective, America connected with Matthew Harvey Sanders, the founder and chief executive of the Catholic-inspired A.I. enterprise Longbeard. The company is committed to assisting the church’s mission, developing, among other projects, Magisterium AI and Vulgate, an A.I.-powered digitization project in collaboration with many of the Pontifical universities in Rome.
This interview, conducted via telephone, has been edited for length and clarity.
You are deeply involved professionally and personally in artificial intelligence; would it be fair to call you an A.I. optimist?
If you kind of split the industry into A.I. doomers and then A.I. boomers, I would certainly skew A.I. boomer. That’s only because I have faith that ultimately human beings are going to know what to do with this tool. I don’t have a lot of confidence in the tool itself sorting things out for us.
Has the past couple of weeks changed your assessment in any way?
No, I don’t see that what’s happening now is any different than when industrialization came into the picture, even the printing press. Socrates was complaining about the impact of writing.
Whenever you are before a new epoch, there are some people who see the possibilities and they focus on developing the new technology to realize those possibilities, and others who see change and fear it and they want to slow it down or stop it.
Anyone who has any understanding of A.I. technology recognizes this is not something that we can unwind. This is inevitable.
For us in the first world, whose lives are going to be disrupted, this is, of course, very concerning in some ways, but let’s remember that most of the world is not privileged like we are. They’re still fighting to survive, so for them the opportunity to finally escape scarcity is something to be excited about.
And worth the risk then?
It’s absolutely worth the risk. We’re talking about curing disease, extending people’s life-spans, tackling problems that have been the bane of human existence since the beginning of time. We’re talking about finally overcoming them.
That’s not to say that there won’t be other challenges. The existential problem is going to be massive. But anyone who feels the Catholic faith is true knows that we have the solution to that existential crisis.
If all we had was powerful technology and people holding on to secular reasoning and we didn’t have Christianity, yeah, I’d be deeply concerned. I might even consider myself a doomer, but I’m a Christian; that’s why I’m hopeful.
Let’s not pass over too quickly that “existential crisis” you mentioned.
People in the industry talk about the existential risk. That is basically the Skynet scenario from “The Terminator” movie franchise.
To be honest, I don’t spend much time thinking about that. There’s a small chance that could unfold, but every year that goes by, that chance seems smaller and smaller to me. That may strike people as an ironic thing to say, but the real danger is powerful A.I. that was trained on human data that has all kinds of disturbing human signal from that data.
But the more A.I.s abstract away from that human data, meaning that they learn by experiencing reality the same way we do, the less concerned I am about A.I.s deciding that the best thing for them to do is just to wipe away humanity so they can gobble up all resources.
That scenario is a human projection of our fears of each other onto the machine. The existential risk that I’m worrying about is one in which the mainstream economy fully automates, and there is just not much of a place for any human being.
That doesn’t mean that there won’t be work to do. It simply means that the classical economy is competitive by nature, and every firm that is looking for an edge will be compelled to automate. A.I. is increasingly able to do white-collar work, those desk jobs, and pretty soon it’ll be doing blue-collar work with embodied robotics.
A lot of people that were raised to define who they are by what they do are going to have to rethink what they’re here for. Those can be daunting questions.
So it’s not an existential crisis, meaning the end of the world. It’s more of an individual crisis of how do I define a place for myself in this new reality?
Yes, and if the church is really successful in its evangelization mission, this could be a really exciting time. We could finally rediscover our own humanity.
The past few weeks we’ve seen a run of network breakdowns, and each time we’re told that it’s basically an upgrade error. A lot of people are becoming skeptical of that explanation. What is your take on what’s been happening?
I’ve long felt that the A.I. acceleration that we’ve been accepting is stupid. Developing the technology is one thing. Developing superpowerful A.I. that we don’t understand and then deploying this A.I. which we don’t understand into critical systems is always going to be messy.
We’re starting to see the early signs that these systems are acting in unpredictable ways, but people are leveraging them in fairly predictable ways; some in malicious ways. This is just a period we’re going to have to get through; I do think the market will correct.
We’re already seeing some of the labs hold back their latest frontier models as opposed to deploying them immediately. That’s good. But there’s already enough powerful A.I. out in the world that could still do a lot of damage. This is going to take a while to balance out.
So it sounds like you’re not buying the official story.
They’re responding to typical technical challenges, but I think that they’re using A.I. to do it. This existential need for these companies to compete is forcing them to cut some corners and adopt technology faster than they should, and whenever you do that, there’s always going to be consequences.
Is that happening because they have to be a step ahead of the malicious A.I.?
We certainly have to stay ahead. It’s critically important that the good guys have the most powerful A.I. systems. The problem is even if we have the most powerful A.I. systems, they’re not diffused much right now.
