Answered Prayers Can Be Disconcerting

Can answered prayers be disconcerting?  Saturday morning I encountered a minor disaster. After taking the 7:23 a.m. train to the city to attend a NYU Bioethics conference on The Moral Brain, I found the subway stop closed for construction. To get out of the rain and save time I jumped into a taxi intent on getting to the 8:30 talk on “The Moral Life of Babies.”


I was in the door at the registration desk when I made the awful discovery that I had left my purse in the taxi.  Wallet, license, address book, $150, five credit cards, keys, cell phone, pen, pencils and lipstick were gone, though I had careful hold of my umbrella and meeting folder. How could I call anyone for help, buy lunch or get back home? A desperate prayer burst from my lips:  “Oh God, please, please, I really need your help this time.”

 Right away the kind security guards on duty supplied me with a cell phone, pen, paper and the relevant emergency numbers to contactl.  No, of course I had no receipt, or note of the taxi’s number.  Then reasoning that these lectures would be the most expensive ones I would ever attend, I hurried into the auditorium.   

 Sunk costs must be left behind.  Besides I could rationally recognize that this was a small potatoes problem.  At my age I could be in real trouble from heart disease, cancer, or dementia.  This loss would only entail extreme inconvenience and distressing pangs of shame and self-reproach.  And hadn’t I written books explaining how God allows mischance in the world, as the necessary concomitant of our freedom?  

So while intently taking notes with my borrowed pen and well in the next presentation contrasting the morality of Kant and Aristotle, I looked up to see a security guard beckoning me.  He came to call me out because the taxi driver had returned my purse ! This upright Asian American citizen had made the effort to recall the drop site and come looking for me. Here was a real life instance of a moral brain in action.  Refusing any money beyond the price of his trip, he even bore up well under my deliriously grateful embrace.    

I, however, was emotionally unsettled by this surprising good news. Now I could avoid shamefacedly confessing ineptness to my family. (They don’t read my blogs.) But whether I did or not, I still had to recognize my dependence on others and how vulnerable to accidents and mistakes I can be.        

 Theologically I had to wonder whether I might be giving too little credence to answered prayers.  As I was prayerfully turning over these concerns last night, I felt God sending me a half- humorous message, “And did you really think I couldn’t rescue you?”  Good point.  If I can’t handle answered prayers here and now, how will I ever be ready for God’s eternal “Yes?”

5 years 1 month ago
Wow!  It's really true that God is ever ready with His Divine Graces (gifts), but we are so distracted to notice.   It's only when we are vulnerable and accept our total dependence on Him that we notice His Graces.    And what a surprise indeed!!!
David Pasinski
5 years 1 month ago
Confirming our basic prayers "Help!!!" and "Thank you..." Amen

Ther tomes on intercessory prayer aside, been there (more of less) and touched by the goodnesss of strangers...
John Barbieri
5 years 1 month ago
What a happy story!
Hurray for the taxi driver!
Most of us want to do the right thing!
So many of our dufferences are overblown and of little consequence. 
Carolee Gifford
5 years 1 month ago
I enjoyed reading this well-written article.
Another disconcerting question can be when it becomes apparent to us that we can be part of the answer to a prayer we are offering.  This experience happened to me as a trauma chaplain.  When I would pray for the families of a trauma victim to be surrounded by help and love, I realized, very humbly, that my simple ministrations of coffee, blankets, and communication with the medical team, could be construed as an answer to prayer.
This realization was not always met with enthusiasm.
Still, it helped me realize throughout my life that we as Christians are called sometimes to be the answer - whether we like it or not!
5 years 1 month ago
Yes, answered prayer can be disconcerting, I mean disturbing to some,  especially  if something small is involved, like $5. I don’t remember why $5 was so important at the time about thirty years ago. But on my way home from work I prayed earnestly for $5. As I walked up to my apartment, there on a step in front of me was a $5 bill Coincidence?  For me, gratitude was instant. Some may ask, “Why just $5 and not more from God?” Because, as I later better understood, prayer (God) is concerned with “need” not “greed!” It also has something to do with trust.  I think that’s a pretty good lesson applicable to all prayer.

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

In this photo taken May 19, 2017, a GPO worker stacks copies of "Analytical Perspectives Budget of the U.S. Government Fiscal Year 2018" onto a pallet at the U.S. Government Publishing Office's (GPO) plant in Washington. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster)
The budget’s moral measure will be assessed by “how well it promotes the common good of all,” the bishops write.
Kevin ClarkeMay 22, 2017
A veteran activist provides a blueprint for creating a movement in the moment of Trump.
Nathan SchneiderMay 22, 2017
Given the number of those in the California legal system today who are Latino, “you can guess a large percentage of them are Catholic.”
Jim McDermottMay 22, 2017
Pope Francis waves during a visit to give an Easter blessing to homes in a public housing complex in Ostia, a Rome suburb on the Mediterranean Sea, May 19 (CNS photo/L'Osservatore Romano).
Vatican leaders seem quietly confident that the meeting will go well.
Gerard O'ConnellMay 22, 2017