Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York, in a lengthy blog post (on his recently launched blog), citing four examples, says yes.   Laurie Goodstein, religion reporter for the Times, in a detailed response on the archbishop’s comments, says no, offering a rebuttal on his blog.  Read the discussion here.  

The Rev. James Martin, S.J., is a Jesuit priest, author, editor at large at America and founder of Outreach.