Thomas Overton is scheduled to be executed at 6 p.m. on Nov. 19.

His death would mean a new annual record for the state of Florida—20 executions in just one year, breaking the previous record of 19 set last year. That record was more than twice the number of Florida’s previous annual record of eight executions, recorded multiple times in recent years.

“Thomas Overton’s case should draw attention to the horrific bloodlust in Florida,” Krisanne Vaillancourt Murphy said in a statement to America. 

Ms. Vaillancourt Murphy is the executive director of the Catholic Mobilizing Network, a restorative justice group working to abolish capital punishment. She and her team have long advocated against Mr. Overton’s execution.

The record-setting execution run in Florida does not appear to reflect the country’s shifting attitude toward the death penalty. Across the United States, support for capital punishment is waning, while many politicians are taking actions to reduce executions.

In Florida, a low barrier to capital punishment

Florida has conducted the second highest number of executions in the United States since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976. It is surpassed only by Texas.

That high number is partly attributable to the state’s especially low barrier to capital punishment at sentencing. Among states that still allow the death penalty, only Florida and Alabama do not require a unanimous jury vote in capital cases. 

Alabama requires 10 out of 12 jurors to vote to condemn a convicted person to death. Florida requires just eight.

“Florida is tragically out of step,” Ms. Vaillancourt Murphy said.

Nine jurors voted to sentence Mr. Overton to death.

He was convicted in 1999 for the murders of Michael and Susan “Missy” MacIvor, who was eight months pregnant. While DNA evidence connected Mr. Overton to the scene, he has maintained his innocence for 30 years. 

Ms. Vaillancourt Murphy emphasized that an execution is always a tragedy and an injustice, “no matter the harm [a condemned inmate] has caused.” But she noted that Florida has experienced the highest number of death row exonerations in the nation. Since 1973, 30 people who had been on Florida’s death row have been acquitted, pardoned or had their charges dismissed.

At a press conference last week hosted by the Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty and Witness to Innocence, three of these 30 men shared their stories. They called upon Florida’s Governor-elect Byron Donalds, a Republican, to halt executions and re-evaluate Florida’s policies on capital punishment. 

America reached out to Mr. Donalds’s office but did not receive a response. In a statement to The Miami Herald, a representative for Mr. Donalds suggested a moratorium on executions was unlikely, noting that the governor-elect “is a staunch supporter of the death penalty and will govern as such.”

Seth Penalver said he spent 18 years in prison for a crime he did not commit before being exonerated.

“I lost my grandmother, lost my father, my mom,” Mr. Penalver said while choking back tears. 

“I have not forgotten what it means to be on the other side of the prison wall facing death, trying to get someone to believe you. Respectfully, Governor-elect Donalds, please listen to us and please stop executing and review them.”

Another of the former prisoners on death row at the press conference, Joaquín José Martínez, had been incarcerated for four years before it was discovered that prosecutors had bribed informants who testified against him in the case.

Mr. Martinez stressed that his exoneration should be viewed not as a fortunate outcome but as evidence of a criminal justice system that is failing.

“I think it’s time to evolve. I think it’s time to change.”

Support for the death penalty at a historic low

Outside of Florida, some political leaders are taking strong measures to address problems with capital punishment in the United States. On Nov. 5, Gov. Gavin Newsom of California commuted the sentences of all 548 people on the state’s death row. 

“We cannot execute people in our imperfect legal system and remain true to our core values, first among them justice and human decency,” Mr. Newsom wrote in an open letter to the state.

Mike DeWine, the Republican governor of Ohio, said he, too, is planning to review and commute death row sentences before leaving office in January. Gov. Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania, a Democrat, paused executions in his state shortly after taking office in 2023 and has since called on lawmakers to abolish the death penalty.

Even Alabama’s Gov. Kay Ivey, a Republican who has presided over 28 executions since taking office in 2017, surprised the public by commuting the sentences of two inmates on death row over the past two years because of concerns about the fairness of their trials.

The shifting perspective on capital punishment is not just among politicians. A Gallup poll published last week found that support for capital punishment in the United States had reached its lowest level in more than 50 years. Only 49 percent of Americans surveyed said they were in favor of capital punishment for convicted murderers. It is the first time support for the death penalty has dipped below 50 percent since 1971.

Only 39 percent of people younger than 30 said they supported capital punishment, and only 28 percent of Democrats did. While Republican support was at 73 percent, that is still “one of the lowest [numbers] Gallup has measured for the group,” according to Jeffrey M. Jones, Gallup’s senior editor.

The poll was taken in the weeks after the botched execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee, an inmate on death row who became the first person to survive lethal doses of execution drugs. She was rushed to the hospital, put on a ventilator and treated for serious injuries. She continues to recover in an isolated medical ward at a women’s prison in Tennessee.

State officials have declined to say if they plan to attempt to reset an execution date for Ms. Pike. Her attorneys have asked Republican Gov. Bill Lee, who is set to leave office in January, to commute her death sentence to life in prison.

The botched execution of Ms. Pike seems to have provoked much of the recent repositioning on capital punishment—including the aborted plan to livestream a firing-squad execution of Nidal Hasan, the former U.S. Army major who killed 13 people during a gun rampage at Fort Hood in 2009. That execution is still scheduled for Dec. 3.

The Catholic Mobilizing Network continues to oppose all executions in the United States. Just this week, it sent letters from young people at the 2026 Ignatian Family Teach-In for Justice to Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Florida Board of Executive Clemency, urging mercy for Mr. Overton.

“Executions only perpetuate the cycle of violence, introducing more trauma to families, to communities and to society,” Ms. Vaillancourt Murphy said.

Will Martino is a Joseph A. O’Hare, S.J., fellow at America Media.