At a sweltering meeting with missionaries and representatives of Indigenous peoples in the Amazon rainforest last Sunday, Pope Leo drew attention to an issue that has long affected Amazonian Catholics: the relatively small number of priests whose areas of ministry cover enormous areas.

“It is true that the laborers seem few,” the pope noted. “Your vicariate [a missionary jurisdiction roughly equivalent to a diocese], as large as entire countries, has only 25 priests.” The Vicariate of Pucallpa, where he was speaking, is slightly larger than Costa Rica or Bosnia and Herzegovina. Those countries have 834 and 667 priests, respectively.

This severe shortage of priests across the Amazon region means that many Catholic communities there “have enormous difficulties in attending the Eucharist,” as the closing document of the 2019 Synod on the Amazon pointed out. “Sometimes it takes not just months but even several years before a priest can return to a community to celebrate the Eucharist, offer the sacrament of reconciliation or anoint the sick in the community.”

Because of that shortage, that synod proposed that “criteria and dispositions be established by the competent authority” to train and then ordain to the priesthood “suitable and respected men of the community” who are married and “have had a fruitful permanent diaconate.” The recommendation passed 128-41, although it was the paragraph in the document that received the most “no” votes.

Pope Francis, in his follow-up document after the synod, chose not to address the proposal for mature, married deacons—often described with the Latin term viri probati (“proven men”), although that term does not necessarily apply exclusively to deacons—to be ordained as priests. In a 2022 interview with America’s Gerard O’Connell, Cardinal Mario Grech, the head of the Vatican’s synod office, said Pope Francis had revealed to him why he had not responded to the proposal.

“He told me, ‘Do you know why I did not accept that proposition? Because I felt that during the synodal assembly there was not a discernment,’” Cardinal Grech told Gerry. Gerry’s report of the interview adds that he asked Cardinal Grech whether he saw Francis’ non-response as “not a rejection” but rather as “a question that hasn’t matured yet,” to which the cardinal responded: “Yes. We need time!”

This week, more than four years later, Gerry was chosen by lottery to ask Pope Leo a question aboard the papal plane on behalf of the English-speaking journalists, and he chose to follow up on the question of ordaining viri probati. He asked Leo, in light of his comments about the priest shortage in the Amazon, “Is this an issue that is still open under you?” Pointing to the Synod on the Amazon’s recommendations and the fact that the question also arose during the consultations for the Synod on Synodality, Gerry asked, “Is the Holy Spirit not saying something to the church through all this?”

Pope Leo gave a lengthy response, first noting that when he arrived in Peru in the 1980s, there were “perhaps between 15 and 20 American Augustinians and two Peruvians” serving as priests in the areas where he worked. Today, he said, there are 35 Peruvian priests and few to no Americans in that region. That area, however, was not in the Amazon, and Leo noted that “the question of vocations” is “more complicated” in the Amazon region. He mentioned that three of the eight Amazonian vicariates, including Pucallpa, “have more vocations today. Other vicariates have far fewer. There is much work to be done.”

Turning to the proposal to ordain viri probati, the pope noted:

It is not the only solution [to the priest shortage], but it is a solution which, in certain areas of the church, can cause division because there is not universal, if you will, acceptance of that concept. And, as I also have made clear numerous times in this brief year and a half—or whatever it is—that I have been pope, that one of my priorities is first to promote unity and communion among us as members of the church.

Addressing what it might take for the proposal to be accepted, Leo said, “To promote an idea which the Holy Spirit may continue to suggest—but not just to me, for the pope does not change church doctrine—we all have to listen.” (Technically speaking, priestly celibacy is a discipline, not a doctrine, and, per the Second Vatican Council’s decree on the life and ministry of priests, celibacy “is not demanded by the very nature of the priesthood, as is evident from the practice of the early Church and from the traditions of the Eastern Churches.”)

