The National Catholic Review

August 3, 2009

Vol. 201 No. 3Whole No. 4862 Download PDF

Editorials

A Shabby Welcome
Iraqi refugees in the United States face harsh pitfalls.

Articles

Torture and the Rule of Law
The Editors
A symposium
Legal Obligations
William Michael Treanor
The proper role of White House lawyers
Truth and Consequences
David Cole
The case for a commission on torture
No Excuses
Mary Ellen O'Connell
Our obligation to prosecute human rights violations

Books and Culture

Culture
The Faith of Abraham
Thomas R. Murphy
God and the Great Emancipator
Art
Michelangelo for Moderns
Jon M. Sweeney
The artist James Ensor had a wicked sense of humor and was obsessed with religious imagery. View slide show.
Film
Cops and Robbers
Richard A. Blake
“Public Enemies” resurrects a perennial tragic hero for one more ritual slaughter.

Columns and Departments

The Word
Nourishing Word
Barbara E. Reid
The Word
Food for Life
Barbara E. Reid
Faith in Focus
The Eyes of a Child
Stephen Martin
Columns
Filling the Gaps
Maryann Cusimano Love
Of Many Things
Of Many Things
Drew Christiansen
Letters
Letters

Web Only

  A Call for Truth and Trust
Maryann Cusimano Love
Daily I receive emails, often from Nigeria, offering financial partnerships and lots of easy money. You likely receive them too. The themes vary, from estates left unclaimed to widows needing assistance from corrupt government bureaucrats, but usually they boil down to a pledge that huge sums will be deposited in my bank account if I merely divulge my account numbers. Why do we delete these emails? Because we don’t believe the information is true and we don’t trust the “business partners.” What do we do when the entire economy becomes a Nigerian email scam? This is essentially what has happened to us in the global economic crisis. People, investors, and banks have lost trust because they don’t believe economic players are telling the truth, and so they are unwilling to do business with them. Banks stopped lending, individuals stopped buying investments, due to a loss of trust and truth across the global market. For most of us, our eyes glaze over at talk of the causes of the current economic crisis. Complex derivatives, subprime mortgages, overleveraging of corporations, inflated rating systems, dark markets—the terms and practices are convoluted and opaque. Pope Benedict XVI’s summary of the problem is not. The pope’s recent encyclical, “Caritas in Veritate,” offers ethical standards for the global economy. Economies need truth and trust to work. Absent those they do not work. We have to put people before profits. When we don’t the whole enterprise comes tumbling down. As the pope notes, “Without truth, without trust and love for what is true, there is no social conscience and responsibility, and social action ends up serving private interests and the logic of power, resulting in social fragmentation, especially in a globalized society at difficult times like the present…I would like to remind everyone, especially governments engaged in boosting the world’s economic and social assets, that the primary capital to be safeguarded and valued is man, the human person in his or her integrity.” We cannot blame only Bernie Madoff, Nigerian scam artists or a few unscrupulous individuals for the recession. The lying, lack of full transparency and insufficient attention to love of neighbor, the common good and justice was widespread. Individuals, banks, investment companies, insurance companies and major corporations lied (even to themselves) or were not fully transparent or were misled about how much income and debt they had, what their assets and liabilities were worth, how much risk they were exposed to and were exposing others to, and how much risk and debt they could afford. When the deceptions (and lack of full transparency) became apparent, trust disappeared and so did the market. Credit froze and people pulled their money out of banks and investments because they didn’t know who was telling the truth and who to trust anymore; good businesses and business people suffered along with the unscrupulous ones. When the markets died so did people; the poor and most vulnerable around the world suffer the most as they lose jobs, food, homes and health. One hundred million more people now go hungry than when this crisis began. Charities lost their investments and donations dried up precisely when more people need their services.  Beyond Profits
  The Pope's Call for Charity
Maryann Cusimano Love, Blase J. Cupich
Two contributors consider Benedict XVI's encyclical on the economy