In a recent editorial (“A way out of the Vatican II liturgy wars: Priests should stick to the rubrics”), the editors of America rightly recognized that the Catholic liturgy “is often a site of contestation” and thus “a wound in the church’s communion and an obstacle to its mission of evangelization.” I believe this to be true. Our divisions are not only a scandal to the world but have become commonplace, acceptable and mundane to many Catholics.
“What do you expect?” we might say of those who think differently from us. “They’re the ones to blame.” And so we overlook the log in our eye and our all-too-human desire to avoid ever being in the wrong.
It can be tempting to say, as suggested by the America editors, that one way toward unity is to simply follow the rubrics of the liturgy. Pope Leo XIV used his recent catechesis on the “Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy” (“Sacrosanctum Concilium”), a key document of the Second Vatican Council, to instruct priests “to always uphold that respect for the texts and regulations of the liturgy which springs from an inner attitude of openness and trust in God, manifesting humility before His greatness and sincere fidelity to ecclesial communion.” He reiterated that call in a letter on June 29 to Cardinal Arthur Roche, the head of the Vatican’s liturgy office, saying, ‘In order to promote the dignified celebration of the sacred mysteries, we must emphasize the need for fidelity to the approved texts and instructions.’”
This may be a good start, but it is not enough to achieve oneness. Rubrics, or the words in red in the Roman Missal, instruct the priest about when and how to stand, sit, bow, genuflect, make the sign of the cross, etc. But they do not describe the meaning and purpose of the parts of the Mass in which they appear.
Rubrics depend upon the context established by two foundational documents. The “Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy” sets the theological vision for the Mass, while the “General Instruction of the Roman Missal,” expanding upon the theology of the constitution, identifies the purpose and meaning of each part of the Mass. Close readings of the former reward its students with a broad and deep understanding of liturgy, while the latter concretely explains the particular and overall trajectory of liturgical prayer.
To take one example, the “General Instruction” describes the introductory rites of the Mass as having “the character of a beginning, an introduction, and a preparation. Their purpose is to ensure that the faithful, who come together as one, establish communion and dispose themselves properly to listen to the Word of God and to celebrate the Eucharist worthily” (G.I., No. 46).
These introductory rites carry a heavy burden: Their purpose is to establish the oneness of the church at worship from the very start. They help the faithful orient themselves in relation to God, self and others. (And what does this look like in these divisive times?) The rubrics tell the priest when to bow, open his hands to pray and so on. By themselves, though, the rubrics offer presiders no orientation, no direction.
My readings of the Constitution and the “General Instruction” suggest an understanding of the Mass as a field of encounter on which individuals are engaged by the three persons of the Trinity. Our “work” is to become aware of standing within the presence of the living God as we are. The trajectory of liturgical praying involves persons becoming grounded in this awareness of who we are, in the very depths we habitually reject, and at the same time encountering God in the Father, Son and Spirit.
We attend to the divine presence in word and sacrament and in the presider, all in union with the others gathered together as church—for “liturgy is the action of Christ and the church” (“Constitution,” No. 7). The problem, as I see it, is that a hard focus on our liturgical, theological and metaphysical unity at Mass has yet to heal our divisions. Our gut-driven allergy to those who do not think as we do is so entrenched that only a profound healing of our stubborn self-will could reconcile us to one another.
Liturgical practice today offers an opportunity to become aware of the body of Christ in the world as divided. What would it look like to be engaged by Christ, by the Trinity, as a body mindful of our separation from, and disdain for, them? To understand that the banners of righteousness we fly over our liturgies (“We are progressive Catholics!” “We are traditional Catholics!”) keep us from existing as one body? To recognize what should be obvious to all?
The body of Christ in the world is gathered together each Sunday by the Spirit of God in communities characterized largely by political and theological leanings left or right. Each Sunday, many receive Communion while denying communion with those with whom we disagree.
Our divisions, our rejection of union coupled with our condemnation of them, could invite deeper reflection. A rush to faithfully comply with the rubrics would only paper over the deeper, painful human motivations that underlie the “liturgy wars.” Hurt, fear, resentment, sorrow—all those emotions in us that need healing. What if we instead used our divisions as a starting point for reflection and repentance rather than leaping over them to some other version of unity? What if all of us faced the woundedness of the church as rooted in our own personal lives? What if we all took a long yet compassionate look at our individual tendencies to separate ourselves from others? My friend Janie from the 12-step world shared a tough slogan: “If I’m not the problem, there is no solution.”
I see little to no possibility that Catholics will resolve our liturgical differences so that our divisions simply disappear. I see even less likelihood that you and I will just let go of our judgments about “those people.” Our divisiveness seems so deeply ingrained that the liturgy wars will endure even if we “stick to the script.” What to do, then?
Become aware of the log in your eye and not be distracted by the speck in their eye.
Become aware of motives that drive you to separate from others, including fear, old hurts, insecurity, resentments, sorrows and disappointments.
Become willing to be encountered by Christ incarnate, who meets us in word and sacrament in the very places you and I avoid.
Following liturgical rubrics could become part of a solution, grounded in the theological insights of the liturgy constitution and the vision of the “General Instruction.” But the more obstinate issue facing the church and human family today concerns you and I making ourselves available to be encountered by God in the very place where we divide and disdain others.
The author’s recently published book Mass Divisions deals at greater length with the topic of this article.
⸺
Roc O’Connor, S.J., is a member of the Bellarmine Jesuit Retreat House staff in Barrington, Ill. He is the author of the book Mass Divisions.
