These quotes in a recent article in The Atlantic, “The People Who Outsource Emotional Labor to AI,” left me flabbergasted:

Franky’s impulse was to write back: “You’re a liar. You’ve always been a liar. All you do is lie.” Instead, she asked an AI program to write a response that was less “condescending and unnecessarily emotional.” […]

A father in Arizona told ChatGPT to use a “five-star-hotel-clerk tone” [to text] his ex, and it did—to the point that, reading over his shoulder, his child was shocked by how nice their parents were being to each other.

Chat, we’ve lost the plot. (For the non-Gen Zers: Houston, we have a problem.)

Does no one know how to talk to each other anymore? Someone physically typed “use a five-star-hotel-clerk tone” into ChatGPT? They can’t be serious.

Well, they are serious, and that leaves me seriously concerned. But the Catholic social tradition has much to offer in the way of addressing this unsettling phenomenon. Its commitment to the dignity of the family and the family’s place in community life proves clarifying in these dizzying times.

The Pew Research Center reports that about half of U.S. adults use artificial intelligence chatbots, and Franky and the father in Arizona are not alone in using them to handle difficult family members. According to a September 2026 poll from Elon University, 27 percent of U.S. adults have used chatbots within the past six months for “personal, emotional, or social purposes.” That number rises to 40 percent among those under the age of 50. 

Why use a chatbot to write texts? Phrasing a message clearly, especially to a difficult relative, is tiring and time-consuming, and chatbots are helpful in curbing impulsive tendencies. Last year, Adrienne Matel wrote in The Guardian about a tech entrepreneur in Vancouver who used Claude to write a text to his friend whose mom had recently died, explaining, “As guys, sometimes we have trouble expressing our emotions.” It is a good thing when adults realize their texts may need some editing or are overly emotional (read: flaming). But asking a chatbot to course correct is not a socially sustainable solution.

Generative A.I. models often capitalize on our most human psychological vulnerabilities, including our tendency to surround ourselves with those we agree with. You have probably noticed this: Chatbots are programmed to flatter. A chatbot may not tell you that your text is inflammatory; that would run the risk of insulting you and losing your precious attention. Instead, it may rewrite your response (how generous!) and ask questions about how it can assist you with something else so that you keep using it. How sweet the lure of the agreeable echo chamber.

Here is the thing, though: Human relationships naturally produce friction and disagreement. Gemini can certainly give advice—even good advice—on how to deal with a grumpy boss in a work meeting or how to coax a 2-year-old away from the playground. But if we outsource the mental energy of communicating with disagreeable people, we naturally weaken our ability to communicate at all. And if we value our relationships, that should raise a red flag.

What can the Catholic social tradition offer for our moral deliberation on this issue? Its call to family and community demands authentic communication in the name of supporting and strengthening families. Pope Leo XIV, in “Magnifica Humanitas,” specifically locates the value of strong familial relationships in the broader context of social life: Families are “the fundamental and irreplaceable cell of every community organization,” he writes (No. 165). Such an image raises the stakes of interpersonal communication. If we cannot effectively communicate with those to whom we are related by blood, how might our broader social and political life suffer? (Have you seen the state of the American political climate?)

Leo’s writing on the importance of family life builds on what Pope Francis wrote 10 years ago in “The Joy of Love” (“Amoris Laetitia”). Francis warns of the suffocating threat of narcissism in relationships modeled after online interactions, narcissism that “makes people incapable of looking beyond themselves, beyond their own desires and needs” (No. 39). You can’t exactly unfriend someone in real life, at least not as quickly as you can online.

Francis does not mince words: “We treat affective relationships the way we treat material objects and the environment: everything is disposable; everyone uses and throws away, takes and breaks, exploits and squeezes to the last drop. Then, goodbye.” His argument distills how an individualist culture encourages a certain kind of corner-cutting cognitive offloading, the same kind that is present in deciding whether to use A.I. to write texts. If we cannot bother to spend five minutes rephrasing our words and calmly respond to Aunt Carol’s nastygram (apologies to any Aunt Carols out there) rather than relying on a chatbot to take the wheel, what does that say about our own narcissistic habits? (Aunt Carol is not off the hook here. She should be checking herself if she’s sending nastygrams in the first place.)

I don’t think it is inappropriate to frame this reality in terms of sin language. The theologian and frequent America contributor James Keenan, S.J., defines sin as “the failure to bother to love.” I would argue that failing to bother to think and care and communicate authentically, without the crutch of ChatGPT, is constitutive of failing to bother to love. To love another is to realize that the silence, the awkwardness, the stumbling are all part of the process.

As Francis also writes in “Fratelli Tutti,” citing Karl Rahner, S.J., “man always has to take up the challenge of moving beyond himself” (No. 88). This wisdom is underpinned by the most fundamental image of what it means to be human in the Catholic tradition. We are made as sacred and social creatures, made to be in relationship. 

It should be said: Some relationships can become overwhelmingly strenuous and require cutting off mutual contact. Declaring that we are made for relationship is not to dismiss these cases or impose a standard that causes additional harm; rather, it is to encourage resilience in the push and pull that is the foundation of what it means to be social.

At its core, the decision of whether to use A.I. to text your family is not merely an issue of convenience but rather one about what we value about being human.

So I implore you: Do the hard work. If that means taking 24 hours before replying to Aunt Carol in order to clear your mind, take the 24 hours. If it is really necessary for someone else to intervene, ask a friend for advice. The way we communicate defines how we live as relational beings. We can’t afford to outsource that.

Molly Wysocki is an O'Hare Fellow at America Media.