Fr. James Martin on Charlottesville: "White supremacy is the opposite of Jesus' message"

Fr. James Martin on Charlottesville: "White supremacy is the opposite of Jesus' message"
Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
janet macdonald
4 months ago

And what is it when the black movement spews such vitriol? Or the alt-left? Is any of this insane hatred mirroring Jesus' message?

Robert Killoren
4 months ago

I am sorry but saying Black Lives Matter is nothing like calling for the repression of minorities, the persecution of Jews and Muslems and advocating killing black people.

Advertisement
James Haraldson
4 months ago

So calling for the killing of cops and celebrating the murder of cops as the Black Lives Matter movement has done repeatedly is nothing evil?

Robert Killoren
4 months ago

Of course not, violence and murder are sin and evil no matter who is involved. However, BLM advocates the equality of a race. White supremacy advocates the superiority of a race. That's a significant difference. One promotes the ideals of America that "all men are created equal"; the other does not.

Beth Cioffoletti
4 months ago

This is what is called "whataboutism". Whenever a valid criticism is raised, the response is to evade it by asking about something else.

Robert Killoren
4 months ago

Fr Jim,
I am really concerned about comments posted on Catholic media reports on Charlottesville. They are saying it was no big deal and thus are defending Trump's initial weak response to white supremacists, racists, and neo-nazis. The tone is definitely alt-right and militant Catholic. What's happening? I feel I've entered an alternate reality.

James Haraldson
4 months ago

Name one person who said it was "no big deal." The alternate reality is your own. There was no "weak" response by Trump. He is under no obligation to indulge himself by stating the obvious about racism. He was right to include the hatred of left wingers in his condemnation. What exactly is the "tone" of a militant Catholic? Are you seriously trying to associate the heroic virtue of loyal Catholics with those of hate groups? If so, you live in no sort of reality at all.

Roy Fanthome
4 months ago

Thank you father Jim. I am surprised that for all the comments on the cold blooded ramming of the car that killed one and injured so many ... no one has yet called it an act of terrorism. I know the press in the UK would have done so if it had happened in that country.

Christopher McNally
4 months ago

Thank you for the lesson. The idea of racial supremacy, or any other form of supremacy of one person or group, violates this founding principle: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal." It is bitterly ironic that people would choose to gather in the home city of the author of the Declaration of Independence and the Statute of Virginia for Religious Freedom, and the Father of the University of Virginia, to rally for principles that Thomas Jefferson, if he were alive today, would denounce and abhor. Even acknowledging his practice of slavery, his sexual abuse of his female slaves, and his use of the word "men," Jefferson was troubled by slavery, he educated his daughters, and he was tolerant of other religions and rejected religious tests. For his day he was an enlightened man and I, for one, am confident that if he were alive today he would have an open mind and reject supremacist ideas in favor or equality.

Henry George
4 months ago

Chris,
How do you know Jefferson would do those things if he were alive today.
What would lead him to such a change in heart ?
Don't you know the Alt-Left is going to demand the removal of Jefferson image and name where-ever the can ?

Rick Cortright
4 months ago

We agree on this one Fr. Martin. Each of these groups is reprehensible. As are the media who fanned the flames and the violent anti-speech Antifa (anti-fascist group) who went there with the intention of initiating violence. They are all at fault.

Henry George
4 months ago

If the Police had kept the two groups of extremists separate,
perhaps none of this would have happened.

All together too much is being made of this tragic incident
in that neither group has much of a following and neither group
is going to take over America.

Stop giving them so much news coverage as that is what they feed on.

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Fr. Carlos Francis Méndez led his parish into action after bringing his sorrow about the hurricane devastation into prayer.
America FilmsDecember 08, 2017
Join America Media as Cardinal Timothy M. Dolan blesses our new headquarters on the Avenue of the Americas.
America FilmsDecember 01, 2017
Students from Sagrado Corazón University distribute supplies around Puerto Rico.
America FilmsNovember 30, 2017
In a highly-anticipated speech in Myanmar, Pope Francis did not mention Rohingya Muslims by name but indirectly showed support for them.
America FilmsNovember 28, 2017