"Make Poverty History": History?

As a statement of intention, "Make Poverty History" is hard to argue with. And it has proven over the course of years to be a rallying cry for people concerned about poverty in our world, particularly in the developing world. 

Yet the concrete goals being set by this popular catchphrase are hard to pin down.  In a piece today in Eureka Street, the Australian Jesuits' online magazine, writer Ben Coleridge argues that "poverty" is inadequate to the issues before us. 

Poverty is not a one dimensional affliction. Communities enduring poverty are almost always torn by multiple afflictions, for example, ethnic or class discrimination or corruption. A person in a poor community may not simply suffer from a lack of primary goods (food, shelter, healthcare), but also from various forms of discrimination or poor access to institutional protection. In India, for example there are on average 11 judges for every 1 million people.

More fruitful planning and action, he suggests, might come by thinking rather in terms of "justice".  "By making 'justice' the stated goal of the 'anti-poverty' movement, success would be measured not only by material outcomes, such as  the quantity of aid delivered or the number of schools opened, but by the impact made on people's lives."

Coleridge's point is well taken.  We're dealing with complex issues here.  And slogans by definition simply in order to focus attention.

But we are imaginative creatures; for better or worse, catchphrases and images and video shorts are important means of capturing and motivating us, particularly in this hyperstimulated deluge of messages within which we live.  

"Make Poverty History" may in fact be history;  but we'll only be well served if we create something else to take its place.

Check out Coleridge's full piece here.

 

Jim McDermott, SJ

Beth Cioffoletti
6 years 8 months ago
It is said that the English word "Justice" is thin broth compared to the Hebrew word for justice, "tsedaqah".  It is roughly translated as the very heart of God.

Don't miss the best from America

Sign up for our Newsletter to get the Jesuit perspective on news, faith and culture.

The latest from america

Muslim groups has raised nearly $75,000 in a crowdfunding campaign for the Chesed Shel Emeth Society cemetery in University City, Missouri.
La medicina de Jesucristo para el estrés no es unas vacaciones en la playa para volver a empezar. Sino un cambio profundo de actitud. Se llama confianza.
Juan Luis CalderónFebruary 23, 2017
Instinct, emotion, intuition—all those elements that make politics, well, politics—still matter.
Matt Malone, S.J.February 23, 2017
Yes, some people crossing the U.S.-Mexico border are breaking the law, but the law is also breaking them.
Sean CarrollFebruary 23, 2017