The documentary film “NAZA” is shot primarily on the rooftops of Tel Aviv. The faces of the 24 interview subjects are washed in shadow. These anonymized voices are members of the Israeli Intelligence Corps, and each of them has sat down to share with the director Yuval Abraham their experience of remote warfare in the “Swords of Iron” war in Gaza. A small circle of quiet forms around their tête-à-têtes, punctured occasionally by an air raid siren. The cacophonous traffic of Israel’s largest city seems far away.
Yet throughout the film, the camera drops in to the apartments behind the speakers, peering into the high-rises of Tel Aviv. Never showing faces, the camera lingers on the edge of voyeurism—the respectful amount of curiosity about neighbors’ lives that is expected in a city.
The camera slowly pans over the domestic scenes inside apartment buildings. Families sitting at home, watching TV, working on laptops. The eye of the camera absorbs pictures of comfort, coziness and security, while the voices of the interviewees share stories of how homes like these became their hunting targets. Captions remind viewers that the Gaza Strip is just an hour’s drive south of Tel Aviv, on the same stretch of Mediterranean coastline.
Abraham is an investigative journalist with +972 Magazine, an independent Israeli news outlet that is a collaboration of Palestinian and Israeli journalists. Abraham and his co-director Rachel Szor won an Oscar in 2025 for their documentary “No Other Land,” which covered the story of Masafer Yatta, a village in the West Bank that, like many others, has been the target of intense Israeli settler and military attacks.
“NAZA,” which premiered at the Venice Film Festival in September to a 25-minute standing ovation, is the story of how a genocide is conducted, straight from the mouths of the officers who conducted it. One of Abraham’s interviewees, when asked directly if he thinks Israel is committing a genocide, responds, “Yes. Completely.”
If you speak truth to power, of course, it’s not all applause and Special Jury Prizes at film festivals. Israel’s Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, has threatened to revoke Szor’s and Abraham’s citizenship. Netanyahu has also ordered an investigation into the identities of the intelligence officers who spoke to the filmmakers. Their voices are distorted and faces hidden in shadow throughout the documentary to protect their identities. Szor and Abraham have since fled Israel—and protestors have chanted death threats outside Szor’s family home.
“NAZA” has not been shown in Israel. But after its international cinematic release, The Guardian will be making it available, for free on its website worldwide in late November.
“NAZA” provides many examples of what Hannah Arendt called the “banality of evil.” Abraham’s interlocutors are not monsters; they are mundane—they argue they are simply doing a job. “If it wasn’t going to be me, it would have been someone else,” one interviewee protests. They speak about their work as if they are simply Silicon Wadi analysts going to work. From 2023—and still up into the present—Israel has been conducting what the United Nations has declared a genocide, with “unprecedented death injury and trauma” to children in particular.
Yet the intelligence officers are not sending down this rain of terror from the trenches or foxholes. They go out for lunch breaks and take smoke breaks and go out partying with their friends at night in Tel Aviv. In contrast, the “real-time targets” they strike have been living in conditions in Gaza that Mirjana Spoljaric, the president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, recently described as “worse than hell on earth.”
Naza, an officer explains to us, is the word used in Israeli intelligence to designate acceptable civilian casualties in the course of a targeted bombing. The “naza count” is the calculated acceptable collateral damage. The officers report that 20 naza are allowed if there is a chance of killing a Hamas operative. Naza counts do not distinguish between men and women, old or young—a homebound grandparent or a newborn infant. The algorithms of war do not differentiate between a toddler and a teenager. Each person is simply one more naza. One interviewee shares the story of a strike where 500 naza were killed in order to annihilate one person. He is not sure if they killed the target or not.
Israeli intelligence can track the movements of everyone in Gaza through smartphones. They know when a target is home through surveillance software on cellphones. One program, called “Daddy’s Home,” would read the texts of family members, including children, to determine when their father had come home for the night. Once the target is sleeping, the apartment building is bombed. The intelligence officers admit to targeting private family homes, like a fox stalking a chicken coop, because it was easier to find their prey at home at night with their families.
Spoljaric warned that the rules of war have been completely disregarded; no longer is there a clear beginning and end to battles, places where safety can be found. There is no safe home. This is not warfare—this is hunting humans.
