Thirty-seven years ago yesterday, eight people—Jesuits Ignacio Ellacuría, Amando López, Joaquín López y López, Ignacio Martín-Baró, Segundo Montes and Juan Ramón Moreno, as well as their housekeeper, Elba Ramos, and her teenage daughter Celina—were murdered by Salvadoran paramilitaries in the Jesuit residence at the University of Central America in San Salvador. The killers fired more than 200 bullets in the attack, presumably to make it look like those martyred had been killed in a shootout.
The shocking murders—and the greasy assurances of the Salvadoran government and military that they would investigate the crime despite the fact that government outlets had been calling the Jesuits traitors in El Salvador’s civil war—became a political cause celebre far beyond the borders of El Salvador, whose government and military were heavily supported by U.S. military aid.
The leader of the outspoken Jesuit community at the U.C.A. was also the rector of the university, Ignacio Ellacuría, S.J. Almost four decades after his martyrdom, it is his face—that fierce mien and aquiline nose—that is most recognizable among the martyrs of El Salvador.
Born in Portugalete in the Basque region of Spain in 1930, Ignacio Ellacuría entered the Society of Jesus at the age of 17. He completed his novitiate in El Salvador and then spent his early Jesuit formation in Quito, Ecuador, before teaching philosophy for three years in El Salvador. He then went to Innsbruck, Austria, to study theology (among his professors was Karl Rahner). He was ordained a priest in 1961.
After completing a doctorate in philosophy at Complutense University of Madrid in 1967 (another of his teachers: the Spanish philosopher Xavier Zubiri), Ellacuría returned to El Salvador as a professor at the University of Central America in San Salvador. He would spend most of the rest of his life in his adopted home and became a Salvadoran citizen in 1975.
In 1974, Ellacuría founded the influential Center for Theological Reflection at the U.C.A. He also edited a journal sponsored by the university, Estudios Centroamericanos. In 1979, he was named rector of the university, a position he would hold until his death. In 1984, he co-founded another journal, the Latin American Review of Theology, with Jon Sobrino, S.J.
During El Salvador’s civil war, Ellacuría and other Jesuits at the U.C.A. offered strong critiques of the government’s actions, while he himself often served as an unofficial liaison between the government and left-wing rebel forces loosely gathered under the umbrella of the Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front (the F.M.L.N.). The war would claim over 75,000 lives in El Salvador and drive many more to migrate from the country.
By the late 1980s, Ellacuría was the object of constant public criticism and not-so-subtle threats from the Salvadoran government and its paramilitary forces.
For the ruling junta in El Salvador (and, let’s be honest, for many Americans then and now), Ellacuría and his confreres were simply Marxists by another name. As Phillip Berryman noted in a 1990 article for America, “Ignacio Ellacuría: An Appreciation,” however, “Ellacuría’s own thinking was independent of the Marxist left, and he frequently expressed his disagreement publicly.” (There’s a lot more Hegel in liberation theology than there is Marx, after all.) Further, in a 1978 essay on the Suffering Servant figure in Isaiah, “The Crucified People: An Essay in Historic Soteriology,” Ellacuría specifically quoted Karl Marx, Berryman wrote, “doing so, however, to distinguish the Christian understanding of the poor from the Marxist notion of the proletariat.”
Did Ignacio Ellacuría and the other martyrs know what was coming on Nov. 16, 1989? They weren’t completely unaware. A year before, the U.C.A. Jesuits had met with Peter-Hans Kolvenbach, the superior general of the Jesuits, in San Salvador. “I could tell they were aware that the Lord might ask their lives of them as participation in his Passion and that they had already made the gift of them,” Father Kolvenbach said in an interview published in the book Men of God: Men for Others and that also appeared in America in 1990. “By their sacrifice they have shared the fate of hundreds of other men and women, victims of battle and reprisal, subjected to the hellish round of violence and death.”
Tertullian’s famous dictum that “the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the church” is applicable here: One irony of Ellacuría’s death is that his ideas are far better known today than they ever were during his lifetime. Not only were his writings not well known in Europe or North America in the 1980s; he was not even the most prominent theologian among the Jesuits of El Salvador at the time. His murderers inadvertently created thousands of disciples of his work and his theological method and bolstered the influence of liberation theology.
Berryman wrote in 1990 that Ellacuría was not necessarily known as much for his theological and philosophical writings as for his public backbone in a precarious time. “What made Ellacuría a public figure in El Salvador was his forthright stance on public issues in his writings,” Berryman wrote, “his editorial guidance and intellectual leadership at the U.C.A.”
In addition to contributing to the spread of liberation theology beyond Central America and Spain, the events of 1989 also arguably caused the end of the Salvadoran civil war. The images of the martyrs dead on the lawn of their residence shocked many erstwhile supporters of El Salvador’s government and brought political and economic consequences almost immediately. Within six months, the U.S. House of Representatives voted 250-163 to cut military aid to El Salvador by 50 percent.
“Those who pulled the trigger and committed this heinous crime included men trained with American money, by American servicemen, on American soil,” Rep. Joe Moakley of Massachusetts said at the time. “American taxpayer money for 10 years now has not been used to build peace with democracy—but to destroy hope and build the private bank accounts of those who get rich at the expense of the Salvadoran people and the American people. This must end, and it must end now.”
A peace agreement in 1992 brought the civil war to an uneasy close. In 2020, a Spanish court convicted Innocente Orlando Montano, a former colonel in the Salvadoran army, of ordering the murder of the Jesuits in 1989. The conviction was bittersweet, noted officials of the U.C.A. in a statement, because even three decades later the trial could not be in El Salvador, but welcomed the modicum of justice the ruling offered.
The years since have not been without greater struggles for El Salvador; nor have liberation theology and its political applications always found a welcome home in the academy or in public discourse. But the witness of Ellacuría and the others remains a challenge to the status quo and to easy answers to political questions that are, inevitably, also theological.
“Ellacuría’s politicized gospel led him to ask not so much why Jesus died, but why he was killed; if we turn the question back on our author himself, the answer is loud and clear: for the ideas that he spent his life expounding and putting into practice,” Paul Lakeland wrote in a 2014 review for America of a volume of Ellacuría’s essays. “Being killed for your vision is one sure if bloody way of having its truth affirmed. In Ellacuría’s case, he died for his insistence that the Gospel calls Christians to build the reign of God in history, and for his efforts to make that happen. That should lead us to pay close attention.”
•••
Our poetry selection for this week is “One,” by Julia Alvarez. Readers can view all of America’s published poems here.
Other recent Catholic Book Club columns:
- ‘Gaudium et Spes’ and the optimistic final days of Vatican II
- Lessons from Donna Tartt’s fiction
- Michael Harrington, the ‘pious apostate’ who championed socialism in America
- Phyllis Trible, who challenged our image of God as male or female
- Jack Kerouac, Gregory Corso and a crucifix on a chain
Happy reading!
James T. Keane