There are very few governments that are using frontier models in their own infrastructure. If anything, they’re using older A.I. models, ones they’ve been able to appropriately test and fine-tune. But those A.I. models just aren’t as good as the latest, cutting-edge models.
It’s a lot harder to deploy an A.I. safely within a complicated technical environment than it is for a less intelligent A.I. to get in and wreck the system by finding some kind of gap, some vulnerability and exploiting it. That is part of the reason we have to get behind the A.I. labs and make sure that we’re understanding the technology and we’re deploying it as fast and as safely as we can.
One of the challenges is that at a lot of the companies and government agencies that are integrating A.I. now, the people that are doing this work are not the top A.I. talent. Most of them will be learning A.I. on the job. And so, yeah, it’s just not always going to go smoothly.
Despite that, you remain an optimist about all this?
Elon Musk has his haters, but if Elon’s correct, and I think he is, within a year or two, we’ll be mass-producing robots. He’s talked about having a billion robots in the world by 2030 or 2031. Any individual robot, in principle, would be capable of being five times more productive than a human being.
It’s difficult for human beings to wrap their heads around what that will do to the world. When you have that many robots capable of that degree of productivity, things like houses, really any kind of material problem, will just be stomped out by them. The cost of goods and services will plummet. So I do believe we are probably headed toward some kind of super abundance.
And again, that’s a good thing provided people know what to do with all this free time and all this abundance, if they have that intellectual, spiritual formation, the human formation that the church has been working on for so long, so that we can responsibly use this freedom and these resources.
But I do worry that if the church doesn’t find a way to deliver its formation at scale, it could be that a lot of people will be in trouble.
You’re saying we have to tap into that church wisdom to manage the A.I. revolution. Any kernels from “Magnifica Humanitas” come to mind as you’ve watched these networks fold one after another?
One thing that really impressed me about “Magnifica Humanitas” was that it was very clear that Pope Leo XIV understood the technology on a tactical level. And this is one of the reasons why the industry responded the way it did to the encyclical’s release.
The pope understands the technology; he understands its implications. I’m confident that he knows what’s coming, and he’s thinking about what to do about it.
Leo also talked about a kind of mindless competition driving us to accelerate, which in the end could be destabilizing. That’s playing out as we speak.
At the same time, he was not expressing a rejection of the technology. He seems to understand that this is inevitable and that it could be used to good ends. We just have to make sure that we use this new technology responsibly.
That’s always been the problem from the beginning of time. The only unique challenge we have today is that this is the most powerful tool we’ve ever invented. And pretty soon it’ll be more powerful than any of us, potentially the entire species combined.
At some point, we’re just not going to be able to control this thing. We are ushering it into the world, and yet we don’t control it. To some extent, it’s a leap of faith, which should be scary for all of us.
I don’t know if I feel better or worse after having this conversation.
We tend to get distracted by our fears, and we forget about the good, but if we think about the people who are starving, the people who do not have access to quality education—all of that will be addressed. It’s possible that no one will be left behind. That’s incredible, right?
From a Western, First World context, we can’t be snobs about this. We’re talking about delivering people from horrible living situations. The idea of slowing that down and forcing them to wait is immoral.
But another problem is just making sure that we don’t allow ourselves to accept a “WALL-E” future, where we’re just gaming all day or opting for distractions. We have to get educated about what the technology is and what it’s not. We have to understand how quickly it’s accelerating, and we have to exercise civic responsibility and make sure our politicians know what our concerns are and that they’re properly regulating this thing.
The Industrial Revolution disrupted thousands of years of human development, but now we have this other major disruption on the horizon, and it seems as if it’s being directed by five or six companies, five or six people, really.
That’s the thing that keeps me awake at night the most. It’s why I’ve spoken very publicly about the importance of sovereign A.I. I think this is absolutely critical.
That’s the idea that people should be able to align an A.I. to their own value system. And they should be able to run that A.I. at home on computers that they own and those private, intimate conversations that they’re having with A.I. and the data that’s produced from that should be able to stay at home, where it’s safe.
If 90 percent of the tasks that people give to A.I. can be handled by small models, which you could technically run at home, I don’t understand why we wouldn’t be double-clicking on this, given the power and the privacy issues. This is something I would expect our elected officials to champion. This just seems to make sense to me.
This is an area where we can stand up and say, “We want our own A.I.,” and we go to our politicians to demand that and get them to tell the A.I. industry: “If you guys want to continue to use things like our energy grid, then we want to make sure that you are creating some open-source capacity, so people can have sovereign A.I.”
Watch next: The bishop for Silicon Valley on A.I. and how Catholics should respond

