Righteous Among Women: Dan Gordon's 'Irena's Vow': a review and an interview

When my friends and I discussed this year’s Academy Awards, I frequently expressed my lack of enthusiasm for the Best Picture winner, “Slumdog Millionaire.” While I admitted that it was beautifully filmed and cleverly structured, I could not buy the amazing coincidences that connected every question with a traumatic event in the young man’s life, as well as the similarly incredible escapes from the mortally dangerous circumstances that led him to his beloved. The only rationale for such a tall tale comes in the final shot, which displays the words: “It is written.” Destiny rules.

Then I saw the new Broadway play, “Irena’s Vow.” It tells an equally incredible but true story of a young Polish Catholic woman, Irena Gut Opdyke, who, while forced to work as a housekeeper for an S.S. officer, Major Eduard Rugemer, managed to hide a dozen Jews in the basement of the officer’s house. Her ingenious methods of keeping the people hidden, fed and cared for are especially tested when one of the women in hiding becomes pregnant.

While several refugees urge the woman to abort the child for their own safety, Irena reveals that after she had stood by watching helplessly as Nazi soldiers brutally slaughtered dozens of men, women and children, she vowed that she would save any life whenever she had the power to do so. During the baby’s delivery, Irena drowns out the mother’s screams by playing Wagner full blast on the major’s phonograph. She finds similar ways of keeping the child’s cries from being heard upstairs. The near-discoveries and the various ruses to keep the Jews’ presence a secret for two years, as Irena herself admits to the audience, “would be farcical if they weren’t about life and death.”

The playwright, Dan Gordon, whom I recently interviewed, is convinced of the presence of a “divine hand” in the narrative, a design or a plan that matches the “Slumdog” belief in what is “written.” Gordon has evidence to support his theory. While the play ends with the release of Irena and her Jewish friends when the Russians drive the Germans out of their town, the subsequent twists in her fortunes only heighten the sense of destiny that shaped the rest of Irena’s days. As the Germans were driven out, Irena was arrested by the Russians as a partisan and sentenced to a labor camp in Siberia.

However, the very Jews who had hidden in the S.S. officer’s basement managed to smuggle her out of the local prison camp. A United Nations High Commissioner, visiting the camp, heard her story and arranged her transfer to the United States, where she worked in New York City for several years. By another sheer coincidence, Irena and the U.N. official met a few years later in New York, married and moved to Southern California, where she spent the rest of her life until her death in 2003. Her name now appears next to Oskar Schindler’s on the wall in Jerusalem that honors the “Righteous Among the Nations,” the title given to Gentiles who risked their lives to aid and save Jews during the Holocaust.

Gordon, whose credits include the screenplays for “The Hurricane” and “Wyatt Earp,” the stage adaptations of “Rain Man” and “Terms of Endearment,” as well as several novels, was captivated by Irena’s story when, again by happy coincidence, he heard her being interviewed on his car radio almost 10 years ago. When he met Irena, he found her to be “totally at peace with herself, wise and even fun” with a “pixie-ish” sense of humor. He discovered that she avoided bitterness about the past and had, in fact, not talked about her experiences for almost 30 years. Only when she answered the telephone one day from a high school student who was taking a survey on the question of whether the Holocaust had really happened did she decide that it was time to tell her story, especially to children, for whom she felt a special responsibility.

The current production, which had a successful run last year Off-Broadway, stars the award-winning actress Tovah Feldshuh, who first appears onstage as the 80-year-old Irena telling her story to a group of high school students. After a few minutes, she is transformed into a 20-year-old in the service of Major Rugemer (Thomas Ryan). Throughout the rest of the play’s 90 minutes she interacts with her employer, other Nazi officers and her Jewish charges, with an occasional address or side-remark to the audience, never leaving the stage as her character careens from crisis to crisis in a battle of wits and physical daring.

Gordon describes Ms. Feldshuh as “a force of nature” in her portrayal of a woman who refuses to lose hope throughout one of the most horrible events in history. Thomas Ryan presents Major Rugemer as a mixture of Germanic discipline and the all-too-human loneliness that accompanies an authoritarian existence. The rest of the characters in the play, unfortunately, tend to fall into the stereotypes of the Jewish victims or the Nazi masochists, paling in comparison with the rich characterization of Irena and the major.

At the end of the performance I attended, the audience gave a prolonged standing ovation. I suspect that this play will live on well beyond Broadway in a film version that is being considered, as well as in many regional theaters around the country. As a historical record of the horrors of the Nazi regime, it joins the stories of Anne Frank, Oskar Schindler, Elie Wiesel and others. As a testimony to the power of the human spirit and, indeed, of spirituality itself, it delivers a timeless message.

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Edward Lally (center) is joined by his schola, Sarah Coffman, Katherine Keberlein, Ngaire Bull and Sarah Beatty, at St. Edward's Catholic Church in Chicago on April 8, 2017. Photo courtesy of Sarah Beatty.
With chant “you’re expressing something in pure melody."
Judith ValenteApril 25, 2017
Vivian Tuttle holds a photo of her daughter Yvonne, who was murdered during a 2002 bank robbery in Norfolk, Neb., as she testifies in favor of the death penalty at a public hearing in Omaha, Neb. in October 2016 (AP Photo/Nati Harnik, file).
The fight against the death penalty lays bare the strengths and weaknesses of the Catholic approach to pro-life issues.
Joseph P. HooverApril 25, 2017
Bill Nye's gags are every bit as goofy as they were in the ’90s. But his new show on Netflix is weighed down by a condescending attitude.
Eric Sundrup, S.J.April 25, 2017
A rally hosted by Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont for a Nebraska Democrat prompted a flurry of questions about the party's pro-choice orthodoxy.
Michael O'LoughlinApril 24, 2017