Tough questions in Oakland

National Catholic Reporter offers a detailed look at an emerging controversy in the Diocese of Oakland involving a national association that offers pastoral support to gay and lesbian Catholics, and a bishop’s quest to assess its Catholicity. From NCR:

Following a more than yearlong investigation into the group's "adherence to the fullness of Catholic teaching," the future of a national association of ministries to gay and lesbian Catholics is uncertain because its board members refused to sign an "oath of personal integrity" to Catholic teaching given to them by the local bishop.

Advertisement

Declining the oath could result in Bishop Salvatore Cordileone of Oakland, Calif., declaring the Catholic Association for Lesbian and Gay Ministry, or CALGM, as "not authentically Catholic," a letter to its members from the association president warns.

"In good faith, we have done most everything required of us to maintain a legitimate space within the boundaries of the institutional Church," president Sheila Nelson wrote to members April 5. "Yet, this has not seemed to be adequate or satisfactory to the office of the bishop. We have repeatedly, abundantly and humbly submitted that our work is pastoral in nature and not political or primarily doctrinal."

Bishop Cordileone has not released a formal statement on the situation, but NCR notes that among the challenges he sees with CALGM are:

the omission of specific church documents on its website and publications; its use of the terms gay and lesbian; members' statements deemed critical of the church; and the backgrounds, affiliations and public statements of both conference speakers and board members.

I admit that I was a bit taken aback by the candid language CALGM uses on its website. Many Catholic organizations, whether official or not, usually shy away from even naming gays and lesbians as such, sometimes opting for the condescending and charged term, homosexuals. Does the bishop’s suggestion that employing the words gay and lesbian openly may forfeit Catholic identity suggest that even recognizing these men and women exist is now verboten? Is there room for dissent? Are issues of sexuality closed off to internal debate?

The president of CALGM said that members of the group have tried to work within acceptable pastoral bounds, but seems skittish about having to sign an “oath of personal integrity.” Should employees and members of Catholic organizations be subjected to fidelity oaths? Should priests and bishops? How would these be enforced, and what would the consequences be?  

Perhaps tenuous, might there be similarities between the situation in Oakland, and the ongoing controversy with US nuns and the Vatican? Might it be that in both cases, church leaders feel they are losing control over people (nuns) and issues (gay rights), and are perhaps attempting to gain it back through heavy-handed expressions of authority? If so, will this method of management and leadership succeed? Does it affect the image of the church in negative ways, or simply remind Catholics who leads?

I’ve asked many difficult questions, and I’m afraid I’m at a loss for answers. But there are gay and lesbian Catholics who remain in the church, and sometimes it feels as if the church does not welcome a continued presence.  Requiring signed fidelity oaths from those who are not be able to sign them in good conscience is perhaps a quick way to root out the opposition, but human beings in need of pastoral care, the Gospel, and the sacraments may be harmed and further marginalized, an outcome that surely no Catholic desires.

A quick aside: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the Mormons, is struggling with issues surrounding same-sex marriage and gay rights in similar ways as the Catholic Church. A recent piece in the New York Times highlights some of the internal battles, which mirror those in the Catholic Church. Read it here.

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Rick Fueyo
5 years 3 months ago
I hope we can get to the point where we can accept of gay and lesbian brothers and sisters.  It's only just. 
Jim McCrea
5 years 3 months ago
"Many Catholic organizations, whether official or not, usually shy away from even naming gays and lesbians as such, sometimes opting for the condescending and charged term, homosexuals."

More's the pity and moral cowardice.

God bless CALGM.  If The Godfather comes down on them, they should simply move to another diocese and continue on with their EXCELLENT work.
Brendan McGrath
5 years 3 months ago
''Many Catholic organizations, whether official or not, usually shy away from even naming gays and lesbians as such, sometimes opting for the condescending and charged term, homosexuals.'' - I'm curious, why/how is the term ''homosexual,'' either as a noun or an adjective, a condescending or charged term?  Certainly ''heterosexual'' isn't seen that way. 

One positive thing, however slight - I've noticed that in Catholic parlance, care is taken to use ''homosexual'' as an adjective rather than a noun: i.e., documents speak not about ''homosexuals'' but rather ''homosexual persons,'' emphasizing the fundamental dignity of the human person, the fact that one's identity is not and cannot be reduced to sexual orientation, etc.

John Hayes
5 years 3 months ago
I admit that I was a bit taken aback by the candid language CALGM uses on its website

''Busted Halo'' is a Paulist website:

http://bustedhalo.com/

it's not especially directed to gays and lesbians, but try typing ''lesbian'', ''gay'', ''bisexual'', ''transgender'' or, even, ''queer''  into the search box and you'll see those terms used unselfconsciously, respectfully and effectively in articles there.

Being uptight about terms like that will keep you from communicating with the people you are trying to welcome and help.

Jim McCrea
5 years 3 months ago
"Being uptight about terms like that will keep you from communicating with the people you are trying to welcome and help."

And what makes you think The Godfather of Proposition 8 wants to welcome and help?

Advertisement

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Imtiaz Cajee, nephew of Ahmed Timol, poses with his book about the activist on Aug. 24 in the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria, South Africa. (AP Photo, File)
A judge has overturned a finding of suicide and ruled that Ahmed Timol was murdered by South Africa’s Security Police 45 years ago.
Anthony EganOctober 23, 2017
Activists with Planned Parenthood demonstrate in support of a pregnant 17-year-old being held in a Texas facility for unaccompanied immigrant children to obtain an abortion, outside of the Department of Health and Human Services in Washington, Friday, Oct. 20, 2017.
Texas bishops: "No one -- the government, private individuals or organizations -- should be forced to be complicit in abortion."
Catholic News ServiceOctober 23, 2017
It is time for the laity to speak out and act like true disciples of Christ in spreading the joy of the Gospel. 
Thomas J. ReeseOctober 23, 2017
Pope Francis speaks from the Vatican as he addresses Canadian youths in a video message that was included in a Salt and Light Television program on Oct. 22 (CNS photo/courtesy Holy See Press Office).
“The world, the church, are in need of courageous young people, who are not cowed in the face of difficulties," the pope said.
Michael J. O’LoughlinOctober 23, 2017