In my beloved Philadelphia, Rocky Balboa is essentially a secular saint. His image adorns clothing, ads and murals. Walk through South Philly’s Italian Market and you may see a jogging man in sweats leading a pack of picture-snapping tourists. A statue of him stands atop the 72 steps outside of the Philadelphia Museum of Art—steps which millions of people jog up every year, imitating the famous scene from the film. If you think this all sounds a little idolatrous, you should hear how we talk about Gritty, the Philadelphia Flyers’ mascot. But I digress.

“Rocky” (1976) isn’t just the most famous movie about Philadelphia: it is Philadelphia, the quintessential underdog city. We have a particular reputation for being gritty, maybe a little grimy and pugnacious. Our fans famously threw snowballs at Santa and are often cited as the worst in the country. Despite some recent golden years, our sports teams are usually miserable. And like any city, we have our social issues: poverty, addiction, homelessness and a homicide rate far in excess of the national average.

“Rocky” acknowledged all of that. It was the story of a working class, down-on-his-luck guy, considered a “bum” by everyone he knows, fighting in cheap boxing matches and collecting money for a mob loan shark to make ends meet. But he knows he has the heart of a champion, even if the rest of the world cannot see it. Rocky pursues his dream against all odds, in the hopes of finally proving that he is worth believing in. He embodies the hope and heart of a city with a perpetual chip on its shoulder, always striving to prove that it’s more than what it seems.

What’s incredible is that “Rocky” was also Sylvester Stallone’s story. He wasn’t a boxer, but a struggling actor, stuck in go-nowhere roles as Goon #3 in crime movies, until he wrote his own golden ticket: a starring vehicle to skyrocket him out of obscurity. The film went from an enormous risk to a box office smash that took home Best Picture at the Academy Awards. After years of being a bit of movie trivia, this incredible story now comes to life in Peter Farrelly’s new film “I Play Rocky.”

The film follows Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) from his early, dead-end days in Los Angeles through the film’s white-knuckle production up to its triumphant first screening. At first he’s sleeping in fleabag motels and the occasional doorway, his only friend a bullmastiff puppy he finds abandoned on the street. His luck improves when he meets and marries Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb), a co-worker at a movie theater who is the first person to see that there is something more to Sylvester than muscles and a distinctive voice. It is Sasha who first encourages him to write a part for himself that will showcase his gifts as an actor. A friend connects him with producers Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell) and Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne), who are impressed by his writing but not interested in buying it. Meanwhile, the stakes only get higher as Sylvester and Sasha prepare to welcome their first child, money growing so tight that Sylvester sells his dog for $40 to afford groceries.

But then, inspiration strikes while watching the Muhammad Ali/Chuck Wepner fight, and he writes the script that will become “Rocky” overnight. Chartoff and Winkler love it, but are baffled by Sylvester’s insistence that he star in the film. Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts), a studio executive, says the film will flop without a star and authorizes the producers to offer Stallone staggering amounts of money to sell the script and walk away. Sylvester sticks to his guns and eventually the studio caves, but under a set of harsh conditions: If film production falls even one day behind schedule, the studio will replace him and reshoot the movie. On a tight budget and an even tighter clock, Sylvester, Sasha and the crew head to Philadelphia to make movie history.

“I Play Rocky” bills itself as “The True Underdog Story,” and if the events of the film ever seem outlandish it is because, in this case, truth is stranger than fiction. “I Play Rocky” correctly identifies that a real underdog story is not about an up-and-comer who is secretly better than everyone else: It is about faith. Sylvester doesn’t just want to be successful; he is an artist who wants to do work that matters. “Rocky” isn’t just a career opportunity, it is a chance to say something important. His faith in himself, and the film, is so dogged that it becomes contagious. He converts the producers, his director, the cast and crew, until finally an entire theater erupts in cheers in response to his vision. It’s not easy and he frequently considers giving up. But “Rocky” is all about “going the distance”—not winning, necessarily, but proving that you can follow your dreams till the end. “I put my heart and soul on the page,” Stallone says in “I Play Rocky.” “If I’m not willing to live up to what I wrote, then what’s the point?”

Just as “Rocky’s” secret ingredient was Stallone’s naturalistic, soulful performance, “I Play Rocky” hinges on Ippolito’s performance as Stallone. From the initial trailers, I’ll admit, I worried that it might come off as an impression. But Ippolito is excellent, nailing not only Stallone’s voice and physicality, but imbuing the role with strength, sadness and heart. You instantly want to root for him. He is bolstered by a strong ensemble, including Jay Duplass as the wry Avildsen and Stephan James as a swaggering but good-natured Carl Weathers (who I wish had been in more of the film). Robb elevates the often-thankless role of Hero’s Endlessly-Supportive-Wife with spark and strength of her own, and Byrne and Kebbell have a funny—and ultimately moving—dynamic as Sylvester’s guardian angels. 

Farrelly, who won Best Picture himself for “Green Book,” shoots the film in an intimate style that stays close to the characters; he knows that the really compelling drama is not on the big screen, but in the hearts and minds of the people who bring the film to life. His crew recreates the grit of 1970s Los Angeles and Philadelphia, returning to several real “Rocky” filming locations in the process. The score, composed by Dave Palmer (and performed, he told me at the premiere, by an all-Philly orchestra), captures the hope and power of the original, occasionally quoting Bill Conti’s iconic work on the original. The film could so easily become mawkish or obnoxiously self-referential, but there’s so much genuine heart on display that it charms you from the start.

“I Play Rocky” succeeds for the same reason that “Rocky” still thrills and inspires 50 years after its premiere: It speaks to the underdog in all of us. We all know what it is like to face rejection, to feel that the world cannot see our true worth. And like Rocky, and Ippolito’s Sylvester, we know what it means to have a dream that keeps us going. Rocky’s story testifies to the truth that all dreamers know: Talent and opportunity are essential, but if you ever want your dream to come true, you’ve got to have faith.

John Dougherty is the director of mission ministry at St. Joseph's Preparatory School in Philadelphia, Pa., moderator of America's Catholic Movie Club, and author of Finding God in All Films: A Contemplative Approach to Watching Movies. You can find more of his work on his Substack, Roll Credits.