Road to Redemption: The opera 'Porgy and Bess' comes to Broadway

Porgy and Bess,” a slimmed down “Broadway musical” version of the 1935 opera by George and Ira Gershwin, has been running at the Richard Rodgers Theater since January. And despite some mixed reviews and an early controversy, set off by Stephen Sondheim over proposed changes to the original script and score, the public has flocked to see it. In February, the producers extended the play’s original 26-week run to the end of September. Now that run has been extended “indefinitely.” This month, “Porgy and Bess” won 10 Tony Award nominations—including best revival of a musical, best director (Diane Paulus), best actress and best actor. That means the play will likely attract still more theatergoers and experience a second, well-deserved boost at the box office.

It is a good thing the public didn’t let the critics keep them away. Too many critics had compared the musical with the opera and found the musical lacking. But for lovers of musicals, a separate genre with a different kind of audience, and for theatergoers in general, many of whom have never seen or heard the three-hour original, this production of the American composer’s landmark is both rich and rewarding. (I myself have never seen the opera, but would seek it out now after having seen this musical version.)

The play places several of Gershwin’s beloved songs (“Summertime,” “I Got Plenty of Nuttin,” “I Loves You Porgy” and “It Ain’t Necessarily So”) into an unforgettable story of love, temptation and redemption.

Porgy (Norm Lewis), a man disabled from birth, loves Bess (Audra McDonald), a drug-addict who needs all the love and community she can get if she is ever to escape the horrendous choices that confront her at every turn: virtual enslavement to a brutal stevedore, Crown (Philip Boykin), or prostitution through a drug dealing pimp, Sporting Life (David Alan Grier). Christians and Jews will see in the plot the biblical story of Hosea repeatedly rescuing his unfaithful love, Gomer, from prostitution, which itself is a metaphor for God’s persistent love and outreach to humanity. The twist in this play is that the “cripple,” as they call Porgy, is the strongest character on stage, and it is his love that has the power to overcome evil and possibly save Bess.

The main characters, plus a couple of minor characters who also have significant songs and roles, are part of an African-American community called Catfish Row, a poor fishing village in Charleston, N.C. This community copes collectively with poverty, racial discrimination, dangerous employment and few prospects for a better life, as well as the drug dealers, prostitutes and violent men among its ranks. This community furnishes a tight-knit bond, full of faith, family and a little bit of fun, though at first the women shun Bess as beneath them.

The combination of story and music is enough to make any production of “Porgy and Bess” worth seeing. But the acting and singing in this production make it moving throughout, and in a couple of scenes, unforgettable. Audra McDonald has been universally acclaimed in her role as Bess, making this “lost” soul a sympathetic character, someone weakened by subjugation and violence and with no one to trust. In one riveting scene, Crown picks her up and all but rapes her onstage; the attraction and revulsion between them is palpable. There are gentle moments between Bess and Porgy, though tension as well, when Porgy tells Bess she has to choose her man. Porgy, who does not have the operatic voice of Bess or Crown, does have passion, earnestness and love, grown strong through suffering, and enough of it to combat and convincingly overcome evil. 

Although this story is set in an African-American community before the civil rights and feminist movements, the story of suffering, temptation and the search for redemption has universal appeal. One sees on stage the power, and limits, of love as a healing force able to offer people at the bottom of society a different future, a second chance at life.

George Trejos
4 years 11 months ago
I saw Porgy & Bess and Jesus Christ Superstar a few weeks back. While JC Superstar, was better attended and received, I did enjoy Porgy and Bess better on a personal level. While Porgy did not get the girl in the end, he and his community of Catfish Row are better off for their experience of love and acceptance. I can not help but hope that Bess was equally affected by the same openness at a deeper level. Life is not always assured of happy endings but certainly is steeped with hope. The journey is as important as the outcome which remains unwritten.
C Walter Mattingly
4 years 11 months ago

Karen Smith,

My wife and I having recently visited New York for the first time in some years to see our daughter in the premier of a new opera, we had time to catch a Broadway show. Our choice came down to "Porgy and Bess" and the stage adaptation of Greg Hansard's totally charming and uplifting film, "Once." We chose the latter. It too concerns itself with the challenges of a love relationship, this time between a struggling musician/hoover repairman and an immigrant young Check woman separated from her husband, who remained behind.  Unlike Porgy and Bess, they suffer not from social inequity or physical disabilities, but rather the trials and angst of urban life, in circumstances raising issues both contemporary and eternal. The story, primarily through the medium of song, involves working out relational problems of marital and personal loyalties. It is an unsentimental affirmation of both fraternal and marital love and their obligations and potential to redeem.
"Once," it turns out, is also the current major competition for "Porgy and Bess" for Tony awards. It is heart-warming that these two productions, African-American and Irish, native and immigrant, are paired side by side on Broadway, as were the two suffering immigrant cultures in the 19th century, with the slave ships losing an estimated 10% of their cargo on the sorrowful voyages from West Africa to the US, and the coffin ships an estimated 20% of their cargo on their journeys to the US from the west coast of Ireland. They blended once to form the great American contribution to the arts, jazz dance, song, and music, and they come together again here on the current Broadway stage to win us over yet again.

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Death-row inmate Ledell Lee. A ruling from the state Supreme Court allowing officials to use a lethal injection drug that a supplier says was misleadingly obtained cleared the way for Arkansas to execute Ledell Lee on Thursday, April 20, 2017, although he still had pending requests for reprieve. (Arkansas Department of Correction via AP)
To take Holy Communion in the face of death is to say that it is fellowship, and not food, that matters most.
Terrance KleinApril 26, 2017
A man rides a bicycle past a billboard with an image of Pope Francis April 26 ahead of the pontiff's April 28-29 visit to Cairo. (CNS photo/Amr Abdallah Dalsh, Reuters)
“Peace be with you” was the message of the Risen Jesus to his disciples on the first Easter, and it is the message Francis will bring to the Muslim and Christian communities in this land.
Gerard O'ConnellApril 26, 2017
Pope Francis is presented with a football helmet by Michigan football team coach Jim Harbaugh during the weekly general audience at the Vatican, Wednesday, April 26, 2017. (L'Osservatore Romano/Pool Photo via AP)
Coach Jim Harbaugh presented a custom Wolverines helmet and a pair of Nike Air Jordan sneakers to Pope Francis.
Michael J. O'LoughlinApril 26, 2017
The 'Hamlet'-inspired play made the playwright Tom Stoppard an overnight sensation.
David StewartApril 26, 2017