What Childish Gambino and Flannery O’Connor have in common

Image: RCAImage: RCA

Childish Gambino’s new music video for “This is America” begins as though it is an early entry for 2018 Song of the Summer. Unseen people sing at what sounds like some kind of beach party, while a guitar sits alone onscreen, waiting to join the fun.

As the guitarist arrives and starts playing, stronger voices crystallize the vibe with a sweetly mellow sound and message: “We just wanna party, party just for you.”

Advertisement

In just four minutes, “This is America” shuttles through an astonishing number of referents to both current affairs and black culture.

Meanwhile onscreen we pan to the still form of Gambino (a.k.a. actor and writer Donald Glover). Seemingly awoken by the bass beat, he slowly turns toward us and begins dancing.

Then he shoots the guitarist in the head, looks us in the eye and begins: “This is America.”

How to talk about this extraordinary piece of work? In just four minutes “This is America” shuttles through an astonishing number of referents to both current affairs and black culture, including gun violence, police shootings, school shootings, OK Go’s Rube Goldberg-style music videos, rap video thug and bling posing, urban riots, the 2015 Charleston, S.C., church shooting, gospel choirs, the gospel of prosperity, Jim Crow imagery, “Get Out,” lynchings, memes, Michael Jackson, viral dance videos and Glover’s former role as nerdy community college kid Troy Barnes on the TV show “Community.” All the while Glover mostly dances his way through an abandoned warehouse with happy school children as chaos ensues in the background, his eyes rarely leaving us.

Critics have talked about the piece in a similarly dizzying variety of ways. Rolling Stone’s Tre Johnson calls it “an upsettingly vivid illustration of the Faustian bargain that black America makes on a regular basis, trading our bodies for our expression and freedom.” And indeed at times every physical gesture and spoken line by Glover seems to offer another pose black performers are forced to take in order to, as the gospel choir sings, “Get your money, black man.” It is clearly no coincidence that Glover released the video at precisely the moment he was performing the song for the first time on “Saturday Night Live,” where he was also doing exactly the kinds of sketches he was indicting.

Jason Parnham at Wired likewise describes it as “a piece of trickster art that soundly rebukes the natural DNA of the protest song and constructs it into a freakish chronicle of imprisoned torment.” Doreen St. Félix at The New Yorker sees Glover “point[ing] to the absurdity of the celebrity worship that attends his fame.”

The video is the apotheosis of viral culture and its incessant reappropriation of images, events and ideas for ironic purposes.

In a way, the video is the apotheosis of viral culture and its incessant reappropriation of images, events and ideas for ironic purposes. Yet here the irony is leveled against that culture itself, the way that it flattens everything to a punchline. The so-called “meta” and “self-aware” prove to be just further mechanisms of self-delusion. Empathy and self-reflection have no place in the land of the GIF. The entertainment they offer is just another kind of slumber.

[Explore America's in-depth coverage of Gun Control.]

“The shortest definition of religion,” the German theologian Johann Baptist Metz famously wrote, is “interruption.” The French philosopher René Girard conceived of the crucifixion similarly, as an act that reveals once and for all the scapegoating violence at the foundation of civilization. “There is no culture without a tomb and no tomb without a culture,” Girard argues in Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World. “The above-ground tomb does not have to be invented. It is the pile of stones in which the victim of the unanimous stoning is buried. It is the first pyramid.”

Our awakening seems constantly to require violence of its own.

In the revelation of that violence, Girard posits, lies the possibility of our freedom from it. Yet paradoxically our awakening seems constantly to require violence of its own.

This is something that the great American Catholic writer Flannery O’Connor knew well and explored in a short story about an old woman on a car trip with her son and his family. Much of “A Good Man is Hard to Find” is a portrait of casual racism, misogyny and callousness, the woman and others around her commenting on the plight of others with cool disinterest. “Oh look at the cute little pickaninny,” she says of a naked black boy who waves at them as they drive past. “If I could paint, I’d paint that picture.”

Then suddenly a roadside accident brings the woman face to face with The Misfit, an almost mythical figure who has been haunting the countryside, killing people. As members of her family are led two by two away to the nearby woods, the woman insists he is a good man.

For Glover and O’Connor both, it is only through an experience of radical interruption is conversion to a life of discipleship even remotely possible.

Finally all alone, with The Misfit now wearing her son’s shirt and her death at hand, the woman suddenly sees this strange and tormented figure with genuine compassion. “Why you’re one of my babies,” she blurts out randomly. “You’re one of my own children!”

After killing her, The Misfit gives her an epitaph and us as well: “She would of been a good woman, if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life.”

No matter the example of Christ or the witness of journalists, activists and artists, the impulse to drown out the cries of society’s victims remains as seductive as a great meme. For Glover and O’Connor both, it is only through an experience of radical interruption—where the floor drops out on us and the rules by which we believe the world works are revealed to be convenient fictions—is conversion to a life of discipleship, the path of goodness, even remotely possible.

