“Hi, I’m Mark Massa. What’s your G.P.A.?”
This was the first greeting I received from Mark Massa, S.J., on the second floor of Duane Library at Fordham University some 21 years ago. We were both at a champagne reception (there was always a champagne reception) following a lecture sponsored by the Curran Center for American Catholic Studies.
In addition to being terrifying, that first greeting was also ironic because never have I met a person more dedicated to the Jesuit principle of cura personalis—care for the whole person (and not just their G.P.A.)—than Father Massa. The founding director of the Curran Center, he was also one of the nation’s most distinguished scholars of American religious history. This was not an individual locked in the ivory tower, however. As one of his thousands of students, I know my own life’s trajectory would have been literally unthinkable without his intercession and interventions.
Father Massa died on Nov. 15 in his room at Spellman Hall on Fordham’s Rose Hill campus, a few hundred yards from our initial meeting. At the time of his death at the age of 76, he held the distinguished Loyola Visiting Chair at Fordham University while on sabbatical from Boston College. He was a Jesuit for 58 years and a priest for 46 years.
Born Sept. 13, 1950, in Shadyside, Ohio, Mark S. Massa entered the novitiate of the then-Detroit Province of the Society of Jesus in Clarkston, Mich., on Aug. 23, 1968. In some interviews, he misidentified the year as 1969. This misstep would come as a surprise to precisely none of his friends; as he often said, “Numbers come to me quickly, just not reliably.”
In between receiving master’s degrees from the University of Chicago and the Weston Jesuit School of Theology, Father Massa taught at Walsh Jesuit High School in Ohio during his Jesuit formation. After ordination to the priesthood in 1980 and a pastoral year at St. Peter’s Catholic Church in Cambridge, Mass., he earned a doctorate in American religion at Harvard University. He would spend the rest of his life working in Jesuit, Catholic higher education: 1987-2010 at his beloved Fordham University, and after 2010 at Boston College, returning to Fordham this year.
To say that he “worked” at these universities would be to ignore what Father Massa said countless times in recent years: “They say if you love what you do, you’ll never work a day in your life. I have certainly found that to be the case.” In his four decades as a professor, Massa taught, mentored, challenged and especially believed in countless students, undergraduate and graduate. And if Mark Massa was on your side, you felt like you could do anything.
Massa’s many books have become required reading among students of American Catholic history. His Harvard dissertation was published as Charles Augustus Briggs and the Crisis of Historical Criticism. Two textbooks, co-edited with Father Richard Viladesau, followed, both of which have appeared on countless university syllabi over the last 30 years. He won the Association for Jesuit Colleges and Universities/Alpha Sigma Nu Award for Outstanding Work in Theology for 1999-2001 for his Catholics and American Culture: Fulton Sheen, Dorothy Day, and the Notre Dame Football Team. (Another irony, as his friends will attest, is that he hated football, once saying: “Is that the oblong ball made out of pig?”) His favorite sports, he often said, were “reading” or “opera.”
Anti-Catholicism in America: The Last Acceptable Prejudice came next. He then co-edited another textbook in 2008 with Catherine Osborne entitled American Catholic History: A Reader. (My students will be reading from the second edition of this book next semester.) The last three monographs of his career were The American Catholic Revolution: How the Sixties Changed the Church Forever; The Structure of Theological Revolutions: How the Fight Over Birth Control Transformed American Catholicism; and Catholic Fundamentalism in America, published last year. These were all written, as Father Massa joked many times, in “deathless prose.”
As elegant a writer as he was, where he really shone was in the classroom. He was, quite simply, the best classroom instructor I have ever experienced. Class with him was, decidedly, an experience. Deeply committed to the Socratic method, Massa delivered rapid-fire questions to his students on the readings of the day, expecting them to be “alarmingly familiar” with the texts on the syllabus. And it must be said that he didn’t suffer fools—or students who didn’t do the reading—gladly.
You would never find things called “student learning outcomes” listed on his syllabi, but students in his seminars emerged more intelligent, more confident and more eloquent come the end of the semester. He began each class session with a thesis statement, and then spent the entire time trying to convince his pupils of the veracity of his claim. If he didn’t convince you, he would welcome you during office hours. Or during “Sherry Hours” (yes, you read that correctly), which took place weekly, where guests were always welcome, and where we would go around in a circle answering, “On a scale of one to 10, where are you on the Massa Stress Index?”
When it was his turn: “I haven’t been below an eight since the Nixon administration.”
Mark had a lot of loves in his life. He loved plotting against senior university administrators, so it was yet another irony that he became one when he was appointed dean of the Boston College School of Theology and Ministry in 2010. He loved presiding at the weddings of former students and baptisms of their children, although he could never guarantee a smooth outcome. Right before my wife and I processed down the aisle for our wedding, he whispered (O.K., shouted), “Just remember, the definition of a good Jesuit liturgy is one where no one gets hurt and everyone leaves with their dignity intact.”
He loved his students first and foremost. A common phrase was “You’re my favorite; don’t tell the others.” He cherished going out to dinner with friends (though if he drove, it felt like a miracle that you survived). Each of those dinner conversations was hilarious. Once, we arrived at a restaurant where dozens of people were waiting for a table. Having called days earlier to secure our table, he walked to the front desk and loudly announced, “We are a party of 17, and don’t have a reservation.”
If a server inquired if he or she could get us anything, he would reliably answer with either “a Tanqueray and tonic” or “a new president of the United States.” And did he ever love gossip about the latest news.
Another time, at a steakhouse in the Bronx, he advised me to order his favorite dish, a ribeye. He was paying, so what choice did I have? I dutifully ordered as I was told, only for him to request “my usual…the pork chops.”
Without a doubt, the thing that Mark Massa loved the most was helping his students discern their vocations in life. On the Feast of Christ the King 19 years ago, he asked me where I had decided to apply to graduate school. I stammered out a half-hearted answer, to which he replied, “That’s it, this will be ‘Dan Cosacchi Week’ in my office; make an appointment for one hour each day, we’ll have everything figured out by Friday.” And voila, just like that, we did.
When I had a job offer some years later that would have taken me away from work in higher education, I called him looking for advice. He was on his annual retreat, but that didn’t matter. As always, he had all the time in the world. We spoke for over an hour, seemingly getting nowhere. Finally, he said: “Just do your Ignatian discernment on this. You’ll know the right answer once you put yourself in front of the throne of God.” He was right.
Mark Massa departed from our company on Sunday. In the second reading at Mass that day, St. Paul reminds the Thessalonians that the day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night. For our brother Mark, that is exactly what happened. Yet, all of us who loved him should be consoled by the faith that he held dear, and which he expressed in the very last sentence of his published works, taken from another of St. Paul’s letters: “For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive” (1 Cor 15:22).
We will not see the likes of Mark Massa again. May he rest in peace and be made alive in Christ.