Leo did not rule out the possibility of change in the future, but emphasized that his immediate priority is to heal divisions within the church. He acknowledged that “many people” disagree with his approach and said the question of married clergy in the Amazon would take time.

Leo’s and Francis’ responses raise interesting questions about the nature of synodal discernment. Even though the proposal to ordain married deacons to the priesthood passed with just over a three-fourths majority at the Amazon synod, Francis, as mentioned above, told Cardinal Grech that he did not believe genuine discernment had taken place. Leo raised a somewhat different concern: that the proposal still lacks universal acceptance and could cause division within the church. 

Interestingly, the final document of the Synod on Synodality, which Pope Francis adopted into his own magisterium, points out in paragraph No. 90 that while discernment seeks consensus and, if possible, unanimity, it does not require it. The question is how much agreement Pope Leo believes needs to be reached before moving forward with a proposal like this.

The concern for unity that Leo expressed is actually one that the Amazon synod’s final document anticipated: It proposed that the formation and ordination of viri probati take into account “that legitimate diversity does not harm the communion and unity of the Church, but rather expresses it and serves it, witness[ing] the plurality of existing rites and disciplines” (here it cites “Lumen Gentium,” Vatican II’s “Dogmatic Constitution on the Church”). It adds that some bishops “were in favor of a more universal approach” to the subject rather than a strictly regional one, as was proposed in the document.

The idea that different regions of the church can adopt different practices without threatening its unity also appears in the 2024 Synod on Synodality’s final document. In paragraph No. 124, the synod says that local churches can “move at different paces,” and that these differences can be valued as expressions of legitimate diversity and opportunities for mutual enrichment. The document does not specifically address the ordination of married men, but it raises a question about Leo’s appeal to unity: To what extent does a pastoral practice proposed for one region need the acceptance of the wider church before it can be adopted?

The final document of the Synod on Synodality also emphasizes that church leaders cannot simply disregard the results of synodal consultations. Paragraph No. 91, discussing cases in which consultation is required under canon law, says that church authorities must take the results seriously and provide a compelling explanation if they depart from an agreed recommendation. The next paragraph extends the underlying principle to bishops and the pope, whose decision-making authority remains intact but who “may not ignore a direction which emerges through proper discernment within a consultative process.” 

In other words, synodal recommendations are not binding on the pope, but that does not mean he can simply dismiss them without explanation. As I have previously reported, the synod’s canonical commission has recommended changes to Pope Leo that would give the synod’s guidelines legal force.

In the next paragraph, the synod makes clear that this obligation extends to the bishop of Rome, who “may not ignore a direction which emerges through proper discernment within a consultative process, especially if this is done by participatory bodies.”

Although Pope Francis apparently did not see the recommendation for ordaining viri probati as emerging “through proper discernment,” Leo may face the question anew, as the commission preparing a proposal for an Amazonian liturgical rite also plans to include a proposal for ordaining viri probati as priests and women as deacons in the Amazon. Around the time of Leo’s election, that proposal was still being evaluated by local churches.

When the Synod on Synodality took up the question of ordaining women deacons in 2024, Agbonkhianmeghe Orobator, S.J., asked a question to the prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith that also seems relevant to the question of the continued discernment on ordaining viri probati, an issue Cardinal Grech said was not yet “mature.”

“I eat a lot of fruits. And when I keep fruits to ripen and mature, I look for signs, the change in color, maybe the aroma, maybe the texture,” Father Orobator said in a meeting on the sidelines of the synod whose transcript was later published by America. “So my question is, what are those signs, those norms, those principles that we should be looking for, that you are looking for, to really judge that, ‘Yes, now is the time that we can say this is mature?’ Because if we don’t have those principles, norms and signs, we could be doing this for the rest of our lives.”

Colleen Dulle is the Vatican Correspondent at America and co-hosts the "Inside the Vatican" podcast. She is the author of Struck Down, Not Destroyed: Keeping the Faith as a Vatican Reporter (Image, 2025).