• Subscribe
  • Log in
  • My Account
  • Politics
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • International
    • U.S. Politics
  • Culture
    • Books
    • Film
    • TV
    • Ideas
  • Faith
    • Faith in Focus
    • Faith and Reason
    • Prayer
    • Spirituality
    • Jesuitical Podcast
  • Vatican
    • Vatican Dispatch
    • Vatican News
    • Pope Leo XIV
    • Inside the Vatican Podcast
  • Scripture
    • Scripture Reflections
    • The Word
    • The Good Word
    • Preach Podcast
  • Podcasts
    • The Spiritual Life
    • Jesuitical
    • Inside the Vatican
    • Preach
    • Hark!
    • All Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • All issues
  • Donate

Sections

  • Politics
  • Faith
  • Culture
  • Vatican
  • Scripture
  • Podcasts

More from America

  • Podcasts
  • Video
  • Newsletters
  • Events
  • Voices
  • YouTube
  • Mobile App
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

Print Edition

December 2026

December 2026

Past Issues

December 2026

Current Issue
  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Sections

  • Politics
  • Faith
  • Culture
  • Vatican
  • Scripture
  • Podcasts

More from America

  • Podcasts
  • Video
  • Newsletters
  • Events
  • Voices
  • YouTube
  • Mobile App
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

Print Edition

December 2026

December 2026

Past Issues

December 2026

Current Issue
  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
Skip to content
  • Donate
America Magazine

America Magazine

The Jesuit Review

  • Subscribe
  • Log in
  • My Account
Subscribe
  • Politics
    • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • International
    • U.S. Politics
  • Culture
    • Books
    • Film
    • TV
    • Ideas
  • Faith
    • Faith in Focus
    • Faith and Reason
    • Prayer
    • Spirituality
    • Jesuitical Podcast
  • Vatican
    • Vatican Dispatch
    • Vatican News
    • Pope Leo XIV
    • Inside the Vatican Podcast
  • Scripture
    • Scripture Reflections
    • The Word
    • The Good Word
    • Preach Podcast
  • Podcasts
    • The Spiritual Life
    • Jesuitical
    • Inside the Vatican
    • Preach
    • Hark!
    • All Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • All issues
Posted inDispatches, Politics & Society

Cardinal Rodriguez: On the need to question capitalism

Jim McDermott by Jim McDermott January 23, 2015

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
View of Vidigal, revitalized slum of Rio de Janiero
A view of Vidigal, a revitalized slum of Rio de Janiero.

Cardinal Oscar Rodriguez Maradiaga during the Q&A following his January 20th talk on “The Meaning of Mercy” at Santa Clara University.

INTERLOCUTOR: In the face of what you have said this evening and other times and what Pope Francis has said that so much today of the global economy is an economy that kills, an economy driven by idolatry, I wonder if you could comment more on those views, which have generated strong opposition in the United States among some listeners.

Well you know opposition isn’t bad in itself, because people can think diversely. The problem is when there is no option for dialogue, for serene dialogue. When you are in a position, like in a trench, defending your way of thinking not even questioning if it is right or not. This is the wrong way of approaching the problems. I believe that of course it is necessary to dialogue.

Nobody says that there is a perfect economic system in the world. And that some systems have defects, this is clear. If an economic system is producing an increasing inequality, should that be the best? It’s necessary to question, Why? And this is why sometimes what has been called in the social doctrine of the Catholic Church “savage capitalism,” it is not only a qualification, it’s true, when you see the results. When you see that poverty instead of diminishing is increasing, it means that something goes wrong. When you see that for instance in one developed country of Europe, there are eight million poor, something is not working. And it’s necessary to question that.

So when the pope talks in “Evangelii Gaudium” that this economy kills, it’s not only to say, Oh he comes from the Third World, he comes from Argentina, he doesn’t know the United States, for instance. It’s not a matter of fact. It’s to go objectively to the situation and to the results, and of course this kind of marginalization and leaving the poor to their own destiny kills. And if a system is killing, it’s necessary to correct it.

And this is why I believe the pope is promoting, sometimes provoking the reaction. Not to globalize, as he said in Lampedusa, not globalizing indifference, because this is one of the illnesses of today, indifference. “Okay, there are people dying in Iran, for four years now in a war? Who cares. It’s their problem.” Globalization of indifference.

We should be concerned, all the baptized, concerned by any war in the world. We cannot be indifferent. It’s necessary of course to be concerned about this.