 

Since “This is America” dropped, people have pulled endless GIFs from it, many of Glover dancing happily, as though this really is a dance video and also some of the horrifying moments like the final shot of him running for his life. Meanwhile, others are remixing the video to upbeat summer songs. Don’t bother us with truth or suffering. We just want to party.

O’Connor, too, was well aware of the strength of our resistance to conversion even after a moment of revelation. “Some fun!” says one of The Misfit’s henchman after the woman’s brutal murder.

“‘Shut up, Bobby Lee,’ The Misfit said. ‘It’s no real pleasure in life.’”

Comments are automatically closed two weeks after an article's initial publication. See our comments policy for more.
Rhett Segall
6 months ago

I think "A Good Man is Hard to Find" unmasks a common center for evil in the grandmother and the "Misfit". It also references a common source of redemption, i.e., the Lord. I do not get a sense of revulsion from Flannery's story; on the contrary I get a sense of wakefulness and a hint of hope. On the other hand, with "This is America", despite its artistic charm, I do get a sense of revulsion. Revulsion to what? Violence and bigotry, surely, but also revulsion to the perpetrators of the violence, i.e, white America. The video seems without nuance. So unlike Flannery.

Theodore Seeber
6 months ago

How is white America responsible for a black man killing another black man? Stupid identity politics. Better yet, how is the bigotry against "white America" based on any reality at all? Why aren't people just people, neither black nor white, but rather children of God?

Rhett Segall
5 months 4 weeks ago

Fair enough. My thought put the video in the context of the killings by Dylann Roof of 9 African Americans. Thanks for the correction.

J Cosgrove
6 months ago

An obviously morally degenerate video but sanctioned because the people are talented and attractive to some and the music resonates. . The narrative which is a false one also will be used to generate sympathy.

If an attractive person commits a crime there will be sympathy for the person. The same crime by an unattractive person will create disdain for the person.

Tim O'Leary
6 months ago

I guess this is like the Yanny Laurel effect so the rage now. I cannot think this adds to our culture in any positive way, whereas FOC did bring so much, telling her horrifying stories against a morally conscious deeply Christian background. In this video, all I see is an ISIS-like assassination of a hooded black man and mowing down of a black choir - all black on black violence, all trivialized by dancing to inane vocals. I wonder if this video was made by the NRA, would it be as popular?

Theodore Seeber
6 months ago

The stupid part is that the suffering of identity politics groups of any type is largely self-inflicted these days. Nobody cares over a blind text terminal interface what you look like, what skin color you have, who you are sleeping with, or how you live. Telecommuting is the great equalizer; in the more educated professions you can end up being paid by people you never meet in person. And the best part of all? The same is true of people who TEACH those professions- online education is now cheaper than ever before with many courses even being offered for free.
There is no longer a reason to leave your house and put your body in danger to make money.

Carol Cox
5 months 4 weeks ago

Brilliant commentary on Childish Gambino. When I first saw This is America, I needed to take a step back as I wasn't sure what images were reeling through my mind. I watched it a number of times and each time it gained more power. I felt that it painted a true portrait of American society today. Donald Glover is a talented artist. Some images are difficult to assimilate; but, they are vivid and real.
Carol Cox

Judith Stadler
5 months 4 weeks ago

Thank you, Fr. McDermott, for sharing this:
"The French philosopher René Girard conceived of the crucifixion similarly, as an act that reveals once and for all the scapegoating violence at the foundation of civilization. 'There is no culture without a tomb and no tomb without a culture,' Girard argues in Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World. The above-ground tomb does not have to be invented. It is the pile of stones in which the victim of the unanimous stoning is buried. It is the first pyramid.”
The latest "pile of stones" are the many monuments and tombs erected in the 1920s by revisionist historians to honor the leaders of the Confederacy. Donald Glover's Childish Gambino hits us over the head with the same message that Mitch Landrieu tries to communicate in his book, In the Shadow of Statues: A White Southerner Confronts History.

Mandy Rose
5 months 3 weeks ago

....

Advertisement

The latest from america

San Francisco Archbishop Salvatore J. Cordileone speaks from the floor on Nov. 14 at the fall general assembly of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops in Baltimore. (CNS photo/Bob Roller) 
At the request of the Vatican, the U.S. bishops postponed a vote on a set of proposals aimed at holding themselves accountable over sexual abuse.
Michael J. O’LoughlinNovember 14, 2018
No single person can be trusted to wield power; therefore, power must be shared among many and policed by a legal system of checks and balances.
Matt Malone, S.J.November 14, 2018
We all share the belief that gun violence has no place in our society, nor does the hate that often precipitates the gun violence.
Lucia McBathNovember 14, 2018
In the life of every long-lived man and woman, the future flows into promise, then fades into peril and panic.
Terrance KleinNovember 14, 2018