Right Carpet; Wrong Cardinal

As noted below, yesterday Cardinal Schoenborn of Vienna met with Pope Benedict at the Vatican. Rocco called the meeting "Vienna carpeted" indicating that Schoenborn was crawled on the Vatican carpet for remarks he made previously, directed against Cardinal Sodano’s handling of the clergy sex abuse crisis. The statement that followed the audience between the Austrian cardinal and his former professor, which was later joined by both Sodano and Cardinal Bertone, was unprecedented. It was also unfortunate. While it is good to see Pope Benedict taking a hands-on approach to the crisis, it appears he got the right carpet but the wrong cardinal.

In an interview a few months back, Schoenborn said that Sodano’s remarks before the Easter Mass, dismissing the renewed focus on the clergy sex abuse crisis as "petty gossip" had caused more harm to the victims of that abuse. He also said that in the 1990s, then-Cardinal Ratzinger had supported the effort to investigate the allegations of pedophilia against Schoenborn’s predecessor, Cardinal Hans Groer, but that Sodano had successfully nixed the investigation.

The Vatican statement after the meeting yesterday explained that Schoenborn had misunderstood Sodano’s remark at Easter. Curiously, it did not mention the issue about Groer. But, the statement contained this sentence: "It is recalled that in the Church, when accusations are made against a Cardinal, the competence [of judgment] rests solely with the Pope; other instances have a function of consultation, always with the proper respect for persons." I read that and said to myself, "So, at the Vatican, it is still more important to follow proper protocol than it is to speak the truth."

Last night I re-watched Jason Berry’s fascinating documentary on the Legionaries of Christ and their serial-pedophile, drug addict founder, Father Marcial Maciel. Everything about the Legionaries creeps me out – the ties to fascists, the military metaphors, the unholy vow never to speak ill of Maciel, the targeting of the powerful, the influential and, above all, the rich for recruitment. The documentary, "Vows of Silence," clearly established the close relationship between Sodano and Maciel and the way the Vatican refused to deal with the allegations against Maciel during John Paul’s last years. Only after John Paul II died, and Sodano lost his influence, was Maciel removed from public ministry. Since the release of the documentary, Berry has further demonstrated the relationship between Maciel and Sodano, including charges of large cash payments to the Vatican cardinal. Even if only half of the charges leveled against Sodano by his accusers are true, even if only a tenth are true, it is difficult, and painful, to believe that he still holds a position of influence within the counsels of the Holy Father.

Recently, at a social gathering, a Vatican official introduced me to someone I had not met before as "the great defender of Pope Benedict from the shoddy reporting of the New York Times." I was deeply honored by the compliment. I could scarcely admire Pope Benedict more than I do, and I think I admire him more than almost all of my acquaintances. But, I cannot defend him from his own bad judgment. Perhaps the Cardinal of Vienna spoke out of school. There are worse sins. It is clear that Cardinal Sodano was at the center of the ring of protection the Vatican threw around one of the most evil men to ever wear a Roman collar. That is a worse sin.



david power
6 years 10 months ago
Hastily spoken truth or truth out of school as you put it can lead to division and that is what the Pope is probably trying to avoid.You can be sure that the Pope has a similar vision of Sodano to that of Schoenborn but realizes that we must be careful not to devour one another as he said last year. Sodano wins the battle and Schoenborn the war.The game is up and they all know it. Schoenborn at this stage is trying to help the Pope ,his friend .He does not care what people think ,he is not interested in the bella figura . When the doors of the Sistine are closed again the wind will blow north one way or another .  
charles jordan
6 years 10 months ago
The only context by which Archbishop Benedict's action makes sense is that the Archbishop of Rome used a very minor error of Schoenborn's; which was to rightly, if not correctly, criticize Sodano in public; so that he, Benedict xvi,  shows that he has control of the issues Schoenborn raised. Thus the Archbishop of Rome created a spectacle showing that he is in charge.
Further in this scenario, Sodano already has a noose around his neck whether he knows it or not.  In as much as Sodano is sitting on a one legged milking stool, it is only a matter of time before we see that he is allowed to swing in the ecclesial wind.
In short, Archbishop Benedict has insured that we see Sodano muddied by his own deeds, and crushed by his own failures, without the distraction of or problems of incorrect processes of fraternal correction.
John McCloskey
6 years 10 months ago
At one time or another we are all called to say, with Peter: "We must obey God rather than men." Promises of obedience and ecclesial comity cannot be allowed to trump the obligation to speak the truth in charity. If cardinals are called on the carpet for saying what is obvious, how can the pope ever hear the truth, and how can the Church be credible? 
ed gleason
6 years 10 months ago
In the next conclave Schoenborn will be inside the room and Sodano will not be seen after opening ceremonies . .
Mark Kolakowski
6 years 10 months ago
So much for all those exhortations during homilies or in Catholic classrooms that a good Catholic should not be afraid "to speak to power." Of course, all but the most incredibly naive already knew that this is yet another "do as we say but not as we do" dictum.
Jim McCrea
6 years 10 months ago
"So much for all those exhortations during homilies or in Catholic classrooms that a good Catholic should not be afraid 'to speak to power.' "
Catholic pious pablum at its very worst.

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Pope Francis listens to a question from Vera Shcherbakova of the Itar-Tass news agency while talking with journalists aboard his flight from Cairo to Rome April 29. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
The situation in North Korea, he added, has been heated for a long time, "but now it seems it has heated up too much, no?"
Gerard O'ConnellApril 29, 2017
Pope Francis greets children dressed as pharaohs and in traditional dress as he arrives to celebrate Mass at the Air Defense Stadium in Cairo April 29. (CNS photo/L'Osservatore Romano)
Francis took the risk, trusting in God. His decision transmitted a message of hope on the political front to all Egyptians, Christians and Muslims alike, who are well aware that their country is today a target for ISIS terrorists and is engaged in a battle against terrorism.
Gerard O'ConnellApril 29, 2017
Pope Francis greets the crowd as he arrives to celebrate Mass at the Air Defense Stadium in Cairo April 29. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
The only kind of fanaticism that is acceptable to God is being fanatical about loving and helping others, Pope Francis said on his final day in Egypt.
U.S. President Donald Trump talks to journalists in the Oval Office at the White House on March 24 after the American Health Care Act was pulled before a vote. (CNS photo/Carlos Barria, Reuters)
Predictably Mr. Trump has also clashed with the Catholic Church and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on many of the policies he has promoted during his first 100 days.
Kevin ClarkeApril 28, 2017