What is my answer to this? Okay, We need to keep dialoguing. I remember eight years dialogue I was participating in with the people of the IMF, of the World Bank, of the Inter-American Development Bank, in order to have the alleviation of the external debt of the poorest countries. At the beginning they said, You priest have nothing to say to us of the work of the economy! After that, finally, in Gleneagles the achievement came, and the external debt of the 26 poorest countries was cancelled. Dialogue is the way to go. And it’s necessary to dialogue in order to correct the defects or illnesses of the economic situation of the world nowadays.  

An economy that is reduced to speculation—this is one of the causes of the big crisis—an economy that is reduced not to thinking in the common good, but only thinking in the good of small groups—people who are becoming every day richer and richer and the difference between those who have most even though that they will never be able to expend. Accumulating riches, for what? Only when death comes, what happens to these big fortunes are causes of terrible fights, legal fights and battles—this is really nonsense. Economy is to make the life more human, more livable. And when economy is only trying to accumulate goods, it’s something ill inside.

So it’s necessary to question. When the Pope is denouncing something, it is not because he is against, no, it is because he wants something better, and it is necessary with dialogue to look. There is no perfect system, as I said, but it’s necessary to question, question when things go wrong, in order to make them go better.  

The full video of his talk at Santa Clara can be found here. This question can be found at 50:30. 

 

Related

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window)X
  • Share on Mail (Opens in new window)Mail
Tagged: Catholic Social Teaching, Economics, Social Justice
Jim McDermott

Jim McDermott

Jim McDermott writes about pop culture at jimmcdermott.substack.

More by Jim McDermott

More from America


On an emotional day in Chiclayo, Pope Leo entrusts his ministry to the Virgin Mary

On an emotional day in Chiclayo, Pope Leo entrusts his ministry to the Virgin Mary

Pope Leo at Catholic university in Peru: ‘Science without a conscience ruins everyone’s life’

Pope Leo at Catholic university in Peru: ‘Science without a conscience ruins everyone’s life’

Will Pope Leo’s call for universal health care be heard in the U.S.?

Will Pope Leo’s call for universal health care be heard in the U.S.?

Classifieds

Your source for jobs, books, retreats, and much more.


  • Development & Operations Associate – Commonweal NYC
  • Catholic Theological Union
  • Bridging English and Culture Studies to Priestly Formation
  • Accompanying Men of All Ages Through Formation
  • Bilingual Director of Religious Education

See all classifieds

Most Popular


Norm Macdonald’s wayward search for spiritual truth
She was in a convent. Now she’s an opera star.
Pope Leo’s joyous return home to Chiclayo
Leo’s ‘masterclass’ in helping Argentina love a new pope
Voters chose four new Catholic governors on Election Day. Does their faith matter? 

America Today

Your daily guide to the most important stories from the Church and around the world - delivered to your inbox each morning. See more newsletters

December 2026

December 2026

Faith. Culture. Perspective

Support a trusted Catholic voice at the intersection of the Church and the world.

Subscribe

Politics

See all


Voters chose four new Catholic governors on Election Day. Does their faith matter? 

How Latino Catholics helped flip the Texas border for Democrats 

Is it time for A.I. to slow down or speed up?

Faith

See all


A Brewers fan on the World Series—and what it has to do with ‘Fratelli Tutti’

What blessed Stanley Rother and Pope Leo XIV share

To understand Christian hospitality, look to the host

Culture

See all


She was in a convent. Now she’s an opera star.

Finding a Lenten vulnerability in Rilke’s ‘Letters to a Young Poet’ 

Review: The ‘Scopes Monkey Trial’ and church-state tensions

Vatican

See all


On voting, can Pope Leo have ‘the best of both worlds’?

Two Bobs from the Midwest: When Bob Dylan met Pope Leo

Pope Leo warns economic inequality threatens peace, urges politicians to serve common good

Scripture

See all


Leadership lessons from shepherds

Be hot or cold, not lukewarm

Unpacking our lives

Podcasts

See all


How Pope Leo transcended Argentina’s political rift

The bishop for Silicon Valley on A.I. and how Catholics should respond

Your friends don’t need your sympathy—they need your compassion

Sections

  • Faith
  • Culture
  • Scripture
  • Politics
  • Vatican
  • Podcast

About America

  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Writing Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Jesuit Vocations

More

  • Donate
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Classifieds Directory

America Today

Your daily guide to the most important stories from the Church and around the world - delivered to your inbox each morning. See more newsletters

Sign up
  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
© 2026 America Press Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Powered by Newspack
  • Donate

Gift this article