As a long-time student of theology, I, like many people, have been preoccupied with the problem of evil. Very often, theologians will point out that most of the evil we witness in life is a direct consequence or reflection of sin. In other words, people freely make decisions that are selfish, exploitative and sometimes downright malicious, which creates ripple effects of suffering. It is, therefore, not God, but us who cause our suffering.
However, this doesn’t solve the problem of “natural evil,” a term used to describe naturally occurring events like hurricanes, tornadoes, fires, floods, tsunamis and congenital diseases. Our guest on this week’s episode of “The Spiritual Life with Fr. James Martin, S.J.” grappled firsthand with this reality as the governor of Kentucky when historic floods swept across the state in 2022. Andy Beshear, a devout Christian, called the floods, “about as close to biblical as you can get.” Together, he and Father Martin discuss the spiritual challenges of facing catastrophe and how the beauty of humanity shines forth in our love of neighbor in the most difficult circumstances.
In our spiritual lives, it’s worth asking: How could a God who loves us allow such atrocities? It is a question that haunted me every time I read the news, until one day, the place I call home was hit by a Category 4 hurricane and became the news.
In late September 2024, Hurricane Helene struck the southeastern United States, including my adopted home state, North Carolina. Historic rainfall caused several rivers and the usually small mountain streams that feed into them to flood. Asheville’s River Arts District was completely submerged, destroying artists’ studios and wiping away restaurants, breweries and coffee shops that were well-loved jewels of this mountain town. Those in more secluded, rural parts of the county were trapped by rising flood waters and forced to climb onto their roofs, cling to tree branches or wade through perilous waters. I am still haunted by the story of a young family who were all swept away in their attempt to escape.
I was extremely lucky. Although my home is surrounded by a forest of tall pines, which creaked and swayed for four terrifying hours, not one tree fell on my house. When the winds died down, my neighbors came out of their homes with chainsaws to clear our road of at least eight fallen trees, including one that landed across my driveway. It wasn’t just my neighborhood. Everywhere I went in the county, there were people offering up what they could. On the sidewalks, people filled big coolers with water bottles. Someone opened the gates to their backyard pool so neighbors could fill buckets of water to flush their toilets. No restaurants were open, but some of their owners hauled propane stoves out to the streets where they served food and did not ask for a dime. And these are the things I personally witnessed, without internet, social media or any clue what was happening throughout the region. I would later hear countless stories of nonprofits, like Beloved Asheville, rushing to the most vulnerable—those living on the streets, in trailer homes and low-lying places—to meet basic human needs.
As someone who has spent most of her life agonizing over the question of where God is when natural disasters occur, I felt no such anxiety. It was weeks before the physical toll of adrenaline and stress left my body, but I no longer suffered theological distress over natural evil. What cured me? It was, quite simply, feeling the overwhelming love of God in the goodness of my neighbors. I did not have to wonder “Where was God?” because I could see God so plainly in the selflessness of those around me. Ultimately, living through a natural disaster taught me that these events do not reveal who God is; they reveal who we are. For all our flaws, what I saw is that most of us want to be helpful; we consider the needs of others before our own; many of us have hidden talents—like wielding chainsaws!—and will stay long after the wreckage to help people rebuild. In a way, we do get to see God in natural disasters—not as the cause but as the love that rushes in to clean, carry and comfort. And as for ourselves, we get to see what it really means to be made in the image of God.
Father Martin’s conversation with Andy Beshear brings this to light in a beautiful way. In a time of political polarization and tribalized suspicion, Gov. Beshear presents a more humble, self-reflective leadership, rooted in his Christian belief that we are all children of a loving God and so ought to “go and do likewise.”
