It’s been a heck of a couple of weeks for devotees of the coming digital Age of Aquarius. As it has so infamously done in the past, Microsoft got the cavalcade of computing breakdowns started on Nov. 12 when its Outlook and Teams networks crashed nationwide.
The Microsoft meltdown was bad enough, but it was followed quickly by the shutdown of the national air grid when the Federal Aviation Administration was forced to ground all air traffic just a day later. According to federal officials, a malfunctioning router and reverberating communications errors made flying unsafe. A nationwide halt was ordered.
The F.A.A. grounding had end users frantically scanning Amtrak schedules. But not for long! The sudden surge proved too much for Amtrak’s booking system, which braked to a near halt.
Back up in the air, thousands of flights were cancelled and many a weekend getaway completely ruined, but the mayhem was just beginning. Just a few days later, banking networks at major repositories of your money went haywire. This week, United Airlines decided to flop solo with another national system collapse, and even Apple’s networks went a little rotten. Anyone having fun yet?
NSANet, a classified internal communications network for the National Security Agency, became the latest digital flameout on Nov. 17. (I’m running out of ways to describe this phenomenon.) An N.S.A. spooksperson reported that the high-tech spy and surveillance agency was simply “updating” NSANet when a software patch blew out, insisting that there was no evidence of a cyberattack deliberately taking down the network.
I.T. chiefs at these corporate and government agencies similarly insisted they have found no evidence of cyberattacks to explain the escalating digital breakdowns. But their denials have not been enough to dissuade an anxious American public, which has become worried that something bigger is afoot.
Last month, for the first time, A.I.–enhanced malicious software intrusions struck corporate networks around the world. It didn’t help that the network crashes occurred just as a rogue wave of end-timer mania hit the internet following the Pentagon’s announcement of the FORTRESS readiness program (for “Federal Operations for Resilience, Troop Resources, Energy, Supply, and Survivability”).
The effort is meant to ensure that key U.S. military facilities around the world could operate for at least three months without outside support. Some analysts say the program is a response to strategic weaknesses revealed by Iranian strikes on American military bases in the Middle East.
The whole notion of such a grid-stomping crisis is, of course, just the sweetest music to the ears of the nation’s already paranoid (are they, though?) prepper community. Preppers were soon online spreading the message that something big was going to happen soon that would require the wisest among us to have a 90-day supply of canned goods and fresh water stashed in our backyard bomb shelters. (And if you don’t have a backyard bomb shelter, get on it!)
Our thoroughly post-modern lives are managed by a vast data stream running above, below and around us. Breakdowns are inevitable, but it is a little unusual to experience so many clustered so closely together and affecting such a broad array of different tech, economic and civil sectors. It is probably not much consolation, but in terms of the sheer breadth of network-crashing impact, other digital infrastructure collapses in the recent past have been much worse.
I’m looking at you, CrowdStrike 2024!
Also worth noting is a purportedly encouraging theme: The breakdowns have been the result not of cyberstrikes or other nefarious doings from the darkest corners of the web, but from the execution of malformed or poorly tested code during system “upgrades.”
That’s part of the reason the F.A.A. shutdown will require thorough investigation. Inside the Department of Transportation, fingers are being pointed at router upgrades begun by a long-term network contractor, L3Harris. But outside the agency, tech-gearheads have been wondering how recent A.I.–assisted software enhancements may have contributed to the systemic collapse.
Matthew Harvey Sanders, the founder and chief executive of Longbeard, a Catholic-filtered A.I. enterprise, tells America that he remains a tech and A.I. optimist despite November’s broad disruptions. (Read the complete interview.)
“Developing super powerful A.I. that we don’t understand and then deploying this A.I. which we don’t understand into critical systems is always going to be messy,” he said.
“We’re starting to see the early signs that these [A.I.] systems are acting in unpredictable ways,” Mr. Sanders said. At the same time, people being people, some bad actors are deploying A.I. “in malicious ways.”
“This is just a period we’re going to have to get through. I do think the market will correct.”
Mr. Sanders exhibited a bit of skepticism about the official stories and suspects that at least part of the problem will prove to be A.I. models used inappropriately on older systems. Because of the threats from A.I.-powered hackers, corporations and government agencies find themselves in an A.I. arms race. The good guys must win it, he says.
And some profit-driven enterprises are suffering from A.I. FOMO. They may be deploying cutting-edge A.I. models too quickly for their own—well, for anyone’s good.
The concentration of most human brainpower at the A.I. labs where the frontier models are being built is contributing to a human capacity problem, according to Mr. Sanders. There are fewer A.I.-skilled developers and administrators at work in the real world where breakdowns occur; fewer technologists who are equipped to understand what is happening and how to respond appropriately when crises emerge.
“Most of them will be learning A.I. on the job,” Mr. Sanders says, “and so, yeah, it’s just not always going to go smoothly.”
Who could have predicted this? Well, Pope Leo XIV already did when he likened our high-tech exuberance and hubris to the hyperactive egoists who threw up the Tower of Babel.
In “Magnifica Humanitas,” Leo wrote:
When a city is built on pride and the claim to self-sufficiency, communication breaks down, languages are confused and people no longer understand each other. The result is not unity, but dispersion. Babel thus reveals the limits of any effort that, however grandiose, arises from self-affirmation, sacrifices human dignity for efficiency and aspires to reach heaven without God’s blessing.
I’ve been a long-term “Big Progress” skeptic, so it should warm the cockles of my grumpy-old-man heart to see shiny, happy high tech unraveling this spectacularly. But a fella does have children stepping out into the world. That means he hopes all the digital wheels are not going to be flying off anytime soon, especially not everywhere at once.
We can find some consolation in the fact that corporate systems can also fail without any assistance from synthetic simulacra. The spectacular leadership crash at Nvidia required neither a fizzling router nor a yard of fiber optic cable, just one of the seven deadlies—a reminder that it’s not only an overreliance on digital innovation but old-fashioned sinning that can pull the mighty from their thrones and disrupt our future-so-bright visions.
On a happier note, while all these bleeding-edge systems succumbed to misadventures in overreaching, an example of some old nuts-and-bolts tech also made news this week.
Let’s reserve a huzzah for the people who built NASA’s Voyager 1 probe, which on Nov. 18, almost a half-century after its launch, reached a distance from Earth of one light-day. That’s more than 16 billion miles from this big blue marble in space, the farthest distance any human artifact has ever ventured. And it is still traveling on today, heading deeper into the vastness of creation.
More from America
- Is it time for A.I. to slow down or speed up?
- A.I., the Incarnation and the true source of human dignity
- Dignity vs. consciousness: a Catholic response to the A.I. wars
- The medieval understanding of intelligence is exactly what we need in the age of A.I.
A deeper dive
- The Trump White House is starting to admit that your bank account and airline tickets are under attack from rogue AI
- Concerns grow after spate of tech outages nationwide
- What a string of tech problems reveals about America’s digital vulnerabilities
- Digital Apocalypse: The Origins of the November 17 Internet Blackout Rumor
The Weekly Dispatch takes a deep dive into breaking events and issues of significance around our world and our nation today, providing the background readers need to make better sense of the headlines speeding past each week. Some recent reports: “Will Pope Leo’s call for universal health care be heard in the U.S.?” and “After an Islamist terror attack on a church in Jordan, are Christians still safe?”
For more news and analysis from around the world, visit Dispatches. This week: “Florida is setting a record for annual executions—but support for the death penalty is falling” and “Voters chose four new Catholic governors on Election Day. Does their faith matter?”