In the summer of 2025 and 2024, international news reported stories of desperate, starving people being shot on their way to food distribution sites. At the time, the Israeli authorities insisted soldiers were protecting themselves from terrorists. The soldiers in “NAZA” report something different. They attest that they knew their targets were innocent, starving people, but they shot them simply to send a message. The rule was to stay on the bridge to cross to the aid distribution. If you left the bridge, you got shot, one interviewee says. There was no other logic to it, he says. Just the unabashed flex of absolute power over another human’s life. No logic can appeal. In Gaza, the human person has been reduced to a number, to target practice.
One man insists that he doesn’t hate Arabs; he says no one in his unit does. “And yet you kill them,” Abraham pushes back. “Well, that’s the mission,” the man responds. As though he has nothing to do with it.
It isn’t long before the viewer begins to shift uncomfortably in his or her seat and to ask: Doesn’t this remind us of something? Doesn’t this insistence on what might be called a “final solution” to wipe out Gaza once and for all remind us of something?
Finally, one young intelligence officer clearly connects the two points. “I grew up with the Israeli narrative,” he says. He went on a school trip as a young student to Poland. He toured concentration camps. He learned what the Nazis did—and he knew it was evil. Now, he tells Abraham, he understands how the Nazis eventually came to do what they did, how the system enabled them to kill numbly. “I still think that they’re evil,” he says, “so what does that say about me?”
The Palestinian writer Ayat Abou Shmeiss lost 35 family members in one of the airstrikes described in “NAZA.” “This is a film about Israelis, made by Israelis and directed first and foremost at Israeli society,” he wrote in +972 Magazine. “Its purpose is not to give Palestinians a voice, but to make Israelis look in the mirror.” While Shmeiss takes issue with the sufferings of Palestinians serving as a prompt for Western liberal self-examination, “NAZA” has indeed become the moral reckoning the world has longed for.
In another essay for +972 Magazine, Saleem Albeik, a journalist and film critic, wrote about how “NAZA” has brought an act of investigative journalism, done in the shadows, into the spotlight of international cinema. Movies, Albeik argues, are the lingua franca of our historical record.
“United 93,” the first dramatization of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, came out five years after the events they depicted. A few months later, Nicholas Cage starred as a firefighter in “World Trade Center.” As the World Trade Center Memorial Foundation broke ground on the 9/11 museum and memorial, Hollywood memorialized the tragedy in the amber of cinema. Both the films and the construction were contested—some families felt five years was too soon to begin reducing memories into the sensationalism of the movies.
But a theatrical release gathers attention. It cements the stories as part of a collective memory, a common experience—“monoculture,” it’s now called in the fragmented world of the internet, a global village now shattered by algorithms. “NAZA” turns the brave voices speaking from the shadows into part of the indelible record of history. It is the artistic form of the expression “never forget.”
We say “never forget,” and so here is “NAZA,” an aid to memories we would rather not have, of actions in which we would rather not be complicit. “NAZA” presents a choice, a necessary step toward reconciliation. We can listen to the stories of those who have repeated history and suffered for it. We can say “never again,” and we can mean it.
The Oct. 7 attacks have frequently been called “Israel’s 9/11.” Hamas fighters killed roughly 1,200 Israelis. Israel has killed more than 74,000 Gazans in the three years since. In this year of the 25th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks, the United States has uncomfortably reckoned with the destruction caused after the attacks. On Sept. 11, 2001, nearly 3,000 Americans were killed. The Watson School of International and Public Affairs at Brown University estimates that more than 940,000 people have been killed directly by “war on terror” violence across the Middle East and Gulf States between 2001 to 2023, more than 200,000 of them from the Iraq and Afghanistan Wars.
“As we act, let us not become the evil that we deplore,” Representative Barbara Lee, a Democrat from California, said in 2001 when she cast the lone dissenting vote against the bill that authorized the use of force for the executive branch to carry out the war on terror. Lee was quoting a clergy member in a memorial service for the attacks of Sept. 11. To be attacked is not to be exempt from moral reckoning. We can say “never again,” or we can allow violence to be repeated without end.
“NAZA” ends with a single scene that shows the human face of the suffering that has thus far only been rendered in numbers, software programs and target counts. It is just one scene, a kind of coda, but it still plays on the back of my eyelids. I can hear the timbre of the father’s ragged, desperate wailing for his children. Who would do such a thing to another person?
“NAZA” begs us to not go sleepwalking into evil. The ongoing decimation of Gaza asks us to look inside our own hearts, our own country, our own tacitly accepted systems of warfare, power-making and systems of alienation that run through every human heart. Who could be capable of denying the humanity of their neighbor so completely? Surely, not I?

